When it comes to quick and easy meals, frozen turkey burgers are a freezer staple for many households. They’re lean, protein-packed, and versatile enough to pair with all your favorite toppings.
But not all turkey burgers are created equal. Some are juicy and flavorful, while others… well, let’s just say they’re better left in the frozen aisle.
To save you the guesswork, we’ve taken on the delicious (and sometimes dry) task of ranking 11 popular frozen turkey burger brands. From supermarket classics like Butterball and Jennie-O to health-conscious picks like Applegate Organics and Trader Joe’s, we’ve grilled, tasted, and analyzed each one.
Whether you’re after a quick weeknight dinner or a backyard BBQ star, this list will help you find the ultimate turkey burger to stock in your freezer.
11. Kroger Seasoned Turkey Burger
The Kroger Seasoned Turkey Burgers are hit or miss depending on your expectations. While the seasoning is bold, some find it artificial or overly processed.
The flavor profile lacks depth, and the seasoning often overpowers the turkey itself, leaving little room for additional toppings to shine. The texture can be a little rubbery if overcooked, and they tend to dry out faster than other options on this list.
On the plus side, they’re affordable and widely available, making them a convenient choice. However, if you’re after a truly satisfying turkey burger experience, this one might leave you wanting more. It’s not the worst option out there, but it’s not one you’ll crave repeatedly.
10. Butterball Original Seasoned Turkey Burgers
Butterball’s Original Seasoned Turkey Burgers come pre-loaded with seasoning, but it’s not always a win. Some find the flavors overpowering, making it hard to customize with your favorite toppings.
The seasoning has a strong, slightly peppery kick that can feel overwhelming if you prefer milder flavors. The texture is a bit spongy compared to other Butterball options, which can detract from the overall eating experience.
On the positive side, these burgers are easy to cook and don’t require additional prep, making them a convenient option for quick meals. Still, they fall short of delivering the balanced flavor and juicy texture that many turkey burger lovers are looking for.
9. Butterball Sweet Onion Turkey Burgers
The Sweet Onion Turkey Burgers from Butterball bring a little variety to the table with a hint of sweetness. While the onion flavor is prominent, it can come off as too sweet for those who prefer savory burgers.
The patties are juicy enough but don’t leave much room for adding your own flavors, as the sweetness can clash with other toppings. They’re a good option if you’re in the mood for something slightly different, but the sweetness might limit their versatility.
For those who love a mix of sweet and savory, these could be a hit, but for others, they might feel like a niche choice better suited to specific occasions rather than an everyday burger option.
8. Jennie-O Seasoned Turkey Burgers
Jennie-O’s seasoned turkey burgers are a reliable middle-of-the-road choice. They offer a decent amount of flavor and stay juicy if cooked correctly. However, the seasoning can sometimes feel uneven, leaving some bites a little bland while others are overly spiced.
The patties are slightly thinner than some competitors, which means they cook quickly but can also dry out if you’re not careful. On the upside, they’re versatile and pair well with a variety of toppings, from classic lettuce and tomato to more adventurous combinations.
If you’re looking for a quick, no-fuss option, these will do, but they’re not likely to blow you away. They’re dependable but lack that wow factor.
7. Butterball All Natural Turkey Burgers
If you’re looking for simplicity, Butterball’s All Natural Turkey Burgers are a solid pick. With fewer additives and a clean turkey flavor, they’re great for pairing with bold toppings or marinades.
That said, the lack of seasoning can leave them feeling a little plain on their own. These patties are made from quality turkey meat, which gives them a natural flavor profile that’s appealing to health-conscious eaters.
However, they’re best suited for those who enjoy customizing their burgers, as the neutral flavor allows you to get creative with seasonings and sauces. They’re a good blank canvas but need some creativity to really shine.
6. Simple Truth Natural Turkey Burgers
These natural turkey burgers from Simple Truth are a favorite for the health-conscious. Made with minimal processing and clean ingredients, they offer a mild turkey flavor that pairs well with all kinds of toppings.
However, the lack of seasoning means they can feel a little underwhelming straight out of the box. Their texture is tender and juicy when cooked properly, making them an enjoyable option for those who prioritize quality ingredients.
These burgers are particularly well-suited for those who like to experiment with bold condiments or unique toppings, as the mild flavor won’t compete with other ingredients. A solid, guilt-free choice for those who like to customize.
5. Jennie-O All White Turkey Burgers
Jennie-O’s All White Turkey Burgers are a great pick for those who prioritize a leaner, lighter option. These patties are made entirely from white meat, giving them a clean flavor and lower fat content.
The lean profile means they’re lower in calories, making them a favorite among health-conscious eaters. However, they’re a bit prone to drying out, so careful cooking is essential. Their neutral flavor makes them highly versatile, allowing you to dress them up with bold sauces or keep it simple with classic toppings.
While they’re not the juiciest option, they’re an excellent choice for those looking for a healthier alternative without sacrificing taste.
4. Trader Joe’s Turkey Burgers
Trader Joe’s turkey burgers are a cult favorite for a reason. Made with minimal ingredients, they’re as close to homemade as you’ll find in the frozen aisle.
The mild flavor makes them a blank canvas for any topping, and their juicy texture is hard to beat. These burgers cook quickly and evenly, making them a convenient option for busy weeknights or last-minute meals.
They’re also a hit among health-conscious shoppers, thanks to their clean ingredient list. Whether you’re grilling or pan-frying, these are a dependable and delicious choice that consistently deliver on flavor and quality.
3. Bubba Burger Turkey Burgers
Known for their hearty texture and robust flavor, Bubba Burger’s turkey patties are a meatier alternative to some of the lighter options on this list. These burgers hold up well on the grill and deliver a satisfying bite that feels closer to beef than most turkey burgers.
The thicker patty design ensures a juicy interior, even when cooked thoroughly. Their bold flavor makes them stand out, and they’re perfect for those who want a burger that feels substantial.
While they’re slightly pricier than some competitors, the quality and satisfaction they provide make them a worthwhile choice for turkey burger enthusiasts.
2. Applegate Organics Turkey Burgers
Applegate Organics is all about quality, and it shows in their turkey burgers. Made with organic turkey and no unnecessary fillers, these patties offer a clean, natural flavor that’s hard to beat.
They’re juicy, tender, and perfect for those who prioritize healthy eating without sacrificing taste. The high-quality ingredients mean you can feel good about what you’re eating, and the mild flavor works well with a variety of toppings.
These burgers are a top-tier option for the health-conscious burger lover who doesn’t want to compromise on flavor or texture.
1. Diestel Family Ranch Ultimate Turkey Burgers with Uncured Bacon
Taking the crown is Diestel Family Ranch’s Ultimate Turkey Burgers with Uncured Bacon. These patties are a flavor explosion, combining premium turkey with the smoky richness of uncured bacon.
The bacon adds a layer of indulgence that sets these burgers apart, creating a juicy, smoky profile that’s hard to resist. The texture is tender and satisfying, and they hold up beautifully on the grill or in a pan.
While they’re pricier than most, the quality and taste make them worth every penny. If you’re looking to elevate your burger night or impress guests at a barbecue, this is the one to beat.
Leave a comment