There’s nothing quite like the creamy bliss of a fast-food milkshake. Whether you’re cruising through a drive-thru after a long day or capping off a burger binge, a frosty shake is the ultimate sweet reward.
But here’s the scoop—not all shakes are created equal. Some are thick, rich, and packed with that nostalgic, real ice cream flavor you crave. Others? Well, they lean more toward whipped fluff and mystery ingredients than actual dairy.
That’s right—despite what the commercials may promise, some fast-food shakes don’t even use real ice cream. They might look the part, but behind the scenes, they’re often made with artificial flavorings, powdered mixes, or soft-serve substitutes that barely qualify as “ice cream” by legal standards.
On the flip side, there are some chains that still do it the right way: hand-scooped, custard-thick, and absolutely loaded with real-deal dairy goodness.
In this guide, we’re separating the milkshake MVPs from the posers. We’ll spotlight 15 fast-food joints that proudly use real ice cream in their shakes—so you know where to go when you want the good stuff.
And because we believe in full transparency (and saving you from sip regret), we’ll also call out 5 chains whose shakes fall short in the ice cream department.
1. Chick-fil-A – Hand-spun with Icedream
The Icedream shake from Chick-fil-A transcends the ordinary fast-food dessert. Imagine a velvety texture that practically dances on your palate, leaving behind a trail of sweetness. This isn’t just any shake; it’s crafted with Chick-fil-A’s proprietary blend of real ice cream known as Icedream.
Every hand-spun cup is a testament to quality, where the synergy of fresh dairy ingredients elevates the shake to gourmet heights. Whether you’re enjoying it on a sunny afternoon or as a late-night treat, it’s an experience worth savoring.
Chick-fil-A’s commitment to excellence shines through in each creamy swirl, making it a favorite for those who appreciate authenticity in every sip. Ever wonder how a fast-food chain can feel like a fine dining dessert bar? One taste of their Icedream shake, and you’ll understand.
2. Shake Shack – Made with dense, rich custard
Shake Shack’s shakes are a celebration of indulgence, where dense, rich custard forms the heart of each creation. This isn’t just a shake; it’s a creamy escape that wraps you in luxurious flavor.
Crafted with a real ice cream base, the shake’s texture is both thick and velvety, offering a delightful resistance to the straw. With each sip, you’re transported to a world where quality ingredients reign supreme, and every flavor is carefully curated.
The atmosphere at Shake Shack—a vibrant mix of urban sophistication and casual charm—complements the indulgent experience of their shakes. Enjoy it as a sweet interlude during a bustling day, or savor it slowly while watching the world go by. Either way, Shake Shack’s custard-based shakes are a must-try for those who crave genuine quality in every sip.
3. Culver’s – Uses their signature fresh frozen custard
Culver’s stands as a beacon of quality in the fast-food shake world, with their signature fresh frozen custard at the core. It’s not just a shake; it’s a symphony of flavors, blending richness with a velvety texture that promises to delight.
Made with real dairy, Culver’s shakes are a testament to their dedication to quality, offering a consistency that’s both smooth and satisfyingly thick. Whether you’re visiting after a long day or celebrating a small victory, this shake offers a moment of pure indulgence.
The friendly atmosphere of Culver’s restaurants enhances the experience, making each visit feel like a treat. With every sip, you’re reminded of the simple joy that real ingredients can bring. It’s a celebration of flavor, crafted for those who appreciate the genuine article.
4. In-N-Out Burger – Made with 100% real ice cream
In-N-Out Burger’s shakes are a delightful ode to simplicity and quality, made with 100% real ice cream. This isn’t just a beverage; it’s a nostalgic trip back to the essence of classic American flavors.
Rich, creamy, and satisfyingly thick, these shakes are a true indulgence, offering a perfect balance of taste and texture. Whether you’re enjoying it with one of their iconic burgers or as a standalone treat, it’s a must-have.
The vibrant, bustling atmosphere of In-N-Out adds to the experience, where each sip feels like a celebration of authentic flavors. For those who relish the genuine taste of real ice cream, In-N-Out’s shakes are a delightful revelation, perfect for capturing the essence of classic fast-food indulgence.
5. Steak ’n Shake – Classic hand-dipped shakes
Steak ’n Shake’s hand-dipped shakes are a nostalgic nod to traditional diner experiences, where real ice cream takes center stage. Imagine savoring a shake that’s been crafted with care, offering a texture that’s both creamy and inviting.
These classic shakes bring a piece of Americana to your taste buds, with flavors that are rich, satisfying, and utterly indulgent. Each sip is a reminder of the simplicity and joy found in genuine ingredients.
Enjoy the retro charm of Steak ’n Shake’s environment, where every shake feels like a step back in time. It’s a delightful escape from the ordinary, perfect for those who appreciate the art of a well-made shake. With its blend of authenticity and nostalgia, it’s an experience to be savored.
6. Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers – Real custard made fresh
At Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers, the shakes are crafted from real custard made fresh throughout the day. These shakes are not merely drinks but a delectable journey into a world of creamy delight.
The texture is rich and satisfying, offering a smoothness that beckons you to savor every drop. Each cup is a testament to the care and passion Freddy’s puts into their products, ensuring that every taste is memorable.
The classic diner atmosphere of Freddy’s enhances this experience, offering a warm and inviting space for enjoying these thick shakes. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, Freddy’s shakes offer a comforting blend of tradition and taste, perfect for anyone seeking a genuine custard experience.
7. Johnny Rockets – Old-school diner-style shakes
Johnny Rockets offers an old-school diner experience with shakes made from hand-scooped real ice cream. It’s more than just a drink; it’s a nostalgic experience that captures the essence of a bygone era.
The texture is creamy and indulgent, echoing the quality and care that goes into every scoop. Each shake is a trip down memory lane, where simplicity and flavor create a timeless combination.
Enjoy the retro charm of Johnny Rockets, where the atmosphere feels like stepping into a classic diner scene. It’s an inviting space where shakes are crafted with love and tradition, perfect for those who appreciate the genuine taste of yesteryear. Whether you’re reliving old memories or creating new ones, Johnny Rockets’ shakes offer a delightful taste of history.
8. Cook Out – Over 40 flavors made with real ice cream
Cook Out offers a world of possibilities with over 40 flavors of shakes, all made with real ice cream. This isn’t just a beverage; it’s an adventure for your taste buds, with each flavor offering a new experience.
The shakes are thick, creamy, and crafted to perfection, ensuring that every sip delivers satisfaction. Whether you’re in the mood for something classic or adventurous, Cook Out has a flavor to match your craving.
The vibrant atmosphere of Cook Out restaurants adds to the fun, making it a perfect spot for exploring new tastes. With such a vast array of flavors, there’s always something new to try, making each visit a fresh and exciting experience. For shake enthusiasts, Cook Out is a playground of flavor possibilities waiting to be explored.
9. Dairy Queen (DQ) – Classic shakes with soft serve
Dairy Queen’s classic shakes are a delightful indulgence, crafted from their signature soft serve, which is dairy-based and full of creamy goodness. Imagine enjoying a shake that’s both thick and smooth, offering a harmonious blend of flavor and texture.
These shakes are a staple for many, offering a comforting taste that feels like a hug in a cup. The consistency is perfectly balanced, ensuring every sip is as enjoyable as the last.
At Dairy Queen, the atmosphere is lively and cheerful, complementing the joyful experience of enjoying a classic shake. Whether you’re a long-time fan or a curious newcomer, Dairy Queen’s shakes offer a taste of nostalgia that never goes out of style. It’s a treat made for those who love the simplicity and authenticity of real dairy delights.
10. Five Guys – Made with real ice cream and customizable
Five Guys shakes are a customizable delight, made with real ice cream and a variety of mix-ins to suit every taste. This isn’t just a shake; it’s a canvas for your culinary creativity, allowing you to craft the perfect flavor combination.
The texture is creamy and inviting, offering a rich base that complements any mix-in you choose. Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors or love experimenting with unique combinations, Five Guys has you covered.
The casual and friendly atmosphere of Five Guys adds to the experience, making it a fun spot to explore new flavors. With a shake in hand, every visit becomes an opportunity to discover something deliciously new. For those who love variety and quality, Five Guys’ shakes offer endless possibilities for indulgence.
11. Potbelly Sandwich Shop – Thick, creamy shakes
At Potbelly Sandwich Shop, the shakes are thick, creamy, and crafted with real ice cream, offering a rich indulgence that’s hard to resist. This isn’t just a treat; it’s a luscious experience that envelops your taste buds in a symphony of flavors.
Each shake is made to perfection, ensuring a silky texture and full-bodied taste that leaves a lasting impression. Whether you’re enjoying it with a sandwich or as a standalone dessert, it’s a testament to Potbelly’s commitment to quality.
The cozy atmosphere of Potbelly enhances the experience, making it a perfect spot for savoring a shake. With every sip, you’re reminded of the joy found in genuine ingredients and craftsmanship. For those who appreciate a hearty shake, Potbelly offers a delightful escape into the world of creamy indulgence.
12. Sonic Drive-In – “Master Shakes” made with real ice cream
Sonic Drive-In’s “Master Shakes” are a true testament to the art of shake-making, crafted with real ice cream for a velvety texture that’s simply irresistible. These aren’t ordinary shakes; they’re masterpieces that invite you to indulge in flavor and creativity.
Each shake is a delightful blend of quality ingredients, offering a rich taste that’s both satisfying and exciting. Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors or love trying something new, Sonic’s Master Shakes provide a variety of options.
The retro drive-in atmosphere of Sonic adds to the charm, creating a nostalgic setting for enjoying these delicious creations. It’s an experience that combines the joy of indulgence with the thrill of discovery. For those who seek a shake with personality, Sonic’s Master Shakes are a delightful choice.
13. Whataburger – Classic shakes with real ice cream base
Whataburger’s classic shakes are an homage to authentic flavors, crafted with a real ice cream base that promises a creamy delight in every sip. These shakes aren’t just a treat; they’re a celebration of simplicity and quality, offering a taste that’s both familiar and satisfying.
The texture is smooth and rich, providing a comforting consistency that’s perfect for any occasion. Whether paired with a burger or enjoyed on its own, the shake offers a taste of tradition in every cup.
The bustling atmosphere of Whataburger adds to the experience, where each visit feels like a celebration of iconic American flavors. For those who appreciate a well-made shake with genuine ingredients, Whataburger delivers on all fronts, capturing the essence of authentic fast-food indulgence.
14. Fatburger – Hand-scooped, real ice cream shakes
Fatburger’s hand-scooped shakes are a tribute to quality and love for real ice cream, offering a thick and creamy indulgence that stands out in the fast-food realm. These shakes aren’t just a beverage; they’re a personal treat crafted with care and tradition.
Each shake is an experience of rich flavor and texture, providing a satisfying sip that echoes the authenticity of hand-scooped quality. Enjoying one feels like a moment of pure indulgence, perfect for any time of day.
The lively atmosphere at Fatburger complements this treat, providing an energetic backdrop for savoring a shake. With each visit, you’re reminded of the joy found in genuine ingredients and the pleasure of a well-crafted shake. For those seeking authenticity, Fatburger’s shakes offer a delightful escape.
15. Baskin-Robbins – Premium ice cream-based milkshakes
Baskin-Robbins milkshakes are the pinnacle of indulgence, crafted with their premium ice cream for a rich and creamy experience. These shakes are more than just a treat; they’re a journey into a world of luxurious flavors and textures that delight the senses.
The use of high-quality ingredients ensures that each shake is smooth, thick, and full of vibrant taste. Whether you’re indulging in a classic flavor or exploring a new combination, Baskin-Robbins offers a shake that satisfies every craving.
The colorful and inviting atmosphere of Baskin-Robbins enhances the enjoyment, creating a perfect setting for savoring a shake. With each sip, you’re reminded of the joy found in premium quality and the thrill of discovering new flavors.
For those who cherish the best, Baskin-Robbins’ milkshakes are an exquisite choice.
16. McDonald’s – Uses a soft serve mix with stabilizers
McDonald’s shakes may offer a familiar flavor, but they’re crafted using a soft serve mix with stabilizers rather than real ice cream. This blend creates a smooth consistency, but lacks the authenticity of true ice cream shakes.
Despite this, many find comfort in the recognizable taste, reminiscent of childhood visits and fast-food nostalgia. The shakes offer a sweet escape, perfect for pairing with classic McDonald’s fare.
The bustling atmosphere of McDonald’s adds to the experience, where convenience and speed meet flavor. While not crafted with real ice cream, these shakes still hold a special place for those who enjoy the simplicity and familiarity of a classic fast-food treat.
17. Burger King – Shakes made with a dessert base
Burger King’s shakes, crafted with a dessert base that doesn’t meet real ice cream standards, offer a different take on the classic treat. The texture is smooth and creamy, yet lacking the depth of flavor found in shakes made with real ice cream.
While not for purists, these shakes still provide a sweet respite for those who enjoy a quick and satisfying treat. The flavors are familiar, offering a taste of nostalgia for many fast-food lovers.
The lively environment of Burger King complements the shake experience, providing a convenient spot for a quick indulgence. Though not crafted from real ice cream, these shakes still offer a comforting taste for those who enjoy a familiar fast-food classic.
18. Wendy’s (Frosty) – Frosty is a dairy dessert
Wendy’s Frosty is an iconic treat, known for its unique texture and flavor, yet it’s technically a dairy dessert rather than real ice cream. The Frosty offers a thick, creamy consistency that’s loved by many for its smooth and indulgent taste.
While it doesn’t meet the technical standards of real ice cream, the Frosty’s blend of sweetness and texture makes it a beloved staple. Perfect for dipping fries or enjoying on its own, it’s a classic treat that holds a special place in fast-food history.
The casual atmosphere of Wendy’s makes it an ideal spot to enjoy a Frosty, whether you’re reminiscing about past visits or creating new memories. Though not made with real ice cream, the Frosty remains a favorite for those who appreciate its unique charm and flavor.
19. Taco Bell – Shakes made with syrup and artificial base
When available, Taco Bell’s shakes, like those in the Freeze line, are crafted with syrup and an artificial base, rather than real ice cream. This results in a unique flavor profile that stands apart from traditional ice cream shakes.
These shakes are a burst of sweet, colorful flavors, offering a playful twist on the classic dessert. While not for traditionalists, they provide a fun and vibrant option for those who enjoy something different.
The lively atmosphere of Taco Bell enhances the experience, making it a perfect spot for those who love bold flavors and a lively dining environment. Though not made with real ice cream, Taco Bell’s shakes offer an adventurous taste for those who enjoy exploring new flavor combinations.
20. Jack in the Box – Uses a shake mix
Jack in the Box offers shakes crafted from a shake mix that’s more synthetic than traditional ice cream. While they don’t meet the standards of real ice cream shakes, they still provide a creamy and enjoyable experience.
These shakes are perfect for those who enjoy a quick, sweet fix, offering a taste that’s both familiar and comforting. The flavor is consistent, making it a reliable choice for fast-food fans.
The quirky atmosphere of Jack in the Box adds to the charm, providing a fun backdrop for enjoying a shake. Though not made with real ice cream, these shakes offer a playful taste for those who appreciate the uniqueness of this fast-food staple.
Leave a comment