Few sodas evoke nostalgia quite like cream soda. With its smooth vanilla flavor and bubbly sweetness, it’s the kind of drink that transports you straight back to childhood—whether that means sipping it at a retro diner, cracking open an ice-cold bottle on a hot summer day, or using it to craft the perfect float.
But not all cream sodas are created equal. Some lean into rich, buttery vanilla notes, while others add a splash of fruitiness or caramel undertones. From old-school favorites to small-batch craft creations, the world of cream soda is more diverse than you might think.
To help you find the best of the best, we’ve rounded up 18 cream sodas that deserve a spot in your fridge. Whether you’re a lifelong fan or just dipping your toes into this fizzy, golden world, this list has something for everyone.
1. A&W Cream Soda
A&W might be best known for its root beer, but its cream soda is an absolute classic. With a smooth, almost buttery vanilla flavor, it’s the kind of soda that feels like a warm hug in a bottle.
The balance of sweetness and carbonation makes it refreshing without being overwhelming, and that signature creamy aftertaste lingers just long enough to keep you reaching for another sip.
Whether you’re pairing it with a burger or using it as the base for a killer ice cream float, A&W Cream Soda is a must-try for fans of old-school flavors.
2. Fanta Cream Soda
Fanta is famous for its bold, fruity sodas, so it’s no surprise that its cream soda takes a slightly different approach. While it still delivers a delicious vanilla punch, it has a unique twist—there’s a subtle tropical fruitiness that makes it stand out from traditional cream sodas.
The result is a bright, effervescent drink that’s incredibly refreshing, especially on a hot day.
Fanta’s cream soda is ideal for those who prefer a lighter, crispier soda rather than an ultra-rich, dessert-like one. It’s bubbly, fun, and a great option if you want something a little different from the classic cream soda experience. If you’re a fan of Fanta’s playful flavors, this one is definitely worth a try.
3. Virgil’s Cream Soda
If you’re looking for a cream soda with a gourmet touch, Virgil’s is the way to go. This small-batch, craft soda is made with natural ingredients and pure cane sugar, giving it a richer, more authentic flavor.
The vanilla is deep and aromatic, complemented by warm caramel and butterscotch notes that make each sip feel indulgent.
Virgil’s takes its soda-making seriously, and you can taste the craftsmanship in every bottle. There are no artificial sweeteners or corn syrup—just pure, old-fashioned soda perfection. The smooth, creamy texture and balanced sweetness make it feel more like a handcrafted treat than a mass-produced soda.
If you want to elevate your soda-drinking experience and enjoy something that feels truly special, Virgil’s Cream Soda is a must-try.
4. Stewart’s Cream Soda
Stewart’s is one of those brands that instantly transports you back to the good old days of soda fountains and drive-in diners. With its signature glass bottle and vintage-style branding, Stewart’s Cream Soda is pure nostalgia in liquid form.
The vanilla flavor is rich and full-bodied, with a subtle caramelized undertone that adds depth to the sweetness.
What really sets Stewart’s apart is its smooth, velvety mouthfeel. It’s not too fizzy, making it an easygoing, sippable soda that feels incredibly satisfying.
Whether you’re pairing it with a burger and fries or just enjoying it on its own, Stewart’s Cream Soda is the kind of drink that makes you appreciate the simplicity of a well-made soda.
5. IBC Cream Soda
There’s something about drinking soda from a glass bottle that just makes it taste better, and IBC Cream Soda is the perfect example. This classic American soda has been around for over a century, and it has maintained its reputation for high-quality flavor.
The vanilla is smooth and creamy, but what makes IBC stand out is its depth—there’s almost a hint of toasted marshmallow, making each sip feel rich and nostalgic.
IBC doesn’t rely on artificial flavors or overly aggressive sweetness. Instead, it delivers a refined, well-balanced cream soda experience that feels timeless.
6. Jones Cream Soda
Known for its quirky branding and ever-changing photo labels, Jones brings the same creativity to its flavors. Unlike many traditional cream sodas, this one has a slightly citrusy kick that adds a layer of brightness to the classic vanilla taste.
Made with pure cane sugar, Jones Cream Soda has a crisp, clean sweetness that doesn’t leave an artificial aftertaste.
It’s fun, modern, and perfect for anyone looking for a cream soda that feels a little more adventurous. Plus, the bold flavors make it an excellent mixer for cocktails or creative soda concoctions.
7. Boylan’s Cream Soda
Boylan’s is all about tradition, and their cream soda is a true classic. Packaged in an old-fashioned glass bottle with a simple yet elegant design, this soda delivers a pure, rich vanilla flavor that’s perfectly balanced with just a touch of caramel.
It’s smooth, not overly fizzy, and has a satisfying depth that sets it apart from mass-produced sodas.
What makes Boylan’s special is its use of real cane sugar, which gives it a clean, natural sweetness. If you appreciate a soda that feels authentically vintage and well-crafted, Boylan’s Cream Soda is an excellent choice.
8. Frostop Cream Soda
Frostop is famous for its rich, nostalgic sodas, and its Orange & Cream Soda is a standout in the lineup. This isn’t just a typical orange soda—it’s a perfect fusion of bright citrus and smooth vanilla cream, reminiscent of a classic orange creamsicle in liquid form.
The first sip hits you with a refreshing burst of juicy orange, followed by a creamy, velvety finish that lingers just long enough to keep you coming back for more.
One of the best things about Frostop’s Orange & Cream Soda is its signature frothy head, a throwback to old-fashioned soda fountains where sodas were served fresh and foamy. It has a thick, indulgent mouthfeel that makes it feel more like a treat than just a drink.
This soda is ideal for ice cream floats, pairing wonderfully with a scoop of vanilla for an ultra-decadent dessert.
9. Henry Weinhard’s Vanilla Cream Soda
If you’re looking for a cream soda that feels truly luxurious, Henry Weinhard’s is the answer. Made with pure vanilla extract, honey, and a touch of caramel, this soda is all about balance and sophistication.
The vanilla is rich and aromatic, the honey adds a natural depth, and the caramel rounds it all out with a slight toasted note.
Everything about this soda—from the smooth, velvety mouthfeel to the beautifully designed glass bottle—screams quality. It’s the kind of soda you savor, letting each sip linger. If you want to elevate your cream soda experience, Henry Weinhard’s Vanilla Cream Soda is a must-try.
10. Crush Cream Soda
Crush is best known for its bright, fruity sodas, and its Cream Soda is no exception—it just happens to be pink! The eye-catching color is part of what makes this soda so fun, but it’s the flavor that truly wins people over.
Unlike some cream sodas that focus solely on vanilla, Crush Cream Soda has a hint of fruitiness, almost like a light cherry or berry undertone, which gives it a unique and playful twist.
It’s light, sweet, and incredibly easy to drink, making it a great option for those who prefer a more refreshing take on cream soda rather than a rich, heavy one.
11. Barq’s Cream Soda
Barq’s may be best known for its root beer with a “bite,” but their cream soda is all about smooth, rich vanilla perfection. It’s one of the darker, more caramelized cream sodas on the market, giving it a deeper, almost toasted flavor profile. The balance of sweetness, creaminess, and just the right amount of fizz makes this a standout in the category.
What makes Barq’s Cream Soda unique is its slightly buttery aftertaste, which makes it feel more indulgent than your average cream soda. It’s not too syrupy or overpowering, so it’s great for sipping on its own or even mixing into creative cocktails.
12. Dr. Brown’s Cream Soda
A true New York deli staple, Dr. Brown’s Cream Soda has been around for decades and has built a loyal following. If you’ve ever been to an old-school Jewish deli, you’ve probably seen this soda paired with a pastrami sandwich or a bagel and lox—and for good reason.
It has a rich, smooth vanilla taste that’s not too sugary or artificial, making it a fantastic companion for savory foods.
Dr. Brown’s cream soda is less fizzy than some of the other options, making it feel a little more relaxed and easygoing. It’s the kind of soda that doesn’t need fancy packaging or gimmicks—it just delivers that pure, comforting cream soda flavor that keeps fans coming back.
13. Mug Cream Soda
Mug is a well-known soda brand, and while most people recognize their root beer, their Cream Soda is equally deserving of attention. This soda is all about smoothness—from the first sip, you get an ultra-creamy vanilla taste that’s sweet, but not too heavy.
What makes Mug Cream Soda stand out is its lighter, airier texture, making it super easy to drink without feeling too rich. If you want a straightforward, classic cream soda that you can enjoy without thinking too hard about it, Mug delivers.
14. Shasta Cream Soda
Shasta is known for being affordable and widely available, but don’t let that fool you—this cream soda holds its own.
It has a bright, clean vanilla flavor that’s surprisingly well-balanced, making it a great everyday soda. While some cream sodas lean heavily into caramelized or buttery notes, Shasta keeps things light and refreshing, making it a great option for casual sipping or mixing into drinks.
If you’re looking for a budget-friendly cream soda that still delivers on flavor, Shasta is a great choice. It may not have the artisanal appeal of some of the smaller brands, but it does the job well and is perfect for stocking up for parties or movie nights.
15. Dad’s Cream Soda
Dad’s Root Beer is already a fan favorite, but their Cream Soda brings just as much old-school charm. This soda is thick, rich, and ultra-creamy, with a strong vanilla presence that feels indulgent and nostalgic.
If you love the feeling of drinking a classic soda shop favorite, Dad’s Cream Soda will not disappoint.
One of the highlights of Dad’s Cream Soda is its strong, fizzy carbonation, which makes it feel extra refreshing. It’s the kind of soda that’s perfect for making ice cream floats, thanks to its bold, creamy texture.
16. Sprecher Cream Soda
Sprecher is a fire-brewed soda brand, meaning their sodas are made using a special craft brewing process that gives them a unique depth of flavor. Their Cream Soda is a prime example of how much care goes into their recipes.
Made with real Wisconsin honey, it has a rich, silky smoothness that makes it feel like a high-end treat.
What really makes Sprecher stand out is its buttery caramel undertones, which blend beautifully with the vanilla, giving it a warm, comforting sweetness.
The fire-brewing process adds depth to the soda, making it more complex than your standard cream soda. If you love handcrafted, premium sodas, Sprecher Cream Soda is worth seeking out.
17. Saranac Shirley Temple Cream Soda
Inspired by the classic Shirley Temple cocktail, it combines bright cherry flavors with creamy vanilla to create a one-of-a-kind soda that’s both nostalgic and refreshing.
This soda is sweet, fruity, and a little fizzy, making it a great option for those who love a bit of extra flavor complexity in their drinks. The cherry notes give it a playful, candy-like sweetness, while the vanilla creaminess smooths everything out.
18. Great Value Cream Soda
Walmart’s Great Value Cream Soda may be a budget brand, but it still delivers a surprisingly smooth and sweet vanilla flavor. It’s light, easy to drink, and a great affordable option if you’re looking for a cream soda fix without spending a lot.
It doesn’t have the depth of some of the craft brands, but it’s sweet, fizzy, and gets the job done. If you’re looking for an everyday cream soda that won’t break the bank, this is a solid choice. Sometimes, simple and straightforward is exactly what you need!
Leave a comment