When it comes to burgers, everyone has a favorite—and they’ll defend it like it’s a matter of national pride. Whether you’re a fan of messy, stacked-to-the-sky patties dripping with sauce or a purist who wants nothing more than a juicy patty on a toasted bun, the burger universe is as passionate as it is diverse. But what happens when we turn to the crowd for answers?
We combed through thousands of Yelp reviews to uncover which burger chains Americans really love—not just the ones with flashy ads or celebrity endorsements, but the ones where the food actually lives up to the hype. And let’s just say, the results might shock you.
While a few household names made the list, others flew in under the radar, quietly building cult followings thanks to standout flavors, top-notch service, and an unwavering commitment to quality.
This isn’t just a list of who has the biggest burgers or the cheapest deals—it’s a snapshot of where real people are lining up (sometimes for hours) to get their hands on a seriously satisfying bite. From West Coast legends to nostalgic diner-style joints and customizable burger bars, we’re diving into 10 burger chains that Yelp reviewers can’t stop raving about.
And yes—the #1 spot goes to a chain with a surprisingly simple menu, loyal superfans, and limited locations that only add to the mystique. Whether you’re a burger snob or just hungry for a reliable next stop, this list will give you something to chew on.
10. Red Robin
Famous for those never-ending steak fries that keep appearing at your table like magic, Red Robin has built a loyal following since 1969. Their Whiskey River BBQ Burger remains a crowd-pleaser with its tangy sauce and crispy onion straws.
Families appreciate the kid-friendly atmosphere and birthday celebrations complete with ice cream sundaes and singing servers. The restaurant’s casual vibe makes it perfect for group gatherings. While not the highest-rated on Yelp, Red Robin earns points for consistency across locations and that unlimited fries policy that nobody can resist.
Their extensive menu offers something for everyone, including turkey and veggie options for non-beef eaters.
9. MOOYAH Burgers, Fries & Shakes
Customization kings MOOYAH let you play burger architect with their build-your-own concept featuring Angus beef, turkey, or black bean patties. Bun options include potato, multigrain, or their famous lettuce wrap for carb-conscious customers.
Founded in Texas in 2007, this relative newcomer has quickly expanded thanks to their hand-cut fries and real ice cream shakes. The casual counter-service setup appeals to families looking for quick, quality meals. Yelpers frequently mention the fresh ingredients and friendly service as standout features.
Their loyalty app offers regular freebies and discounts, making return visits even more tempting for burger enthusiasts seeking personalized flavor combinations.
8. Wayback Burgers
Originally named Jake’s Hamburgers, Wayback Burgers captures the essence of simpler times with their hand-pressed patties and nostalgic diner atmosphere. Their signature Cheeeesy Burger features four slices of American cheese melted between two patties – a gooey masterpiece that keeps customers coming back.
Seasonal milkshakes like Jerky Milkshake (yes, with real beef jerky!) showcase their creative side. The chain started in Newark, Delaware in 1991 and has maintained its commitment to fresh, never-frozen beef. Yelp reviewers consistently praise the juicy burgers and crispy fries.
The reasonable prices and monthly burger specials create an experience that feels like a modern take on the classic roadside burger joint of yesteryear.
7. Five Guys Burgers & Fries
Peanut shells crunch underfoot as you wait for your made-to-order burger at Five Guys, where simplicity reigns supreme. Started by the Murrell family in Arlington, Virginia in 1986, this chain focuses on doing a few things exceptionally well rather than offering an extensive menu.
Their cooking method – smashing fresh ground beef on a flat-top grill – creates those coveted crispy edges while keeping the inside juicy. The complimentary toppings bar allows for over 250,000 possible burger combinations!
Yelpers rave about the generous portion of hand-cut fries, often overflowing their paper bags. The open kitchen concept showcases their nothing-to-hide approach to fast food that has earned them a dedicated following despite higher-than-average prices.
6. Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers
Smashed-thin patties with deliciously caramelized edges are the hallmark of Freddy’s, founded in 2002 by WWII veteran Freddy Simon and his sons. Their steakburgers feature beef smashed so thin you can see the lacy, crispy edges extending beyond the bun – a texture sensation that’s earned them a devoted following.
The frozen custard side of the business isn’t an afterthought but a star attraction. Made fresh throughout the day, it’s denser and creamier than regular ice cream, perfect for their signature Turtle sundae. Yelp reviews consistently mention the clean restaurants and friendly service.
The retro 1950s aesthetic creates a wholesome atmosphere that matches their commitment to quality ingredients and made-to-order preparation methods.
5. Islands Restaurants
Surfboards on the walls and beach music playing overhead create the laid-back atmosphere at Islands, where California-style burgers meet tropical paradise vibes. Founded in 1982 by a surfing enthusiast, this chain brings Hawaiian inspiration to their menu while maintaining serious burger credentials.
Their Hawaiian Burger topped with pineapple, teriyaki sauce, and Swiss cheese remains a customer favorite. The fresh-cut fries, made from Idaho potatoes and cooked in canola oil, achieve that perfect balance between crispy exterior and fluffy interior. Yelpers particularly appreciate the full bar service and TVs showing surfing competitions and sports.
Though slightly pricier than some competitors, the vacation-like atmosphere and quality ingredients make Islands a unique entry in the burger chain landscape.
4. Culver’s
Wisconsin dairy country gave birth to Culver’s unique ButterBurger – not a burger cooked in butter, but one served on a lightly buttered and toasted bun. This subtle difference creates a rich flavor profile that’s earned them cult status since opening in 1984. Fresh, never-frozen beef is seared to order, creating a homemade taste that chain restaurants rarely achieve.
Their famous frozen custard, made in small batches throughout the day, features a special Flavor of the Day rotation that keeps customers checking their calendars. Yelp reviewers consistently mention the exceptional cleanliness and midwestern hospitality.
The blue-uniformed staff and cozy dining rooms reflect their commitment to traditional values while their food quality elevates them above typical fast-food fare.
3. Shake Shack
Born as a hot dog cart in Manhattan’s Madison Square Park, Shake Shack transformed into a global phenomenon under restaurateur Danny Meyer’s guidance. Their ShackBurger combines 100% Angus beef with a proprietary blend of mayo, ketchup, mustard, and spices to create their addictive ShackSauce.
The potato buns receive a butter bath before toasting, creating that perfect contrast between soft bread and juicy meat. Their frozen custard concrete mixers feature collaborations with local bakeries and chocolatiers, showing their commitment to community connections. Yelpers praise the quality-to-price ratio and modern, eco-friendly restaurant designs.
While lines can be intimidating at popular locations, the mobile ordering app helps burger enthusiasts skip the wait for what many consider the perfect balance between fast food convenience and gourmet quality.
2. The Habit Burger Grill
The distinctive smoky flavor that comes from cooking over an open flame distinguishes The Habit from nearly every competitor. Their Santa Barbara-style charburgers feature a unique double-sided grill that sears both sides simultaneously, locking in juices while creating those coveted grill marks.
Founded in 1969 near the beach in Santa Barbara, California, The Habit maintained a small regional presence until expanding nationally in recent years. Their tempura green beans and sweet potato fries offer unique alternatives to standard sides.
Yelp reviewers frequently mention the fresh vegetables and consistently high quality across locations. The open kitchen concept allows customers to watch as their meals are prepared, reinforcing their transparency about ingredients and cooking methods that have earned them the #2 spot in our rankings.
1. In-N-Out Burger
The plot twist nobody saw coming! Despite limited locations primarily in the western United States, In-N-Out Burger dominates Yelp ratings nationwide. Their famously simple menu – featuring just burgers, fries, and shakes – hides a secret menu where those in-the-know order items like “Animal Style” with grilled onions and extra spread.
Founded in 1948 as California’s first drive-thru hamburger stand, In-N-Out maintains strict quality standards: no freezers, microwaves, or heat lamps in any location. Their potatoes are peeled and cut fresh daily for fries, and their beef is free of additives and fillers. Yelpers consistently praise the consistent quality and reasonable prices.
The family-owned chain’s slow expansion preserves their standards while creating a sense of exclusivity that has travelers planning special detours just to experience their legendary Double-Double.
Leave a comment