When dining out, desserts are often the sweet finale to a meal. However, not every dessert is worth the indulgence. Some may appear tempting but come with hidden pitfalls, from high-calorie counts to underwhelming flavors. We’ll explore 22 desserts that might make you think twice before ordering.
1. Deep-Fried Desserts

Deep-fried desserts are indulgent treats that can be hard to resist, often featuring items like Oreos or ice cream wrapped in batter and fried until crispy. However, these desserts are calorie-dense and heavy on fats, making them a less-than-ideal choice for those watching their waistlines. Additionally, the frying process can overshadow the natural flavors of the ingredients, leaving you with a greasy aftertaste. While they can be a fun occasional indulgence, it’s worth considering the dietary impact before ordering. Opt instead for something lighter if you’re looking to enjoy dessert without the guilt.
2. Cheesecake

Cheesecake is a beloved dessert known for its creamy texture and rich flavor, often topped with fruit or chocolate. Despite its popularity, cheesecake is high in calories and saturated fats, which can be detrimental to those managing their health. The richness can also be overwhelming, leaving little room to appreciate the subtleties of its flavor. Additionally, not all restaurants excel in crafting this dessert, sometimes resulting in a dense or overly sweet outcome. If you’re considering a lighter option, think about sharing a slice with a friend to cut down on the indulgence.
3. Store-Bought Cookies

Store-bought cookies, though convenient for restaurants, often lack the homemade touch that makes desserts special. These cookies may be stale or overly processed, missing the gooey center or fresh-baked aroma that make cookies irresistible. Additionally, their uniformity offers no unique dining experience, often leading to disappointment compared to freshly baked alternatives. When out for a special meal, you deserve desserts crafted with care and creativity. Consider opting for an in-house specialty instead, where quality and flavor are prioritized, providing a more memorable end to your dining experience.
4. Crème Brûlée

Crème brûlée is an elegant dessert that many order for its rich custard base and delightful caramelized sugar crust. However, not every restaurant masters the balance of textures, which can leave you with a too-soft custard or an overly hard top. Additionally, the simplicity of ingredients means quality is key, and a poor choice can lead to a bland flavor lacking the vanilla punch. It’s often best enjoyed at establishments known for their dessert expertise. If you’re unsure of the restaurant’s capability, it might be wise to pick a safer bet or inquire about their specialties.
5. Sliced Desserts

Sliced desserts, such as pre-cut cakes or pies, are often displayed to entice diners, yet they can pose several drawbacks. These pre-sliced options may suffer from dryness, losing their freshness over time, especially if left uncovered. The visual appeal can also be deceptive, as a beautiful slice doesn’t guarantee optimal taste or texture. Furthermore, these desserts might not reflect the culinary skills of the establishment, often sourced from outside vendors. For an authentic experience, it might be better to choose a dessert made to order, ensuring the freshest ingredients and greatest attention to detail.
6. Soufflé

Soufflé is a sophisticated dessert that promises a light, airy texture and intense flavor. However, its preparation is notoriously difficult, requiring perfect timing and technique. Many restaurants struggle to deliver a soufflé that lives up to its delicate promise, often resulting in a dish that’s fallen flat or is overly dense. The wait time can also be longer than anticipated, which might not fit into a busy dining schedule. For those willing to take the risk, a well-executed soufflé can be a rewarding choice. Otherwise, it might be safer to explore other desserts on the menu.
7. Brownies

Brownies are a classic dessert staple known for their rich, chocolatey goodness. Yet, many restaurant brownies fall short of expectations, often being too dry or lacking the fudge-like consistency that makes them beloved. Commercially prepared versions may also be overly sweet, overshadowing the chocolate’s deep flavors. To ensure a satisfying experience, inquire if the brownies are made in-house or if they offer unique twists like additional toppings or flavors. If in doubt about the quality, consider pairing it with ice cream to balance out any dryness and enhance the overall dining experience.
8. Ice Cream Sundaes

Ice cream sundaes are a nostalgic treat, bringing back memories of childhood indulgence. However, in a restaurant setting, these sundaes may not always meet expectations. The ice cream quality can be inconsistent, sometimes lacking creaminess or coming with icy textures. Additionally, the toppings often overshadow the main attraction, with excessive syrups and whipped cream hiding subpar ice cream. To enjoy a sundae at its best, choose a venue known for quality ice cream or ask for minimal toppings to truly savor the flavors. Sometimes, less is more when it comes to this classic dessert.
9. Molten Lava Cake

Molten lava cakes offer a dramatic dessert experience, with warm chocolate flowing from the center. However, the allure often surpasses the reality. Many restaurants rely on pre-made versions, resulting in a lackluster texture or uneven baking. The cake’s richness can also be overwhelming, masking the subtleties of the chocolate’s flavor profile. When craving this indulgence, ensure the restaurant is known for its desserts or seek out places with a pastry chef. For those who prefer a simpler chocolate fix, a well-made brownie or dark chocolate tart might prove a more satisfying choice.
10. Pies

Pies are a comforting, homey dessert that can be a perfect end to a meal. Yet, restaurant versions often disappoint due to soggy crusts or overly sweet fillings that lack the balance of flavors. Pre-made pies may sit too long, compromising their freshness and texture. When choosing pie, inquire if it’s made in-house and freshly baked, ensuring the use of quality ingredients. For those who value the pie experience, consider selecting seasonal flavors that showcase ripe fruits or classic favorites that the restaurant is known for, enhancing the dining delight.
11. Poorly Garnished Desserts

Poorly garnished desserts can detract from an otherwise enjoyable dining experience. While garnishes are meant to enhance presentation and flavor, some restaurants overdo it or use uninspired elements. Too much decoration can make the dessert look cluttered, while lackluster garnishes may fail to add any real value. An elegantly plated dessert with thoughtful garnishing speaks volumes about a restaurant’s attention to detail. If presentation matters to you, consider choosing desserts that are known for their aesthetic appeal or ask for minimal embellishments to let the true flavors stand out.
12. Fruit Parfaits

Fruit parfaits might seem like a healthy dessert option, but they often come with hidden drawbacks. Many restaurants use canned fruits or sugary syrups, negating the natural goodness of fresh produce. Additionally, the yogurt might be sweetened or not of the highest quality, reducing the healthfulness of this choice. The granola, too, can be more about sugar and less about wholesome grains. For a truly refreshing experience, ask if fresh, seasonal fruits are used, or seek out establishments known for their quality and commitment to health-conscious desserts.
13. Red Velvet Cake

Red velvet cake, with its striking color and rich cream cheese frosting, is a popular choice. However, it’s often more about appearance than flavor, with some versions lacking depth beyond the sweetness. The color can be achieved with heavy use of food coloring, which may deter those seeking natural ingredients. Additionally, the icing can be too rich, overshadowing the cake itself. If you’re tempted by its visual appeal, ensure the restaurant is praised for its baking skills or consider sharing a slice to manage the richness. Taste, after all, should match the expectation.
14. Fancy Milkshakes

Fancy milkshakes, adorned with elaborate toppings and vibrant colors, make for an Instagram-worthy treat. Yet, their appeal often ends there, as the focus shifts from flavor to appearance. These milkshakes can be overloaded with excessive sugar and unnecessary additives, leading to a lack of genuine taste. For those seeking a genuine milkshake experience, it’s best to opt for simpler versions that highlight quality ice cream and real ingredients. Remember, a well-made classic vanilla or chocolate milkshake can offer a more satisfying and flavorful experience than its heavily embellished counterpart.
15. S’mores

S’mores bring a sense of nostalgia, reminiscent of campfires and outdoor fun. However, translating this simple pleasure into a restaurant setting often falls short. The charm of s’mores lies in their DIY nature, which can be lost in a pre-made version. Additionally, quality ingredients are crucial, and some establishments may use marshmallows or chocolate that don’t match the memories. For an authentic s’mores experience, consider places that offer tableside preparation or seek out outdoor venues that capture the spirit of this treat. Sometimes, simplicity and experience are key to enjoyment.
16. Out of Season Desserts

Out of season desserts may sound tempting, offering flavors that are typically rare at certain times of the year. However, these desserts often use ingredients that aren’t at peak ripeness, resulting in a lackluster taste. The reliance on imported or preserved produce can dilute the overall flavor profile, making them less satisfying. For a more rewarding experience, focus on seasonal desserts that showcase the freshest ingredients available. This not only supports sustainable practices but also ensures a dessert that delights the palate with genuine flavors and textures.
17. Skillet Chocolate Chip Cookie from Chili’s

The skillet chocolate chip cookie at Chili’s is a warm, gooey treat, loved for its simplicity and indulgence. Yet, such desserts may often cater more to novelty than taste, with the cookie’s texture occasionally leaning towards doughy rather than perfectly baked. The ice cream, while a great addition, can sometimes mask the cookie’s true flavors. For those who savor a well-balanced dessert, consider sharing this dish to enjoy its warmth without being overwhelmed. Alternatively, seek out venues that bake cookies to order, ensuring each bite delivers the perfect balance of chewy and crunchy.
Leave a comment