One of the most famous frozen pies in America started in 1948 with a woman baking pies in her kitchen. She sold them to local restaurants before her name ever reached a grocery store freezer.
I love that detail because it changes how I see that cold box in the frozen aisle. Somebody’s home recipe can grow into a pie you grab on a busy Tuesday.
Store-bought apple pie gets teased a lot, but it saves a lot of holidays too. Big warehouse pies, supermarket bakery pies, and freezer pies all play by different rules.
Some come ready to slice. Others need an hour in your oven first.
So which one belongs on your table? I wanted to sort them by what actually matters to you, like size, effort, and the kind of crowd you’re feeding.
Your fork deserves a smart choice, right?
1. Costco Kirkland Signature Apple Pie
Size is the first thing people talk about with this pie, and for good reason. It’s one of the largest apple pies you’ll find on a regular store shelf.
Costco sells it in its bakery section under the Kirkland Signature label. It tends to show up most around fall and the winter holidays, so availability can change by season and by warehouse.
Here’s why that matters to you. If you’re feeding a big family, a church potluck, or a crowd of cousins, one pie can stretch a long way.
You won’t need to buy three smaller pies and hope they match.
The trade-off is space. A pie this big needs room in your fridge and a sturdy spot on your counter.
Measure your fridge shelf before you shop, or you’ll be playing a game of leftover Tetris.
You also need a Costco membership to buy it in the store. If a friend has one, this is a great time to be extra nice to that friend.
Serving tip number one is simple. Use a long, sharp knife and wipe it between cuts for cleaner slices.
A wide pie server helps you lift pieces without the filling sliding off.
Warming it up is a nice touch too. A short stay in a low oven can bring back that just-baked feel before dessert.
Add a scoop of vanilla ice cream and your guests won’t ask where it came from.
This pie works best for big gatherings and folks who love leftovers. For a small household, you might end up eating pie for breakfast all week.
Honestly, there are worse problems to have.
2. Marie Callender’s Dutch Apple Pie
Crumb topping lovers, this one’s for you. A Dutch apple pie swaps the top crust for a sweet, crumbly layer that bakes up golden.
Marie Callender’s sells it in the frozen aisle at many grocery stores across the country. The brand traces back to Marie Callender, who began baking pies in California in 1948.
Since it’s frozen, you bake it at home. That means your kitchen gets that apple pie smell, which might be the best free bonus in dessert history.
Plan ahead, though. Baking a frozen pie takes a good chunk of time, so check the box directions before guests arrive.
Starting late is the fastest way to serve dessert at bedtime.
A baking sheet under the pie is a smart move. It catches drips and makes it easier to pull the pie out safely.
Your oven floor will thank you.
Why pick this one over a fresh bakery pie? You can keep it in your freezer for weeks and bake it whenever the mood strikes.
Surprise guests or a sudden craving won’t catch you empty-handed.
Let it cool before slicing. Hot filling runs everywhere, while a rested pie holds its shape better on the plate.
The brand also sells other apple styles, like a lattice apple pie. If your crowd argues about crust versus crumb, you can grab one of each and call it peace talks.
3. Publix Bakery Apple Pie
Grocery runs in the Southeast come with a sweet side quest. Publix bakeries sell apple pie right alongside their famous cakes and cookies.
Publix is a supermarket chain with stores in Florida, Georgia, the Carolinas, and several other Southern states. If you live near one, a pie can join your cart next to the milk and bread.
The big perk here is convenience. The pie comes baked, so you can bring it home and serve it the same night.
No oven timer, no flour on your shirt.
Holiday seasons get busy at grocery bakeries. Many Publix stores let you place bakery orders ahead of time, which can save you from a sad, empty shelf on Thanksgiving week.
Ask at your local bakery counter about what’s available. Pie choices can shift with the seasons, and the staff there will know their own lineup best.
For serving, a quick warm-up works wonders. A few minutes in the oven helps the crust feel fresh again.
Microwaves can make crust soggy, so skip them if you can.
This pie fits nicely into weeknight plans. Maybe it’s a birthday for someone who doesn’t like cake.
Maybe it’s just Wednesday and you need a win.
You can also dress it up easily. Try whipped cream, a drizzle of caramel sauce, or a sprinkle of cinnamon on top.
Small extras make a store pie feel like a real event.
4. Walmart Freshness Guaranteed Apple Pie
Budget-friendly dessert doesn’t have to feel like a sacrifice. Walmart’s Freshness Guaranteed line includes bakery apple pies at many of its stores.
With stores across the country, Walmart is often the easiest place to find a pie fast. For families in small towns, it might be the only big bakery section nearby.
The appeal is simple. You can grab dinner supplies, school snacks, and dessert in one trip.
That’s a lot of errands crossed off with one parking spot.
Store stock can vary from location to location. Some stores carry several pie sizes, while others may have fewer choices.
Checking the store app before you leave can save a wasted trip.
So who should pick this one? It’s great for casual dinners, school events, or nights when you need dessert without much fuss.
Nobody at a bake sale is checking pie pedigrees.
A few easy upgrades help a lot. Brush the top crust with a little melted butter and sprinkle on some sugar before a short warm-up.
You’ll get a shiny, bakery-style finish.
Leftovers keep best when covered. Wrap the pie well and store it according to the label directions.
Fresh pie stays fresh longer when it isn’t left open on the counter.
Got kids who like to help? Let them add toppings like whipped cream or a little cinnamon.
They’ll feel like chefs, and you’ll still skip the hard part.
5. Whole Foods Market Apple Pie
Label readers, gather around. Whole Foods Market is known for its ingredient standards, and that includes the food in its bakery cases.
The company keeps a list of ingredients it doesn’t allow in the foods it sells. If you like knowing what goes into your dessert, that list can bring some peace of mind.
Whole Foods bakeries often carry apple pie, especially during fall and the holidays. Selection depends on the store, so your local shop might offer a slightly different lineup.
Price usually runs higher than basic supermarket pies. Think of this pick as the one you bring when you want to impress your in-laws a little.
Holiday ordering is a big help here too. Whole Foods typically offers holiday meal and dessert ordering ahead of big dates.
Planning early means less stress and fewer frantic texts.
Got a guest with food needs? Read the label carefully or ask a team member about ingredients.
Allergies are serious, so it’s always smart to double-check.
Serving this pie can be simple. A little whipped cream or a slice of sharp cheddar on the side makes a classic combo.
Yes, cheese with apple pie is a real thing, and it’s surprisingly tasty.
Pick this one when ingredients matter as much as flavor to you. It’s also handy when you want a dessert that looks thoughtful without hours in the kitchen.
Your secret stays safe with us.
6. Kroger Bakery Apple Pie
Kroger might go by a different name in your town. The company runs stores under banners like Ralphs, Fred Meyer, King Soopers, and Smith’s.
That matters when you’re pie hunting. Many of these stores share Kroger’s bakery products, so a familiar apple pie could be closer than you think.
Kroger bakeries commonly stock apple pie, and the selection often grows around the holidays. Some stores may also carry pies under the Private Selection label, Kroger’s more upscale brand.
Checking the app or website before heading out is a smart habit. You can see what your nearest store carries and sometimes order ahead for pickup.
Less wandering, more eating.
Why choose a Kroger pie? It’s an easy middle ground between budget picks and fancy bakery buys.
You get a ready-to-serve dessert without hunting down a specialty shop.
Freshness tips apply here too. Look at the date on the package and pick the newest one on the shelf.
It’s a small step that makes a big difference.
Want to make it feel homemade? Serve slices on your nicest plates with warm caramel or a scoop of ice cream.
Presentation does half the work at most dinners.
A Kroger pie is great for potlucks and family dinners. It’s familiar, friendly, and easy to find in many parts of the country.
Sometimes the best dessert is the one you can actually get today.
7. Wegmans Apple Pie
Some shoppers treat Wegmans like a weekend outing. The grocery chain has a loyal following, and its bakery is part of that appeal.
Wegmans started in Rochester, New York, and now runs stores in several Eastern states. If one is near you, the bakery department is worth a stroll.
Apple pie is a regular bakery item at many Wegmans stores. During fall and the holidays, you may see extra pie choices pop up.
Wegmans also takes holiday orders in many seasons. Ordering ahead can help you skip the stress of finding an empty shelf on the busiest baking days of the year.
Think about timing when you buy. A pie picked up the day of your dinner will taste its freshest.
If you buy early, store it as the label suggests.
This pick is great for anyone who wants a grocery pie that feels a step up. It’s also handy if your store is already your weekly stop.
One trip, one pie, one happy table.
For a fun serving idea, set up a little topping bar. Put out whipped cream, ice cream, caramel, and cinnamon.
Guests can build their own slice, and you look like a hosting genius.
Is it the cheapest option on this list? Probably not.
But for a special meal, a trusted bakery pie can be worth the small splurge.
8. Trader Joe’s Apple Pie
Seasonal shopping turns pie hunting into a treasure hunt. Trader Joe’s is famous for rotating products, and baked goods often come and go with the calendar.
That means apple pie might be on the shelf one month and gone the next. Fall is usually the best time to look for apple desserts at Trader Joe’s.
Here’s a tip: ask a crew member. Trader Joe’s staff are known for being friendly, and they can tell you what’s in stock or coming soon at that store.
Products can change quickly, so don’t fall too hard for one item. If you find a pie you like, enjoy it while it lasts.
Next season may bring something new.
Why choose this store at all? Trader Joe’s prices are often reasonable, and the store layout is small and quick to shop.
You can be in and out before your ice cream melts in the car.
Pair your pie with other store finds. A tub of vanilla ice cream or a can of whipped cream turns a simple slice into a party.
Little extras make dessert feel bigger.
This pie suits people who love trying new things. If you’re the kind of shopper who checks the seasonal section first, you’ll feel right at home.
Just remember the golden rule of Trader Joe’s. If you see something you love, grab it now.
Waiting until next week can be a heartbreaking pie lesson.
Share this story
