6 Holiday Ice Cream Sandwich Flavors To Look For At Target This Season

Holiday desserts are about to get a little more interesting at Target. Instead of choosing between gingerbread cookies…

6 Holiday Ice Cream Sandwich Flavors To Look For At Target This Season
6 Holiday Ice Cream Sandwich Flavors To Look For At Target This Season

Holiday desserts are about to get a little more interesting at Target. Instead of choosing between gingerbread cookies, brownies, and cheesecake, shoppers will soon be able to enjoy all three flavors in frozen form.

Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches is introducing a limited-edition Holiday Variety Pack featuring six different ice cream sandwich flavors, including Gingerbread House, Cookie Butter Cheesecake, and Mint Fudge Brownie.

The collection will arrive at Target stores nationwide on November 28, 2026, with a retail price of $11.99. Each box includes six individually portioned, Chomp-size ice cream sandwiches, making it an easy option for holiday gatherings, movie nights, or anyone who enjoys trying different desserts.

And while gingerbread and mint might seem like obvious holiday choices, the assortment also includes a few unexpected combinations.

Here’s a closer look at all six flavors coming to Target this season.

1. Gingerbread House

Gingerbread House
© Reddit

Few desserts capture the holiday season quite like gingerbread. Its combination of warming spices and sweet cookies has been a Christmas tradition for generations, and Nightingale is giving that familiar flavor a frozen makeover.

The Gingerbread House ice cream sandwich features gingerbread cookies paired with cream cheese ice cream.

It’s a combination that takes inspiration from classic holiday baking while adding a rich, creamy contrast to the spiced cookies.

The cream cheese element is particularly interesting. Instead of relying on plain vanilla ice cream, the filling brings a cheesecake-like character that could complement the gingerbread’s distinctive spice.

For anyone who enjoys gingerbread cookies with cream cheese frosting, this flavor offers a different way to experience a familiar holiday pairing.

It’s also one of the most seasonally distinctive options in the collection, making it an obvious starting point for shoppers looking for something that feels unmistakably festive.

2. Cookie Butter Cheesecake

Cookie Butter Cheesecake
© nightingaleicecream

Cookie butter has become a favorite ingredient in everything from coffee drinks to cheesecakes, thanks to its sweet, caramelized biscuit flavor.

Nightingale’s Cookie Butter Cheesecake ice cream sandwich brings that indulgent combination into its holiday assortment.

The flavor features cookie butter cheesecake with swirls of speculaas cookie crumbs, adding a spiced biscuit element to the creamy dessert.

Speculaas cookies are traditionally associated with European holiday baking and are known for their aromatic spices and crisp texture.

That makes them a natural addition to a holiday-inspired ice cream sandwich.

Unlike the more straightforward Gingerbread House flavor, Cookie Butter Cheesecake brings together several dessert ideas in one treat.

The cheesecake component provides a rich foundation, while the cookie butter and spiced crumbs add another layer of sweetness and flavor.

For shoppers who usually gravitate toward cheesecake, caramel, or cookie butter desserts, this could be one of the most appealing selections in the box.

3. Mint Fudge Brownie

Mint Fudge Brownie

Chocolate and mint are a classic holiday combination, appearing in everything from peppermint bark to festive cookies and hot chocolate.

Nightingale’s Mint Fudge Brownie ice cream sandwich brings those familiar flavors together in a frozen dessert.

The combination centers on refreshing mint and rich, fudgy brownie flavors.

It’s an appealing contrast: the cool character of mint balances the deeper sweetness associated with chocolate brownies.

For shoppers who find some holiday desserts overly sweet, the mint element may provide a refreshing change from the heavier flavors in the assortment.

It’s also a good option for anyone who enjoys mint chocolate chip ice cream but wants something with a stronger brownie-inspired character.

While several flavors in the holiday box lean toward warm baking spices, Mint Fudge Brownie takes a different direction with its combination of cool mint and chocolate.

That variety is part of what makes the collection interesting. Rather than offering six similar holiday treats, Nightingale has included flavors that appeal to different dessert preferences.

4. Cherry Chocolate Brownie

Cherry Chocolate Brownie

Not every holiday dessert needs peppermint, gingerbread, or cinnamon to feel special.

Cherry Chocolate Brownie brings a fruitier combination to Nightingale’s seasonal variety pack.

The flavor pairs cherry with rich, fudgy brownie notes, creating a contrast between fruit sweetness and chocolate.

Cherry and chocolate have long been popular together in desserts, from chocolate-covered cherries to layered cakes.

Here, the combination becomes part of a handheld frozen treat.

The cherry element helps distinguish this flavor from Mint Fudge Brownie, even though both feature chocolate-inspired components.

Where the mint version emphasizes a cool, refreshing contrast, Cherry Chocolate Brownie offers a fruit-and-chocolate pairing.

That makes it an interesting choice for anyone who prefers fruity desserts but still wants something rich enough to satisfy a chocolate craving.

It’s also one of the less traditional holiday flavors in the collection, giving the assortment a little more variety beyond the expected seasonal favorites.

5. Cookie Monster

Cookie Monster
© Jay C Food Stores

Sometimes, the simplest dessert combinations are the ones people return to again and again.

Cookie Monster is Nightingale’s playful take on cookies-and-cream ice cream, a familiar favorite that fits naturally into an ice cream sandwich collection.

The flavor offers a more traditional dessert experience alongside the assortment’s seasonal creations.

While Gingerbread House and Cookie Butter Cheesecake introduce holiday-inspired spices, Cookie Monster keeps the focus on the classic appeal of cookies and cream.

That makes it a useful addition to a variety pack designed for sharing.

Not everyone at a holiday gathering wants a strongly spiced or mint-flavored dessert. Some people would rather stick with a familiar combination, especially when choosing from several unfamiliar options.

Cookie Monster provides that alternative without feeling out of place.

It’s also a flavor that can appeal beyond the holiday season, giving the limited-edition box a balance between festive creations and everyday favorites.

6. Brookie Dough

Brookie Dough
© Delish

For anyone who has ever struggled to choose between a brownie and a chocolate chip cookie, Brookie Dough offers a tempting solution.

The flavor combines brownies, cookies, and vanilla ice cream in one frozen dessert.

The name comes from the popular brookie concept, which brings together two beloved baked treats: brownies and cookies.

Nightingale takes that idea and adds a creamy ice cream component, creating a dessert that draws on several familiar favorites.

The chocolate richness associated with brownies contrasts with the sweetness of cookies, while vanilla ice cream provides a classic finishing element.

Compared with the more adventurous flavors in the holiday assortment, Brookie Dough is likely to feel familiar to anyone who enjoys traditional American desserts.

It also gives chocolate lovers another option beyond Mint Fudge Brownie and Cherry Chocolate Brownie.

For shoppers who prefer cookie dough, brownies, or classic vanilla ice cream, this combination brings all those dessert ideas together.

Share this story

Leave a response

Your email address stays private. Required fields are marked with an asterisk.