If there’s one universal truth in life, it’s that Reese’s knows how to do peanut butter and chocolate like no other. They’ve mastered the art of creamy, crunchy, gooey, and downright addictive treats.
But with great creativity comes great tragedy—because for every Reese’s masterpiece that sticks around, there are others that vanish into the candy graveyard, never to be seen again.
And let’s be honest: some of those losses still sting.
Maybe you were lucky enough to experience the genius of Reese’s Inside Out, where the chocolate and peanut butter swapped places in a mind-blowing role reversal. Or maybe you still dream of Reese’s Swoops, those chocolate-dipped chip-shaped wonders that left us too soon.
And who could forget the sheer perfection of Reese’s Peanut Butter & Banana Creme Cups, a sweet tribute to Elvis that disappeared faster than you could say “thank you, thank you very much”?
1. Reese’s Peanut Butter Bites
Imagine if you could pop little bites of Reese’s magic straight into your mouth. Reese’s Peanut Butter Bites were the answer to many a chocolate lover’s dream. Compact, flavorful, and easy to munch, they were the perfect snack for those on the go.
Unfortunately, their small size led to potential choking hazards, resulting in their discontinuation in 2007. These tiny taste explosions were missed by fans who had grown fond of their crunchy bite and smooth peanut butter filling.
They were perfect for road trips, movie nights, or any occasion that demanded a quick chocolate fix.
2. Reese’s Elvis Peanut Butter & Banana Creme Cups
Channeling the King himself, Reese’s Elvis Peanut Butter & Banana Creme Cups paid homage to Elvis Presley’s famed peanut butter and banana sandwiches.
These limited-edition treats, released in 2007, featured a delightful banana creme layer that danced with the classic peanut butter filling. Fans enjoyed the sweet twist that added a rock ‘n’ roll flair to their snack time.
Whether you were an Elvis aficionado or simply a candy enthusiast, these cups offered a taste of nostalgia and novelty. Sadly, as with many great hits, they were here for a good time, not a long time, disappearing after their brief appearance.
3. Reese’s Double Chocolate
Chocoholics rejoiced when Reese’s introduced Double Chocolate cups, swapping out the usual peanut butter for a double dose of chocolate delight.
The rich chocolate-flavored filling was a dream come true for anyone seeking a deeper cocoa experience. These cups were a decadent twist on the classic, appealing to those who believed that more chocolate is always better.
Despite its allure, the Double Chocolate variant didn’t last in the market. The absence of the signature peanut butter may have left fans missing the original contrast of flavors. Yet, for a glorious period, chocolate lovers indulged in this luscious treat.
4. Reese’s Swoops
Who could resist a chocolate chip shaped like a Pringle? Reese’s Swoops were a peculiar yet delightful creation, offering a thin slice of chocolate bliss.
Launched in various flavors, including the beloved Reese’s, these treats provided a new way to experience chocolate. Their unique design made them an interesting snack choice, perfect for sharing or savoring solo.
However, despite their innovative approach, Swoops were discontinued in 2006, leaving a void in the hearts of those who appreciated their quirky charm. They remain a fond memory for those who had the chance to enjoy their fleeting presence.
5. Reese’s Inside Out
Flipping the script on a classic, Reese’s Inside Out cups offered an unexpected twist: a peanut butter exterior wrapped around a chocolate core. This inversion delighted those who loved surprises in their snacks.
The innovative design provided a different texture and taste experience, as the smooth chocolate filling contrasted with the peanut butter shell. Fans intrigued by the flip eagerly embraced this novel treat.
However, like many bold innovations, it was short-lived, vanishing from store shelves before it could become a staple. Its absence is still felt by those who crave a taste of its unique twist on tradition.
6. Reese’s Stuffed with Crunchy Cookie Cups
Combining two beloved snacks into one, Reese’s Stuffed with Crunchy Cookie Cups were a delightful fusion that offered a surprise crunch.
Introduced in 2017, they quickly won over hearts with their textured blend of smooth peanut butter and crispy cookie bits. This combination added an addictive crunch that was hard to resist. Despite their initial popularity, these cups were soon discontinued, leaving fans wishing for their return.
They were perfect for those who enjoyed a twist on the classic cup, providing a playful bite that engaged the senses with every munch. A true treat for cookie and candy lovers alike.
7. Reese’s Spreads Snacksters
Snacking took on a new form with Reese’s Spreads Snacksters, offering a delightful pack of graham dipping sticks paired with Reese’s chocolate-peanut butter spread.
This handy snack introduced around 2015 was perfect for those who loved to indulge in a sweet treat on the go. The combination of crunchy graham and creamy spread offered a satisfying textural contrast that delighted taste buds.
Whether it was a midday pick-me-up or a sweet addition to a lunchbox, Snacksters provided a moment of joy. Despite their appeal, they vanished from stores, leaving snack enthusiasts longing for their convenient and delicious pairing.
8. Reese’s Honey Roasted Peanut Butter Cups
Sweet and nutty, Reese’s Honey Roasted Peanut Butter Cups brought an extra layer of flavor to the classic confection. First seen in the early 2000s and briefly returning in 2017, these cups featured honey-roasted peanut butter that added a delightful sweetness to the mix.
The combination was a hit among those who cherished a twist on tradition, offering a subtly different tasting experience. The honey-roasted flavor was both nostalgic and innovative, providing a new dimension to the beloved Reese’s taste.
Sadly, despite its unique charm, it didn’t secure a permanent spot on shelves, leaving fans wanting more of its honeyed bliss.
9. Reese’s Crunchy Cookie Cup
Layers of goodness defined the Reese’s Crunchy Cookie Cup, a treat that combined the richness of peanut butter with the satisfying crunch of crushed chocolate cookies.
First introduced in 1997, this candy provided a multi-layered experience that was both exciting and indulgent. The mix of textures appealed to those who loved a little extra crunch in their candy.
Despite its initial success, the Crunchy Cookie Cup was discontinued in 1999, leaving a void for fans who appreciated its intricate layers. It remains a fond memory for those who experienced its short-lived presence, inspiring cravings for its unique blend of flavors.
10. Reese’s Caramel
Adding an extra layer of indulgence, Reese’s Caramel cups introduced a rich caramel filling to the classic combination.
This variation, first available in 2006, offered a gooey twist for those who loved the mix of sweet and savory. The caramel layer complemented the peanut butter perfectly, creating a luxurious candy experience that tempted many.
However, despite its decadent allure, it was soon discontinued, leaving a gap for fans who craved its sweet complexity. The caramel-infused cups remain a cherished memory for those who had the pleasure of indulging in their smooth, velvety richness.
11. Reese’s Fudge
Going darker and richer, Reese’s Fudge cups were a chocolate lover’s dream, enveloping the classic peanut butter center in a thicker and darker chocolate shell.
Introduced in 2004, this version offered a more intense chocolate experience that captivated fans seeking something richer. The combination of dark chocolate with the creamy peanut butter provided a sophisticated twist on the classic cup.
Despite its allure, the Fudge variant was eventually discontinued, leaving behind a trail of longing taste buds. It stands as a testament to Reese’s ability to innovate while staying true to its roots, even if only for a brief period.
12. Reese’s White Chocolate
For those who preferred the lighter side of chocolate, Reese’s White Chocolate cups offered a delightful twist on the classic confection. Introduced in 2003, these cups featured the beloved peanut butter filling encased in a smooth white chocolate shell.
The creamy, sweet flavor provided a different tasting experience that appealed to white chocolate enthusiasts. Despite its initial popularity, this variation didn’t secure a permanent place on store shelves.
Fans of white chocolate still reminisce about the unique blend of flavors, wishing for a comeback of its sweet, creamy goodness that complemented the traditional peanut butter so well.
13. Reese’s Whipps
Light as air, Reese’s Whipps were a softer, fluffier take on the classic peanut butter cup. With a nougat center, this version provided a lighter, airy texture that was a refreshing change from the dense traditional cup.
Introduced in the mid-2000s, it offered a unique profile that attracted fans looking for something different. Despite its light and whimsical nature, Reese’s Whipps were discontinued in 2010, leaving fans yearning for its gentle touch.
Those who had the pleasure of tasting its soft, nougat-filled center remember it fondly as an innovative twist on a beloved classic.
14. Reese’s Medals
In celebration of the 2024 Summer Olympics, Reese’s Medals brought a festive flair to the beloved candy. Shaped like actual medals, this limited-edition release offered a fun twist for sports enthusiasts.
The familiar taste of creamy peanut butter and smooth chocolate remained unchanged, but the playful designs added a special touch to the celebratory treat.
Despite their novelty, these cups were a temporary addition, aligning with the Olympic spirit before disappearing from shelves.
Leave a comment