Mayonnaise: the unsung hero of sandwiches, the secret ingredient in many a potato salad, and the silky binder that holds your favorite dips together.
But not all mayos are created equal! When it comes to finding a mayonnaise with quality ingredients, you need more than just a smooth, creamy texture. You want real ingredients, no weird preservatives, and a flavor that brings a little joy to every bite.
We’ve rounded up 15 of the best mayo brands with quality ingredients that will upgrade your sandwiches, salads, and more.
1. Sir Kensington’s Organic Mayonnaise
Sir Kensington’s Organic Mayonnaise is like the aristocrat of condiments. It’s made with certified organic ingredients and sunflower oil, so you can feel fancy while spreading it on your BLT.
This mayo is all about keeping things real—no artificial preservatives or colors here. It also has a touch of lemon juice, giving it a zesty lift that’s perfect for everything from sandwiches to aioli.
The texture is luxuriously smooth, and it strikes a perfect balance between creamy richness and a light, refreshing finish. Whether you’re using it as a spread or mixing it into a sauce, Sir Kensington’s offers an elevated experience with every bite.
2. Primal Kitchen Real Mayonnaise
If you’re living the keto or paleo life, Primal Kitchen’s Real Mayonnaise is your new best friend. Made with avocado oil, this mayo is free from sugar, dairy, gluten, soy, and canola oil.
The ingredients list is as clean as it gets, featuring only real, wholesome items. Unlike many other health-conscious mayos that can taste bland or too oily, Primal Kitchen brings a full-bodied flavor with a satisfying, creamy consistency.
It’s perfect for creating homemade dressings, spreading on sandwiches, or as a dip for fresh veggies. You’ll love how it manages to be both indulgent and diet-friendly.
3. Chosen Foods Avocado Oil Mayo
Chosen Foods Avocado Oil Mayo is for anyone who wants a mayo that does double duty as a health-conscious choice. Made with 100% pure avocado oil, this mayo is non-GMO, gluten-free, and skips the added sugars.
It’s creamy, dreamy, and ideal for paleo and keto diets. What sets it apart is its clean, buttery taste that complements rather than overpowers. It’s fantastic in potato salads, slathered on a burger, or even as a base for creamy salad dressings.
With Chosen Foods, you get a mayonnaise that not only tastes good but also aligns with a healthy lifestyle.
4. Duke’s Real Mayonnaise
Duke’s Real Mayonnaise has a bit of a cult following, especially in the South. It’s made with egg yolks—not whole eggs—which gives it an extra creamy texture.
Duke’s is also one of the rare mainstream mayo brands with no added sugar. It has a tangy, vinegar-forward taste that brings a kick to coleslaws and deviled eggs. It’s a mayonnaise that doesn’t shy away from bold flavors, making it a standout choice for recipes where you want a bit of zing.
The consistency is thick and luxurious, ideal for spreading, mixing, or dipping.
5. Best Foods Organic Mayonnaise
Known as Hellmann’s in certain regions, Best Foods Organic Mayonnaise offers the same classic taste as the original, but with a commitment to better ingredients.
Made with organic soybean oil and cage-free eggs, this mayo is all about keeping things simple and wholesome. It delivers that iconic, creamy taste with a slightly tangy undertone that everyone loves. The organic version ensures you get the same trusted quality while avoiding synthetic pesticides and GMOs.
Whether you’re making a classic potato salad or simply spreading it on bread, this mayo delivers consistency and flavor every time.
6. Kewpie Mayonnaise
Kewpie Mayonnaise is a game-changer for anyone who loves a little umami in their life. This Japanese mayo is made using only egg yolks (no whole eggs here), giving it a uniquely rich and creamy texture.
It also uses rice vinegar instead of distilled vinegar, which adds a subtle sweetness and a hint of umami that makes it perfect for everything from sushi to sandwiches. The iconic squeeze bottle with a fine nozzle allows for perfect drizzling, making it a favorite for artistic food presentations.
Whether you’re using it in a homemade poke bowl or drizzling it over okonomiyaki, Kewpie brings a distinct and unforgettable flavor.
7. Sir Kensington’s Classic Mayonnaise
Sir Kensington’s Classic Mayonnaise proves that sometimes classic really is best. Made with sunflower oil and free-range eggs, this mayo boasts a short, clean ingredient list with nothing artificial.
It has a smooth, almost homemade taste that elevates everything it touches. Use it as a base for a homemade aioli, mix it into a potato salad, or simply spread it on your favorite sandwich for a creamy, rich flavor that feels like a step above standard store-bought mayo.
The brand’s commitment to using ethically sourced ingredients makes every dollop feel a little bit better.
8. Tessemae’s Organic Mayonnaise
Tessemae’s Organic Mayonnaise is like the health guru of the mayo world. With organic sunflower oil and cage-free eggs, it ticks all the boxes for those following a paleo or Whole30 diet. There’s no added sugar, no preservatives, and no artificial anything.
It offers a beautifully mild flavor with a creamy texture that works well in everything from coleslaw to deviled eggs. It’s also a great choice for those who prefer their condiments with a clean label, free from unnecessary additives.
The light, fresh taste allows it to blend seamlessly into dressings and sauces, adding creaminess without overwhelming other flavors.
9. 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Mayonnaise
Whole Foods’ 365 Organic Mayonnaise is a perfect choice for anyone who wants quality without the hefty price tag. This mayo is made with organic ingredients, including cage-free eggs, and avoids artificial flavors and preservatives.
It has a mild, balanced flavor and a smooth texture that makes it versatile for a variety of uses. It works well in sandwiches, mixed into salads, or as a base for homemade dips.
The affordability of this organic option makes it a practical choice for those who want to enjoy quality ingredients on a budget.
10. Trader Joe’s Organic Mayonnaise
Trader Joe’s Organic Mayonnaise delivers quality ingredients and flavor without breaking the bank. Made with organic expeller-pressed soybean oil and cage-free eggs, this mayo has a classic creamy texture and a subtle flavor that enhances without overpowering.
It’s ideal for everything from classic sandwiches to creating flavorful dressings or dipping sauces. Trader Joe’s keeps it simple, focusing on what matters—quality ingredients and good taste. It’s a great choice for those who want an organic option that doesn’t sacrifice taste or texture.
11. Just Mayo (by Eat Just, Inc.)
Just Mayo by Eat Just, Inc. is a fantastic option for those who are looking for a plant-based alternative to traditional mayonnaise. It’s completely egg-free and made with non-GMO ingredients, making it a hit among vegans and those with egg allergies.
Despite being plant-based, Just Mayo has a remarkably classic mayo flavor and a thick, creamy consistency that makes it perfect for traditional uses like potato salads, sandwiches, and dips.
It’s proof that you don’t need eggs to make a great mayonnaise, offering all the versatility and flavor you expect from a classic spread.
12. Spectrum Organic Mayonnaise
Spectrum Organic Mayonnaise offers a simple, clean take on a beloved classic. Made with organic cage-free eggs and organic soybean oil, this mayo is free from artificial colors and preservatives.
It has a mild, balanced flavor that makes it a great choice for those who prefer their mayo to blend seamlessly into recipes rather than stand out too much.
Whether you’re whipping up a tuna salad or crafting a gourmet burger, Spectrum offers a smooth, creamy consistency that adds just the right amount of richness.
13. Blue Plate Real Mayonnaise
Blue Plate Real Mayonnaise is a hidden gem, especially beloved in Southern kitchens. Its rich and creamy texture is perfect for classic recipes like deviled eggs, coleslaw, and traditional Southern potato salads.
Made with simple ingredients like soybean oil, egg yolks, and vinegar, it delivers a well-rounded, slightly tangy flavor that enhances without overwhelming. The consistency is thick enough to hold up in recipes but smooth enough for easy spreading.
If you’re looking for a dependable mayo that brings a touch of nostalgia and a lot of flavor, Blue Plate is a great choice.
14. Hampton Creek’s Just Mayo
Hampton Creek’s Just Mayo is another excellent vegan option that does not compromise on flavor or texture. Made with non-GMO ingredients, this egg-free mayo is perfect for those following a plant-based diet or who have egg allergies.
It has a classic, tangy mayo flavor and a thick, spreadable consistency that works well in a wide range of recipes. From sandwiches to salad dressings, Just Mayo delivers a familiar taste with a cleaner ingredient list.
It’s a versatile choice that proves you don’t need traditional ingredients to create a delicious, creamy condiment.
15. Woodstock Organic Mayonnaise
Woodstock Organic Mayonnaise brings together quality, simplicity, and flavor in one jar. This mayo is made with organic ingredients, including expeller-pressed soybean oil and cage-free eggs, ensuring a clean label with no artificial additives.
It has a classic mayo flavor—rich, smooth, and versatile—that works well in both everyday recipes and gourmet dishes. Woodstock’s commitment to transparency and quality ingredients makes it a trustworthy choice for those who want to enjoy their favorite condiment without compromise.
Whether you’re spreading it on a sandwich or mixing it into a dressing, this mayo delivers both quality and taste.
Leave a comment