M&M’s aren’t just a candy—they’re a crunchy, chocolatey, peanut-buttery, caramel-filled obsession. With so many flavors on the market, from timeless classics to wild seasonal creations, we decided to put them all to the test.
Some wowed us with their perfect balance of crunch and sweetness, while others left us questioning why they exist.
So, which M&M’s flavor is truly the best? And which ones should you skip? We ranked them all, from the most forgettable to the ultimate, can’t-stop-eating favorite.
14. Strawberries & Crème
Strawberries & Crème M&M’s promise a taste of summer in every bite. However, they miss the mark with an overwhelmingly sweet and artificial flavor.
The candy coating struggles to capture the freshness of real strawberries, making the experience less enjoyable for those who prefer a natural taste. Even though the idea seems appealing, the execution lacks balance, leaving a somewhat cloying aftertaste.
For those with a sweet tooth, this might hit the spot, but for others, it’s a reminder of candy past its prime.
13. Milk Chocolate
Milk Chocolate M&M’s are the epitome of the classic chocolate candy, offering a reliable but unremarkable experience. The sweet, creamy milk chocolate is encased in a colorful candy shell, delivering nostalgia with each crunch.
While dependable and beloved by many, when compared to its more adventurous counterparts, it can feel quite plain.
However, the simplicity of this flavor is its charm, making it a comforting choice for those who enjoy the classics without any frills. For some, it may lack excitement, but for others, it’s a timeless treat.
12. Easter Sundae
This candy flavor brings festive flair with pastel colors and a sweet flavor reminiscent of spring celebrations. The flavor profile, though cheerful, edges on artificial, perhaps trying too hard to capture holiday whimsy.
It’s a fun addition to any Easter basket, providing a burst of color and sweetness. However, the taste may not stand out, overshadowed by its visual appeal.
For those seeking novelty, this might delight, but it’s not a year-round favorite.
11. Toasty Holiday Peanut
Toasty Holiday Peanut M&M’s offer a warm, nutty twist on the traditional peanut variety. Infused with a hint of holiday spices, they provide a cozy alternative for the festive season.
The added warmth from the spices complements the peanut nicely, but it might not be compelling enough for a year-round staple. A nice holiday treat.
10. Holiday Mint
Holiday Mint M&M’s cater to mint lovers with their bold, refreshing taste.
Each candy delivers a punch of minty freshness encased in rich chocolate, making it a favorite for some. However, the mint can be overpowering, potentially off-putting to those with a milder palate.
For mint enthusiasts, they’re a delightful treat, but for others, the strong mint flavor might be too intense. A balance of mint and chocolate could broaden their appeal.
9. Pretzel
Pretzel M&M’s bring an intriguing combination of salty, crunchy, and sweet. The contrast between the crunchy pretzel center and the smooth chocolate coating is a delightful surprise. However, some might find them a bit lacking in chocolate, as the pretzel center dominates the palate.
Ideal for those who enjoy a more savory-sweet balance, they’re a playful twist on traditional M&M’s. While not for everyone, their unique texture and flavor profile make them a must-try for adventurous snackers.
8. Almond
Almond M&M’s offer a satisfying crunch enhanced by a nutty undertone. The almond adds a different texture compared to the classic Peanut M&M’s, making each bite a bit more substantial.
However, some might find them less satisfying due to the almond’s milder flavor, which can be overshadowed by the candy coating. While they might not replace the classic, they add variety to the M&M’s lineup.
7. Dark Chocolate
Dark Chocolate M&M’s are a rich, intense delight for those who appreciate the deeper flavors of chocolate. Each candy offers a robust cocoa flavor, making it a standout choice for dark chocolate aficionados.
A little goes a long way, making it a satisfying nibble for those special moments. Perfect for dark chocolate lovers.
6. Crunchy Cookie
Crunchy Cookie M&M’s introduce a playful texture with a mild cookie flavor. Each candy delivers a delightful crunch, though the cookie taste is subtle and sometimes overshadowed by the chocolate.
The overall experience is enjoyable, especially for those who appreciate texture. Ideal for cookie lovers who enjoy a twist in their candy, these are a fun treat to try.
5. Peanut
Peanut M&M’s are a timeless classic, offering a crunchy, salty-sweet experience that’s hard to beat. The combination of whole peanuts enveloped in chocolate and a candy shell creates an iconic snack that satisfies every time.
Loved by many for its simplicity and perfect balance, it’s a staple at parties and gatherings. While it lacks the novelty of new flavors, its consistency and reliability make it a perennial favorite. A classic that never disappoints.
4. Caramel Cold Brew
Caramel Cold Brew M&M’s bring the coffeehouse to your candy bowl.
The mix of caramel and coffee flavors creates a deliciously rich experience that caters to coffee lovers. Each candy delivers a harmonious blend, reminiscent of a caramel macchiato. While the coffee flavor is prominent, it doesn’t overpower, allowing the caramel’s sweetness to shine.
Perfect for a mid-afternoon treat, they offer a sophisticated twist on traditional candy. For those who love both coffee and caramel, these M&M’s are a match made in heaven. A delightful, grown-up candy choice.
3. Caramel
Caramel M&M’s are a chewy, sweet delight that marries the smoothness of chocolate with gooey caramel. Each bite offers a satisfying chew that complements the chocolate shell, making it a perfect combo for caramel lovers.
The balance of flavors is spot-on, providing a sweet treat that’s hard to resist. Ideal for those who enjoy a rich, decadent experience, Caramel M&M’s are a standout in the lineup.
2. Peanut Butter & Jelly
Peanut Butter & Jelly M&M’s are a surprising delight, capturing the essence of a classic sandwich in candy form. The berry flavor pairs wonderfully with the creamy peanut butter, offering a nostalgic taste that sparks joy. It’s a bold combination that works beautifully, providing a burst of flavor in every bite.
For those who grew up loving PB&J, these M&M’s are a fun, whimsical treat. While unconventional, they manage to bring a beloved childhood favorite to life in a new way.
1. Peanut Butter
Peanut Butter M&M’s are the pinnacle of creamy, chocolatey perfection.
Each candy delivers a harmonious blend of peanut butter and milk chocolate, creating a smooth, indulgent experience. The balance is flawless, making it a top choice for peanut butter aficionados.
Its rich, creamy texture sets it apart from other flavors, providing an irresistibly satisfying treat. For those who cherish the classic combination of chocolate and peanut butter, these M&M’s reign supreme. It’s a beloved favorite that continues to delight with every bite. Truly, the best of the best.
Leave a comment