As someone who takes their sandwiches, deviled eggs, and potato salad seriously, I’ve always considered myself a bit of a mayo connoisseur. For years, I’ve remained loyal to one particular brand – the kind you shell out a few extra dollars for because you’re convinced it makes all the difference.
But recently, curiosity (and a dwindling grocery budget) led me on a mission: to blind taste test 9 popular mayonnaise brands and rank them from worst to best.
And let me tell you—I was not prepared for what I discovered.
Each was sampled on its own and then again spread on white bread, with crackers, and in a small potato salad. I judged on taste, texture, tang, and overall balance. So, let’s start!
9. Whole Foods 365 Mayonnaise
Whole Foods 365 Mayonnaise is a delightful surprise for those seeking quality on a budget. The texture is creamy, and it spreads effortlessly on sandwiches. The taste is subtly tangy with a rich, smooth finish that complements a variety of dishes. From potato salads to gourmet burgers, it adds a touch of sophistication without breaking the bank.
Many appreciate its straightforward ingredient list, which emphasizes quality and taste. For those who prioritize organic options, Whole Foods 365 offers a reliable choice. Why pay more when you can have this flavorful experience at a fraction of the cost?
8. Kraft Real Mayo
A true kitchen essential, Kraft Real Mayo brings a timeless quality to everyday meals. Renowned for its classic, crowd-pleasing taste, it strikes the perfect balance of flavor—ideal for everything from creamy coleslaw to a stacked turkey sandwich. Its thick, velvety texture clings just right, making it a picnic favorite that won’t slide or separate.
Rooted in Kraft’s long-standing reputation for reliability, this mayo carries a sense of nostalgic comfort. It’s the kind of staple that fits seamlessly into both casual lunches and celebratory spreads, offering the dependable quality generations of families have come to count on.
7. Trader Joe’s Organic Mayonnaise
Trader Joe’s Organic Mayonnaise is a gourmet delight for the health-conscious. Its organic certification ensures that only the finest ingredients go into every jar. The taste is fresh and clean, with a hint of lemon that adds brightness to salads and sandwiches.
Perfect for those who value natural ingredients, this mayo turns everyday meals into culinary experiences. Trader Joe’s commitment to quality makes this a standout option for those seeking flavor without compromise. Its versatility in the kitchen makes it a favorite among home chefs who appreciate a touch of elegance.
6. Best Foods Real Mayonnaise
There’s something undeniably satisfying about the smooth richness of Best Foods Real Mayonnaise. A trusted companion in kitchens for generations, it delivers consistent quality and a depth of flavor that elevates classics like deviled eggs and chicken salad to comfort-food status.
Its unmistakable taste brings a touch of tradition to every dish, blending effortlessly into both humble lunches and elaborate family dinners. What truly sets it apart is its versatility—it’s as at home in a quick sandwich as it is in a layered casserole. Best Foods Real Mayonnaise is more than just a condiment; it’s a reflection of home, history, and the recipes that bring us together.
5. Hellmann’s Real Mayonnaise
Hellmann’s Real Mayonnaise enjoys a reputation for being the gold standard in the mayo world. Its uniquely creamy taste is perfect for binding ingredients together in dishes like potato and egg salad.
Hellmann’s is known for its quality and consistency, earning a loyal following over the decades. Whether enhancing a sandwich or creating a dip, its rich, smooth flavor profile elevates your culinary creations. For those seeking reliability and great taste, Hellmann’s remains an unbeatable choice for any occasion.
4. Duke’s Mayonnaise
Bold, tangy, and unapologetically Southern—Duke’s Mayonnaise is more than just a spread; it’s a culinary cornerstone. Renowned for its sugar-free recipe and velvety texture, Duke’s adds a signature bite that elevates staples like coleslaw, pimento cheese, and deviled eggs.
Its devoted following isn’t just regional pride—it’s a testament to a flavor that’s stood strong for over a century. With each spoonful, Duke’s brings an unmistakable Southern charm to the table, transforming everyday meals into nostalgic favorites. It’s not just mayo—it’s a legacy born in the South and beloved nationwide.
3. Kewpie Japanese Mayonnaise
Kewpie Japanese Mayonnaise offers a unique twist with its creamy texture and umami flavor, thanks to the addition of rice vinegar and MSG. This mayo is a star in Japanese cuisine, perfect for drizzling over okonomiyaki or dipping tempura.
Its squeezable bottle makes it convenient to use, and its distinct taste elevates everyday dishes to gourmet levels. Kewpie’s innovative recipe has won over food enthusiasts around the world, making it a must-have for anyone looking to explore new flavors and culinary experiences.
2. Thomy Mayonnaise
With its luxurious, creamy texture, Thomy Mayonnaise stands as a testament to Swiss culinary excellence. This delightful condiment transforms ordinary sandwiches into gourmet masterpieces. The subtle hint of mustard adds a tantalizing zing, awakening your taste buds with every bite.
Unlike other brands, it maintains a balance of tang and richness, offering a versatile addition to various dishes. The jar’s charming design also adds a touch of elegance to any kitchen. Whether you’re a mayo aficionado or a curious foodie, Thomy Mayonnaise invites you to embrace a world of flavor and tradition.
1. Great Value Mayonnaise (Walmart)
Yes, Walmart’s store brand took the crown—and I still can’t believe it. This mayo was perfectly balanced: slightly tangy, ultra creamy, and incredibly satisfying. It didn’t overpower in recipes, blended beautifully, and stood its ground on a simple slice of white bread. At less than half the price of some others, it’s now my go-to.
Ideal for those who love to whip up quick meals, this mayonnaise adds a touch of satisfaction without the high price tag. It’s perfect for dressing salads or spreading on sandwiches, bringing deliciousness to every bite.
Have a favorite mayo I missed? Let me know – because this mayo journey is far from over.
Leave a comment