For cookie lovers across the country, spring doesn’t officially start until brightly uniformed Girl Scouts set up their iconic cookie booths. From Thin Mints to Samoas, these sweet treats are more than just snacks—they’re seasonal traditions, nostalgia-packed boxes of joy, and a way to support future female leaders. But this year, there’s a bittersweet twist to the celebration. After the 2025 season, two beloved cookie flavors—Girl Scout S’mores and Toast-Yay!—will be retiring.
Two Favorites Say Farewell
Ever since I was a Girl Scout Brownie, buying cookies each spring has been a personal tradition. Sure, you can whip up a batch of copycat cookies at home, but there’s something special about supporting your local troop and seeing that colorful lineup of cookie boxes stacked in your pantry. That’s why the news of these retirements hits a little harder than your average product update.
Girl Scout S’mores, inspired by the classic campfire treat, feature two graham cracker-flavored cookies sandwiching a creamy marshmallow and chocolate filling. Introduced in 2017, they quickly became a fan favorite—not only for their flavor but for how well they captured the essence of Girl Scout culture: friendship, adventure, and of course, camping.
On the other hand, Toast-Yay! cookies brought the breakfast table to cookie form. These French toast–inspired goodies debuted in 2020 and featured buttery, cinnamon-spiced cookies dipped in a light icing. Shaped like tiny slices of toast, they were as Instagram-worthy as they were delicious. A nod to warm morning memories and sweet comfort, Toast-Yay!s had a charm all their own.
While both cookies had relatively short runs compared to classics like Thin Mints or Samoas, they carved out loyal followings. The Girl Scouts’ decision to discontinue them is part of the natural ebb and flow of product offerings—but this time, fans have a little advance warning.
Last Chance to Stock Up
The good news? You still have time to grab a few final boxes of these outgoing flavors. The 2025 Girl Scout Cookie season officially launched on January 7 and runs through April. Between now and then, you’ll be able to find booths near grocery stores, community centers, and other familiar neighborhood spots. If your cookie cravings strike after February 21, you can even order online, with direct-to-door shipping available for ultimate convenience.
So whether you’re a die-hard S’mores lover or someone who enjoys a Toast-Yay! with your morning coffee, now’s the time to make space in your freezer (because yes—Girl Scout Cookies freeze beautifully). Treat yourself while you still can, and maybe even grab an extra box or two for those cookie-loving friends who haven’t heard the news yet.
A Strong Lineup Remains
Even with S’mores and Toast-Yay!s bowing out, the 2025 Girl Scout Cookie menu still brings plenty of flavor. Thin Mints, the perennial top-seller, are back with their refreshing chocolate-mint crunch. Samoas (also known as Caramel deLites) deliver that signature blend of caramel, coconut, and chocolate drizzle. And Peanut Butter Patties (aka Tagalongs) satisfy anyone with a love for that perfect peanut butter and chocolate combo.
Other favorites expected to return include:
- Trefoils – the classic shortbread cookies stamped with the Girl Scout emblem
- Do-Si-Dos – peanut butter sandwich cookies with an oatmeal twist
- Lemon-Ups – crisp lemon cookies featuring inspirational messages
- Adventurefuls – brownie-inspired cookies with caramel and sea salt centers
- Toffee-tastics – a gluten-free option for those with dietary restrictions
It’s worth noting that cookie names and selections may vary slightly depending on your local Girl Scout council, so check with your area troop for the most accurate list.
Why Cookies Matter
Girl Scout Cookies aren’t just tasty—they’re part of a larger mission. The cookie program is the largest girl-led entrepreneurial program in the world. Every box you buy helps girls learn essential skills like goal-setting, decision-making, money management, and people skills. Profits stay local, supporting troop activities and community projects, from service initiatives to STEM education.
So while we’re sad to say goodbye to Girl Scout S’mores and Toast-Yay!, we can take comfort in knowing that each cookie box—no matter the flavor—is helping shape confident, capable young women.
Don’t Miss Out
The farewell is official, but it’s not final until the last box is sold. Whether you’re a longtime fan of the retiring flavors or simply want to give them a try before they vanish from shelves, now’s the time to act. Because once they’re gone, they’re gone—and we all know the cookie cravings don’t care about retirement.
Find your favorite Girl Scout, visit a booth, or shop online starting February 21. Say your sweet goodbyes—and then maybe say hello to a new favorite.
Leave a comment