Fast food desserts can be a total treat—or a total letdown. With so many options tempting us from drive-thru menus, it’s hard to know which ones are worth the splurge and which are better left behind. That’s why we did the taste-testing for you. From creamy shakes and gooey lava cakes to crunchy pies and forgettable cookies, we’ve sorted the must-haves from the major misses. Whether you’re craving something chocolatey, fruity, or just downright indulgent, this list will steer your sweet tooth in the right direction. Here are 6 fast food desserts to love—and 6 that disappoint big time.
1. NOT IT: Burger King’s Chocolate Shake
At first glance, Burger King’s chocolate shake seems promising with its swirled whipped topping and classic presentation—but that’s where the praise ends. The texture is noticeably thin, bordering on milky, and the chocolate flavor falls flat with an artificial aftertaste. It lacks the depth and richness you’d expect from a dessert designed to satisfy a sweet craving. Even as a quick fix for a chocolate urge, it underdelivers. The shake melts fast, gets watery even faster, and leaves you wanting something creamier. In a world full of shake options, this one struggles to justify its place on the menu.
2. WORTH IT: Wendy’s Frosty Fusions
Imagine blending childhood nostalgia with trendy dessert mashups—that’s exactly what Wendy’s Frosty Fusions deliver. These treats build on the iconic chocolate or vanilla Frosty base, then stir in bold extras like crushed Oreo cookies, chunks of brownie, strawberry Pop-Tart pieces, and gooey caramel.
The result? A fast food dessert that feels totally customizable and surprisingly elevated. It’s a fun, build-your-own approach without compromising the creamy Frosty texture fans love. Each bite delivers variety, crunch, and flavor that keeps things exciting. It’s not just a dessert—it’s a whole new experience that makes a drive-thru stop feel a little more special.
3. NOT IT: Taco Bell’s Cinnamon Twists
Light, airy, and generously dusted with cinnamon sugar, Taco Bell’s Cinnamon Twists might sound like a dream—but they quickly fade into disappointment. While crisp at first, they often become stale within minutes, and the lack of any substantial flavor leaves a hollow snacking experience.
The sweetness feels one-dimensional, and the texture borders on Styrofoam-like if you let them sit too long. As a side or snack, they’re cheap and cheerful, but as a dessert? They lack the indulgence and satisfaction most people crave after a meal. Fun to crunch, perhaps, but not worth the sugar spike.
4. WORTH IT: Chick-fil-A’s Chocolate Fudge Brownie
The first thing you’ll notice about Chick-fil-A’s brownie is its rich, homemade-style texture—it’s dense without being dry, fudgy without being cloying. Packed with both semi-sweet and dark chocolate chunks, it strikes a near-perfect balance between indulgence and approachability. The slightly crisp top gives way to a soft, chewy center, making it feel more like a bakery treat than something scooped from a fast food counter. Whether paired with a coffee or enjoyed solo, this brownie satisfies the chocolate craving on a level that most quick-service chains can’t reach. For chocolate lovers, it’s a no-brainer win.
5. NOT IT: McDonald’s Baked Apple Pie
There’s a lot of nostalgia packed into McDonald’s baked apple pie, but unfortunately, it doesn’t live up to the memory. The crust, once deep-fried and gloriously crisp, is now baked—and while healthier, it’s also drier and less satisfying.
The filling can be overly sweet with an artificial apple flavor that overshadows any natural fruit notes. Texture-wise, the interior gets gloopy fast, and the spice blend leans more cloying than comforting. While it still has loyal fans, this pie feels more like a relic of the past than a dessert worthy of today’s cravings.
6. WORTH IT: McDonald’s Oreo McFlurry
There’s something timeless about the Oreo McFlurry—it’s been a go-to dessert for decades, and for good reason. The smooth vanilla soft serve acts as a creamy canvas for generous swirls of crushed Oreo cookies. What sets it apart is the consistently thick texture that lets you savor every spoonful without the mess of a melting shake. The Oreo bits retain just enough crunch to add contrast without going soggy. It’s sweet but not overwhelming, simple but satisfying. When you want something familiar, cold, and totally dependable, the McFlurry never lets you down.
7. NOT IT: Wendy’s Chocolate Chunk Cookie
What looks like a bakery-style cookie at Wendy’s quickly proves otherwise after the first bite. It’s thick but not chewy, slightly crisp but somehow still bland. The chocolate chunks—though visible—don’t offer much in the way of rich flavor, and the cookie itself tastes more like pre-packaged dough than something freshly baked. There’s little balance between sweet and salty, and the overall result is forgettable. It lacks the gooey center or melty goodness that makes a cookie irresistible. Despite being a convenient add-on, it doesn’t hold a candle to homemade or even decent store-bought versions.
8. WORTH IT: Domino’s Chocolate Lava Crunch Cake
Domino’s may be best known for its pizza, but its Chocolate Lava Crunch Cake is a hidden gem. Crack open the crisp outer shell, and you’re greeted with a stream of molten chocolate that’s warm, rich, and ridiculously decadent. Each cake is portioned just right—enough to satisfy without being overkill.
The textural contrast between the crisp exterior and gooey middle makes every bite feel luxurious, especially for a fast food dessert. It’s indulgent enough for date night, yet easy enough to eat with your hands after a pizza party. Lava cake from a delivery box? Believe it.
9. NOT IT: Burger King’s Hershey’s Sundae Pie
This pie might win points for visual appeal with its chocolate drizzle and whipped topping, but flavor-wise, it disappoints in almost every department. The crust is dry and crumbly, lacking the buttery richness of a good graham base, and the filling—meant to mimic a chocolate mousse—tastes overly processed and flat. The Hershey’s branding sets high expectations that aren’t met, as the chocolate flavor is dull and the texture is oddly gelatinous. It’s a dessert that promises decadence but delivers mediocrity. For something with such iconic branding, this slice falls well short of being a chocolate lover’s dream.
10. WORTH IT: Popeyes’ Blueberry Lemon Cream Cheese Fried Pie
A first bite of this Popeyes creation is all it takes to get hooked. The flaky, golden crust crunches with each mouthful, giving way to a warm, tart-sweet filling that blends blueberries, lemon zest, and velvety cream cheese.
Unlike the usual apple fare, this flavor profile offers a welcome twist—fruity, tangy, and slightly indulgent. The cream cheese adds richness, while the citrusy zing keeps it from feeling too heavy. It’s not always on the menu, but when it appears, dessert lovers should jump at the chance. This pie proves fast food sweets can be both creative and crave-worthy.
11. NOT IT: In-N-Out’s Strawberry Shake
While In-N-Out has its loyal following, their strawberry shake doesn’t exactly win dessert awards. The flavor leans more toward artificial candy than real fruit, and the shake’s consistency—while thick—isn’t enough to save it from mediocrity. There’s little depth to the taste, and the lack of real strawberry bits or even a punchy syrup makes it feel generic. In a chain celebrated for simplicity, this shake feels too simple—like an afterthought rather than a deliberate treat. It’s not offensive, just utterly forgettable in a fast food world that now offers far more exciting frozen fare.
12. WORTH IT: Shake Shack’s Shakes
Creamy, thick, and unapologetically rich, Shake Shack’s shakes are everything a milkshake should be. These aren’t the watery, forgettable kinds you get elsewhere—each one is slow-sipped and ultra-satisfying. Whether you stick to classics like chocolate and vanilla or explore seasonal offerings, you’re met with premium ingredients and bold, lasting flavors.
What truly elevates these shakes is the texture: impossibly smooth and indulgently dense, without ever veering into overly sweet territory. Served in a minimalist cup with a wide straw, they’re simple in appearance but indulgent in every sense. It’s dessert with substance—and serious style.
Leave a comment