Girl Scout Cookies have been a staple of American culture for decades, offering a delightful array of flavors that cater to every taste bud. From the timeless classics that have stood the test of time to the innovative creations that have since been retired, these cookies hold a special place in our hearts and pantries. In this blog post, we’ll explore 25 notable entries from the rich history of Girl Scout Cookies, capturing their unique charm and the joy they bring to cookie enthusiasts everywhere.
1. Savannah Smiles
A delightful tribute to the Girl Scouts’ birthplace, Savannah Smiles debuted in 2012 and quickly became a fan favorite. These bite-sized, crescent-shaped cookies featured a bright lemon flavor and were dusted with powdered sugar, giving them a light yet satisfying sweetness. Their zesty citrus taste set them apart from richer, chocolate-based cookies, making them a refreshing option.
Despite their popularity, they were retired in 2019, leaving lemon lovers searching for a replacement. Though no longer available, Savannah Smiles are fondly remembered for their melt-in-your-mouth texture and cheerful flavor that brought a little extra sunshine to cookie season.
2. Thanks-A-Lot
These simple yet delicious cookies carried a heartfelt message. Introduced in 2006, Thanks-A-Lot featured a crisp shortbread base dipped in rich fudge, with “Thank You” embossed on top in different languages. They combined buttery and chocolatey flavors in every bite, making them a go-to for those who enjoyed classic combinations. While they had a loyal following, they were discontinued in 2020 to make room for newer cookie varieties. Though no longer available, Thanks-A-Lot remains one of the most memorable cookies, reminding fans that Girl Scout Cookies are not just about flavors but also about gratitude and kindness.
3. Rah-Rah Raisins
Rah-Rah Raisins arrived in 2015 as a hearty, whole-grain cookie option. Packed with plump raisins, oats, and Greek yogurt-flavored chunks, these cookies offered a unique twist on the classic oatmeal cookie. While they weren’t as decadent as chocolate-based cookies, they provided a chewy, mildly sweet treat with a hint of tanginess. Though they had a health-conscious appeal, Rah-Rah Raisins failed to gain the same level of popularity as other cookies and were discontinued after just a few years. Despite their short-lived run, they remain a nostalgic favorite for those who enjoyed their soft, wholesome flavor and texture.
4. Dulce de Leche
Dulce de Leche cookies brought a taste of Latin America to the Girl Scout lineup. Introduced in 2008, these bite-sized treats featured caramel-flavored dough infused with sweet, creamy dulce de leche. Their smooth texture and rich caramelized taste made them stand out among the more traditional cookie flavors.
Though they had a devoted fan base, they were discontinued in 2014, leaving caramel lovers longing for their return. While newer caramel-based cookies exist, none have captured the same buttery, melt-in-your-mouth experience as Dulce de Leche, making them one of the most missed discontinued Girl Scout Cookie flavors.
5. Cranberry Citrus Crisps
In 2013, the Girl Scouts introduced Cranberry Citrus Crisps, hoping to provide a refreshing, fruit-forward alternative to classic cookies. These crispy whole-grain treats featured a tart cranberry flavor balanced with hints of orange and lemon. With their light texture and mild sweetness, they appealed to those looking for a less indulgent option. However, they struggled to compete with the more decadent cookies and were discontinued after just a few years. Though short-lived, Cranberry Citrus Crisps remain a unique entry in Girl Scout Cookie history, remembered by those who appreciated their tangy, refreshing taste during their limited availability.
6. Juliettes
Named after Girl Scouts founder Juliette Gordon Low, these cookies were as special as their namesake. Juliettes featured a rich combination of caramel, pecans, and chocolate, creating a nutty, buttery delight. They had a texture similar to classic pecan pralines, making them a favorite among caramel lovers. Though they were discontinued in the late 1990s, their legacy lives on through other caramel-based cookies. Many still reminisce about their decadent taste, wishing for a comeback. Juliettes were more than just cookies—they were a tribute to the woman who started it all, making them a beloved piece of history.
7. Shout Outs!
Shout Outs! were a bold departure from traditional Girl Scout Cookies. Introduced in 2010, these Belgian-style caramelized cookies had a crisp texture and a rich, buttery flavor similar to European speculoos. Embossed with motivational phrases like “Shout Out for Good,” they aimed to inspire while delivering deliciousness.
Though they had an enthusiastic following, they didn’t last long and were discontinued after just one season. Fans of Biscoff cookies still remember Shout Outs! fondly, wishing for their return. Despite their short run, they remain one of the more unique cookies the Girl Scouts have ever offered.
8. Thank U Berry Munch
Combining sweet and tart flavors, Thank U Berry Munch debuted in 2009 as a cranberry-studded treat. These crispy cookies featured white fudge chunks, adding a creamy contrast to the chewy dried cranberries. While they offered a unique flavor profile, they never reached the popularity of chocolate-based cookies. In 2014, they were discontinued, leaving berry lovers disappointed. Despite their early exit, Thank U Berry Munch is fondly remembered by those who enjoyed the mix of fruit and sweetness. Their clever name and distinctive flavor made them stand out, even if they didn’t last as long as other favorites.
9. Cinna-Spins
Cinna-Spins were designed for those who craved cinnamon without the guilt. These crispy, swirl-shaped cookies were sold in 100-calorie packs, making them a lighter option. Their warm cinnamon flavor was comforting, reminiscent of snickerdoodles or cinnamon toast. Unfortunately, they didn’t last long and were discontinued in the late 2000s.
While some appreciated their portion-controlled packaging, others found them less indulgent than traditional Girl Scout Cookies. Though they weren’t a major hit, Cinna-Spins hold a special place for those who loved their nostalgic, spiced flavor. Their brief presence makes them a unique entry in Girl Scout Cookie history.
10. Lemon Chalet Cremes
For those who loved a creamy citrus treat, Lemon Chalet Cremes were a dream. These sandwich cookies featured a spiced shortbread base filled with a smooth lemon-flavored crème. Their unique blend of cinnamon and citrus made them different from other lemon cookies. Introduced in the early 2000s, they had a devoted fan base until they were discontinued in 2010. While Lemon-Ups and Lemonades offer a citrusy fix today, Lemon Chalet Cremes remain unmatched in their balance of spice and sweetness. Fans still reminisce about their rich flavor, making them one of the most-missed Girl Scout Cookies.
11. Aloha Chips
Aloha Chips brought a tropical twist to the Girl Scout Cookie lineup. These buttery cookies featured rich chocolate chips and crunchy macadamia nuts, evoking the flavors of Hawaii. Their sweet yet slightly salty taste made them a delightful departure from classic cookies.
Despite their delicious combination, they were discontinued in the mid-2000s, leaving fans longing for their return. The macadamia nut and chocolate pairing remains a favorite in many desserts, but Aloha Chips had a distinct flavor all their own. While they’re gone, they remain a cherished memory for those who got to enjoy them.
12. Olé Olés
A festive and flavorful addition to the Girl Scout Cookie family were Olé Olés. These powdered sugar-covered treats featured a light pecan shortbread base with hints of coconut. Their delicate texture and slightly nutty sweetness made them stand out. Despite their unique appeal, they were discontinued in the early 2000s. Fans of coconut and pecan still remember them fondly, comparing them to Mexican wedding cookies. While they may be gone, Olé Olés left a lasting impression, proving that sometimes the most unexpected flavors can become cult favorites.
13. Double Dutch
Chocolate lovers adored Double Dutch cookies. These rich, cocoa-packed treats had a deep chocolate flavor that satisfied even the most serious sweet tooth. With a crisp texture and an intense cocoa taste, they were a dream come true for those who preferred chocolate over everything else. Unfortunately, they were discontinued, leaving a void for dark chocolate enthusiasts. While other chocolate cookies remain in the lineup, none have matched the deep, indulgent richness of Double Dutch. Their disappearance is still mourned by fans who crave their bold, chocolatey goodness.
14. Girl Scout S’mores
A campfire classic turned into a cookie, Girl Scout S’mores debuted in 2017 and quickly became a fan favorite. These crunchy graham cracker cookies sandwich a smooth marshmallow-like crème and a layer of chocolate, delivering the nostalgic flavors of a traditional s’more in every bite. The contrast between the crispy graham, creamy filling, and rich chocolate makes them a unique treat. Sadly, 2025 marks the final year for this beloved seasonal cookie. Fans should stock up while they can because once they’re gone, this delicious twist on a classic campfire treat will be nothing more than a memory.
15. Toast-Yay!
Breakfast meets dessert with Toast-Yay! cookies, a fun and flavorful treat introduced in 2021. These crispy, French toast-shaped cookies are infused with a warm cinnamon-vanilla flavor and dipped in a light icing for the perfect touch of sweetness. Their unique shape and comforting taste made them a standout addition to the Girl Scout Cookie lineup, offering something different from the usual chocolate and peanut butter varieties. However, despite their charm, Toast-Yay! is set to be discontinued after 2025. Fans should savor them while they can because soon, this cozy, breakfast-inspired cookie will be just a delicious memory.
16. Thin Mints
Few cookies have reached the legendary status of Thin Mints. Introduced in 1939, these crisp, chocolate-coated mint cookies deliver the perfect balance of sweetness and refreshing coolness. Their signature crunch and rich dark chocolate flavor make them a must-have year after year. Whether stored in the freezer for an extra chill or enjoyed straight from the box, Thin Mints continue to be the top-selling Girl Scout Cookie. Thankfully, this classic is still available, proving that some traditions never fade.
17. Trefoils
Sometimes, simplicity is key, and Trefoils prove just that. These traditional shortbread cookies have been part of the Girl Scout lineup since the early years, offering a buttery, lightly sweet flavor that pairs perfectly with coffee or tea. Their iconic trefoil shape symbolizes the rich history and values of the Girl Scouts. While flashier flavors come and go, Trefoils have stood the test of time, proving that classic, time-honored recipes still have a place in our hearts and cookie jars.
18. Samoas
Chocolate and coconut fans, rejoice! Samoas are a beloved Girl Scout Cookie known for their rich caramel, toasted coconut, and dark chocolate drizzle. First introduced in 1974, these crisp, chewy cookies offer the perfect balance of sweet and slightly salty flavors. The deep, slightly bitter notes of dark chocolate contrast beautifully with the gooey caramel and nutty coconut, making every bite unforgettable. Unlike Caramel deLites, which use milk chocolate, Samoas have a bolder, more intense chocolate finish. Thankfully, this classic treat remains part of the Girl Scout lineup, proving that some flavor combinations never go out of style.
19. Lemon-Ups
Bright, zesty, and uplifting, Lemon-Ups bring a cheerful twist to the Girl Scout Cookie lineup. Introduced in 2020, these crispy, lemon-flavored cookies stand out with their tangy citrus taste and inspiring messages baked right into each cookie.
Unlike richer chocolate or peanut butter varieties, Lemon-Ups offer a refreshing burst of tartness balanced by a subtle sweetness. Their crunchy texture and bold lemon flavor make them a favorite for those who love citrusy treats. Luckily, this sunshine-filled cookie is still around, continuing to brighten cookie season with its crisp bite, zesty flavor, and a little extra motivation in every package.
20. Do-si-dos/Peanut Butter Sandwiches
If peanut butter and oatmeal had a perfect match, it would be Do-si-dos. These delicious sandwich cookies feature two crispy, lightly salted oatmeal cookies filled with a smooth, creamy peanut butter center. The contrast between the slightly crunchy texture and rich, nutty filling makes them both nostalgic and satisfying. First introduced decades ago, they have remained a staple in the Girl Scout Cookie lineup, proving that simple flavors can stand the test of time. Loved by peanut butter fans and cookie lovers alike, Do-si-dos continue to deliver the perfect balance of sweet, salty, crunchy, and creamy in every bite.
21. Toffee-tastic
Gluten-free and totally delicious, Toffee-tastic cookies arrived in 2015, bringing a buttery, crunchy option for those avoiding gluten. These rich cookies feature sweet, caramelized toffee bits that add the perfect amount of crunch to their crumbly, melt-in-your-mouth texture. Unlike some gluten-free treats that come and go, Toffee-tastic has remained a fan favorite, proving that flavor and texture don’t have to be sacrificed. Their golden, buttery base combined with crunchy toffee pieces makes them an indulgent treat for everyone. As one of the longest-running gluten-free Girl Scout Cookies, Toffee-tastic continues to be a standout choice year after year.
22. Lemonades
Crisp, refreshing, and full of flavor, Lemonades are a citrusy delight that has brightened cookie season since 2006. These shortbread cookies feature a buttery, melt-in-your-mouth texture topped with tangy lemon-flavored icing, creating the perfect balance of tart and sweet.
Their zesty citrus flavor makes them stand out among richer, chocolate-based cookies, offering a refreshing alternative for lemon lovers. Unlike other discontinued lemon cookies, Lemonades have remained a reliable favorite in the Girl Scout lineup. Their bold flavor, crisp texture, and nostalgic charm make them a cookie that continues to bring sunshine with every bite, year after year.
23. Adventurefuls
One of the newest additions to the Girl Scout Cookie family, Adventurefuls burst onto the scene in 2022, bringing a rich and indulgent experience. Inspired by brownies, these decadent cookies feature a deep chocolate base, topped with smooth caramel-flavored crème and finished with a hint of sea salt. The combination of chewy and creamy textures makes every bite satisfying. Despite being a newcomer, Adventurefuls have quickly gained popularity among chocolate lovers. Their sweet, salty, and fudgy profile makes them a standout option, proving that even new flavors can become instant classics.
24. Caramel Chocolate Chip
Another gluten-free favorite, Caramel Chocolate Chip brings a beloved combination to the Girl Scout Cookie lineup. Introduced in 2019, these soft-baked cookies are packed with sweet caramel, rich chocolate chips, and a hint of sea salt, creating a chewy, balanced treat.
While they don’t have the same long history as classic cookies, their blend of salty and sweet flavors makes them a standout choice. Perfect for those avoiding gluten or simply craving a gooey, chocolatey bite, Caramel Chocolate Chip cookies have proven that gluten-free options can be just as indulgent and satisfying as their traditional counterparts.
25. Caramel deLites
Coconut and caramel lovers, meet your perfect cookie! Caramel deLites are a crisp, golden cookie topped with rich caramel, sprinkled with toasted coconut, and drizzled with smooth milk chocolate. First introduced in 1974, they quickly became a favorite, offering the perfect mix of chewy, crunchy, and sweet flavors.
Unlike Samoas, which use dark chocolate, Caramel deLites feature a lighter, creamier milk chocolate drizzle, giving them a distinct, sweeter taste. Their irresistible texture and balanced flavor make them a staple Girl Scout Cookie. Luckily, they are still available, proving that some treats truly stand the test of time.
26. Tagalongs/Peanut Butter Patties
Peanut butter lovers, get ready to indulge! Tagalongs, also called Peanut Butter Patties, are a dream come true for those who crave the perfect blend of peanut butter and chocolate. These decadent cookies feature a crisp shortbread base covered in a thick layer of creamy peanut butter, all wrapped in a smooth chocolate coating. The contrast between the crunchy cookie and the velvety filling makes every bite irresistible. First introduced decades ago, they have remained a fan favorite. Fortunately, this beloved classic is still part of the Girl Scout Cookie lineup, proving that some flavor combinations never go out of style.
Leave a comment