Skip to Content

21 Things You Should Never Say When Ordering the Perfect Steak

When it comes to ordering steak, certain comments can make or break your dining experience. Whether you’re a seasoned steak lover or a curious newcomer, avoiding these common faux pas can ensure your meal is as enjoyable as possible.

1. “I’d Like The Steak Tartare Well Done”

1. I'd Like The Steak Tartare Well Done
© thekitchenwhitelaw

Imagine ordering a dish that’s traditionally raw and asking for it cooked. Steak tartare, a delightful assembly of finely minced raw beef, should never be requested well done. You might end up with a confused waiter or chef. This dish is cherished for its raw texture, allowing the flavors to shine without heat.

Asking for it well done defeats its very purpose. If you’re not comfortable with raw meat, consider choosing another dish. Embrace the culinary journey by understanding what each dish offers, ensuring you enjoy every bite as intended.

2. “Can You Heat Up The Blue Steak?”

2. Can You Heat Up The Blue Steak?
© bandbsteak

Blue steak, or a very rare steak, is a choice that celebrates the natural flavors of quality beef. Requesting it to be warmed changes its essence entirely. Rather than asking for it to be heated, consider selecting a different level of doneness.

The beauty of blue steak lies in its tender texture and pure taste. If you’re curious but unsure, ask for guidance on selecting a doneness level you’ll enjoy. This way, you respect the dish and the chef’s expertise while ensuring a pleasurable dining experience.

3. “I’d Like My Steak Done Medium Plus”

3. I'd Like My Steak Done Medium Plus
© yellowblissroad

Ordering ‘medium plus’ can lead to confusion. This term isn’t universally recognized, and chefs might be unsure how to meet your expectations. For clarity, it’s best to stick to the standard doneness levels: rare, medium rare, medium, medium well, and well done.

If you’re aiming for something between two levels, communicate clearly with your server. This helps ensure your steak is cooked to perfection, just the way you like it, without any misunderstandings or disappointments during your meal.

4. “I’d Never Drink White Wine With Steak”

4. I'd Never Drink White Wine With Steak
© Burnett Fine Foods

Pairing wine with steak traditionally leans toward reds, yet white wine can offer a refreshing alternative. Dismissing white wine outright means missing out on unique flavor combinations. A full-bodied white wine can complement certain cuts and preparations beautifully. Explore options like Chardonnay or Viognier, and let the sommelier guide you.

This open-minded approach not only enhances your dining experience but also broadens your culinary horizons. Remember, the perfect pairing is what tastes best to you, so don’t be afraid to experiment and enjoy.

5. “What’s Your Daily-Special Steak Today?”

5. What's Your Daily-Special Steak Today?
© osamilnyc

Daily specials are exciting, but in a steakhouse, the focus is usually on quality cuts that are consistently available. Asking for a special might suggest unfamiliarity with the menu. Instead, inquire about the chef’s recommended cut or preparation method.

This shows appreciation for the chef’s expertise and the restaurant’s offerings. You might discover a signature dish or seasonal ingredient that enhances your meal. Being open to suggestions can lead to a memorable dining experience, showcasing the best of what the steakhouse has to offer.

6. “Is This Steak Grass-Fed?”

6. Is This Steak Grass-Fed?
© gordonramsaybarandgrillph

Grass-fed beef is known for its distinct flavor and nutritional benefits. However, not all steaks in a restaurant may be grass-fed. While it’s good to be informed, asking this question at every turn can appear overly particular. If grass-fed is important to you, check the menu or ask once before ordering.

Understanding the differences in flavor profiles and choosing accordingly enhances your appreciation for the steak. It’s about enjoying what’s on your plate and trusting the restaurant to deliver quality, regardless of the beef’s origins.

7. “Can I Have A Vegetarian Option Instead?”

7. Can I Have A Vegetarian Option Instead?
© School Night Vegan

While many steakhouses offer vegetarian options, seeking them out in a steak-focused establishment may limit your experience. Embrace the venue’s specialty by exploring creative side dishes or appetizers, which might surprise you with their flavor and innovation. If you’re dining with meat-eaters, consider sharing plates to experience the steakhouse atmosphere.

Should you prefer strictly vegetarian fare, researching menu options beforehand ensures you find a dish that satisfies your dietary preferences while still enjoying the company and ambiance of a steakhouse dinner.

8. “What Steaks Are Trending Right Now?”

8. What Steaks Are Trending Right Now?
© jjratiganbrewingco

Dining on trends can seem appealing, yet when it comes to steak, classics often shine brightest. Instead of chasing trends, focus on enjoying a cut that suits your taste and the restaurant’s strengths. Quality steakhouses pride themselves on expertise and consistency rather than fleeting fads.

Ask the server about the house specialties or what the chef recommends. This approach guarantees a meal that’s delicious and memorable without succumbing to the whims of fleeting culinary trends. Enjoying a steak is about timeless flavors and personal preference.

9. “Bring Me A Salt Shaker”

9. Bring Me A Salt Shaker
© Forest Decor

Chefs take pride in seasoning their dishes perfectly. Asking for a salt shaker implies the dish isn’t to your liking before you even taste it. Instead, savor the flavors as presented. High-quality steaks are seasoned to enhance, not overshadow, their natural taste.

If you feel the need for extra seasoning, try the dish first and then request subtly. This respects the chef’s craft while ensuring your palate is satisfied. Remember, dining is not just about eating but appreciating the culinary journey crafted by the professionals.

10. “I’ll Take The Filet, But With Just A Few Changes”

10. I'll Take The Filet, But With Just A Few Changes
© m0mmyeats

Ordering a filet only to request several alterations can disrupt the balance of flavors intended by the chef. Each component, from seasoning to sides, is chosen to complement the dish. If you have specific preferences, discuss them with the server so they can guide you to a dish that naturally fits your tastes.

Such communication prevents misunderstandings and ensures a harmonious dining experience. By trusting the chef’s expertise, you allow yourself the opportunity to enjoy a meal crafted to perfection, tailored subtly to your preferences.

11. “Can You Make It Well Done?”

11. Can You Make It Well Done?
© charleyssteakhouse

Requesting a steak well-done can sometimes alter its intended flavor and tenderness. While personal preference is key, consider that well-done might diminish the juiciness and intricate flavors of quality beef. If you prefer less pink, try medium-well as a compromise.

This retains more moisture and flavor while achieving your desired doneness. Engaging with the server about your preferences can lead to suggestions that match your taste while respecting the quality of the steak. A well-cooked steak is about balance, ensuring satisfaction with every bite.

12. “I’ll Need Lots Of A1 Sauce With My Steak”

12. I'll Need Lots Of A1 Sauce With My Steak
© Food52

Sauce complements rather than masks the flavor of a well-prepared steak. Requesting heaps of A1 sauce might suggest dissatisfaction with the steak’s natural taste. Instead, consider tasting the steak as it is served first. High-quality cuts are meticulously seasoned and cooked to bring out their unique flavors.

If you prefer additional sauce, use it sparingly to enhance rather than overshadow the dish. This approach allows you to appreciate the craftsmanship of the steak while satisfying your personal taste preferences. Respect the chef’s work and the steak’s natural flavor.

13. “Does The Chef Know How To Cook Steak?”

13. Does The Chef Know How To Cook Steak?
© chef.uri.elbaum

Questioning the chef’s skill in a steakhouse can come across as disrespectful. Assume competence and allow the dining experience to speak for itself. Chefs in reputable establishments have honed their skills to deliver exceptional dishes. If you’re unsure about a specific preparation, ask the server for guidance or recommendations.

This approach conveys respect and trust, enhancing your dining experience. Remember, a steakhouse is a celebration of culinary art, where the chef’s expertise is showcased in every dish. Enjoy the meal with confidence and an open mind.

14. “Can You Butterfly the Steak?”

14. Can You Butterfly the Steak?
© ryanmichaelcarter

Butterflying a steak alters its cooking process, potentially affecting the texture and flavor balance. If you’re considering this request to change doneness, communicate your desired outcome instead. Chefs can suggest alternatives that achieve your preferences while preserving the steak’s integrity.

For thicker cuts like filet mignon, proper cooking techniques ensure even doneness without compromising quality. Trust the chef’s expertise to deliver a steak that meets your standards, while exploring different cuts and preparations that naturally align with your taste.

15. “And Make It Quick”

15. And Make It Quick
© RecipeTin Eats

Rushing a steak order can compromise its quality. Good steak takes time to cook to perfection, allowing flavors to develop fully. If you’re in a hurry, consider selecting a cut that naturally cooks faster, such as a skirt or flank steak.

Communicate your time constraints politely, allowing the staff to accommodate your needs while preserving quality. Patience ensures a meal worth savoring, with every bite reflecting the care and expertise invested in its preparation. Enjoy your steak as a leisurely indulgence, not a rushed necessity.

16. “Can I Have Extra Grill Marks?”

16. Can I Have Extra Grill Marks?
© rockwoodcharcoal

Grill marks are a visual appeal and often signify a nicely grilled steak. However, asking for extra can lead to overcooking. The focus should be on flavor and texture rather than appearance. Trust the chef’s judgment in grilling your steak to perfection, ensuring a balance of char and tenderness.

If presentation is important to you, communicate your preferences subtly, but remember that taste reigns supreme. A well-cooked steak is memorable for its flavor, where grill marks are just a part of the culinary artistry.

17. “I’ll Have My Steak Without Any Fat”

17. I'll Have My Steak Without Any Fat
© Certified Angus Beef

Fat in steak contributes significantly to its flavor and juiciness. Asking for a steak without any fat might hinder these qualities. If you prefer lean cuts, consider options like filet mignon, which naturally have less fat while maintaining tenderness.

Communicate your preferences, and let the staff guide you to a choice that aligns with your taste. Remember, fat is an integral part of the steak experience, enhancing its richness and depth of flavor. Embrace the balance of lean and fatty elements for a satisfying meal.

18. “Your Biggest Tomahawk Steak, Please”

18. Your Biggest Tomahawk Steak, Please
© Vikalinka

Ordering the largest steak, like a tomahawk, is an exciting venture, yet be mindful of portion size and appetite. Such cuts are meant for sharing and are best enjoyed with company. If dining solo, consider smaller cuts or be prepared to take leftovers.

This approach allows you to enjoy the grandeur without waste. A tomahawk steak is a culinary spectacle, celebrated for its presentation and flavor. Embrace the opportunity to share the experience, creating memorable dining moments with friends or family.

19. “Can I Have A Tofurkey Steak?”

19. Can I Have A Tofurkey Steak?
© Grateful

Requesting a tofurkey steak in a steakhouse dedicated to traditional beef cuts might raise eyebrows. While creativity is appreciated, steakhouses focus on meat-centric dishes. For vegetarian alternatives, inquire about side dishes or vegetable platters that showcase the kitchen’s versatility.

Many establishments offer unique, flavorful items catering to non-meat eaters. Exploring these options enhances your dining experience, allowing you to enjoy the ambiance while respecting the establishment’s specialty. This thoughtful approach ensures a memorable meal, even without the steak.

20. “Is Your Beef From Local Farms?”

20. Is Your Beef From Local Farms?
© farm story meats

Supporting local farms is commendable, but not all steakhouses source their beef locally. Asking this question reflects values but be open to quality regardless of origin. High-end steakhouses often prioritize premium cuts from reputable sources, ensuring exceptional flavor and texture.

If local sourcing matters to you, check the menu or ask once to clarify. Enjoy the meal knowing the steak is selected for its quality, whether local or not. Appreciate the variety and craftsmanship behind each dish, celebrating the steakhouse’s commitment to excellence.

21. “What’s the cheapest steak you have?”

21. What’s the cheapest steak you have?
© Prosper Meats

Asking for the cheapest steak might suggest prioritizing cost over quality. Instead, explore cuts that offer value while delivering on flavor and enjoyment. Affordable options like sirloin or flat iron provide satisfaction without breaking the bank.

Engage with the staff for recommendations that align with your budget and taste. This ensures a fulfilling dining experience, showcasing the steakhouse’s ability to cater to diverse preferences. Remember, the best steak isn’t always the most expensive; it’s about finding the right balance of quality, taste, and affordability.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *