Ohio might be known for its buckeyes and roller coasters, but the sandwich scene deserves just as much attention. From Pittsburgh-inspired creations to authentic Philly cheesesteaks, the Buckeye State has become a haven for sandwich lovers. These eight Ohio sandwich chains have mastered the art of stacking meats, cheeses, and toppings between bread so perfectly that they might just spoil you for all other sandwiches forever.
1. Primanti Bros.
A Pittsburgh legend that crossed the border into Ohio, bringing its iconic sandwiches stuffed with coleslaw and french fries right between the bread! The signature stacked sandwiches started as a practical meal for truckers who needed to eat quickly with one hand on the wheel.
The bread is thick-sliced Italian, sturdy enough to hold the mountain of ingredients without getting soggy. Meats range from pastrami to capicola, always piled high and topped with provolone.
What makes these sandwiches unforgettable is the perfect balance of warm meat against cool coleslaw, with those crispy fries adding unexpected texture in every bite. It’s a complete meal that fits in your hands!
2. Potbelly Sandwich Shop
Named for the antique potbelly stoves that warm their original shops, this chain delivers toasty sandwiches that feel like a hug on a cold Ohio day. Each sandwich gets a quick trip through a salamander oven, melting the cheese and warming the bread to perfection.
The secret weapon here? Their hot pepper blend that adds just enough kick without overwhelming the other flavors. Regulars know to ask for extra.
Potbelly stands out for its attention to bread texture – crispy outside, soft inside – and perfectly proportioned ingredients. Nothing falls out when you take a bite! Their signature wrapping technique keeps everything hot until the last bite.
3. Jersey Mike’s Subs
“Going Mike’s Way” has become a sandwich lover’s mantra in Ohio. This phrase signals the addition of onions, lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil, and spices that transform an ordinary sub into something extraordinary.
The magic happens when they slice the meat and cheese to order right in front of you. Cold subs showcase the freshly sliced meats, while hot subs benefit from a quick trip to the grill. The bread – baked in-house daily – has that perfect crusty exterior and chewy interior that authentic sub rolls require.
Locals rave about the #13 Original Italian, loaded with provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and pepperoni. It’s a flavor explosion that’s worth every calorie!
4. Firehouse Subs
Founded by firefighting brothers, this chain brings the heat with steamed subs that changed how Ohioans think about hot sandwiches. Unlike competitors who toast their bread, Firehouse steams their meats and cheeses before loading them onto subs, creating a melt-in-your-mouth experience.
The Hook & Ladder® sub remains their bestseller – smoked turkey breast and Virginia honey ham smothered in Monterey Jack cheese. Each location features custom murals depicting local firefighting history, connecting the brand to Ohio communities they serve.
Their signature hot sauce bar lets heat-seekers customize the spice level. For the full experience, pair your sub with their famous Fire Hydrant sweet tea, brewed fresh daily with cane sugar.
5. Capriotti’s Sandwich Shop
Home of the legendary Bobbie® – Thanksgiving dinner reimagined as a sandwich! This Delaware-born chain has captured Ohio hearts with their homemade approach.
Every morning, whole turkeys roast in-store, creating the foundation for their signature sandwiches. Hand-pulled turkey makes all the difference compared to typical deli slices. The meat stays moist and flavorful, whether served warm or cold. Their Italian subs feature premium Genoa salami and capicola imported from Italy, proving their commitment to authenticity.
What truly sets Capriotti’s apart is their vegetarian options. The Veggie Cole Turkey uses smashed avocado instead of mayo, making it a healthier choice that doesn’t sacrifice flavor. Their bread, delivered fresh daily, provides the perfect vessel for these creative combinations.
6. Charlie’s Deli & Catering
A true Ohio original that started as a corner deli and grew into a beloved local chain. Charlie’s old-school approach means every sandwich comes with a pickle spear and a genuine smile. No fancy gimmicks here – just quality ingredients stacked generously between bread that’s delivered fresh each morning.
The Italian sub has achieved legendary status among locals. Imported meats and cheeses are sliced paper-thin, allowing for perfect layering and flavor in every bite. Their house-made Italian dressing adds just the right tang. Charlie’s stands out for their commitment to the classics while accommodating modern dietary needs.
Gluten-free options don’t feel like an afterthought, and their vegetarian creations satisfy even dedicated meat-eaters. Family-owned for three generations, the passion shows in every sandwich!
7. Marlow’s Cheesesteaks
Authentic Philly cheesesteaks have found a home in Ohio thanks to Marlow’s dedication to getting every detail right. The thinly sliced ribeye sizzles on a flat-top grill before being chopped with metal spatulas – that distinctive scraping sound is music to sandwich lovers’ ears!
The bread comes directly from Philadelphia’s Amoroso Bakery, creating that perfect combination of chew and softness that defines a proper cheesesteak. Choose between provolone or their house-made cheese whiz, both melted into the hot meat for maximum flavor fusion.
Owner Marlow spent years in Philadelphia learning the craft before bringing it to Ohio. His attention to detail shows in the perfectly caramelized onions and the way each sandwich is wrapped in paper to steam briefly before serving, melding all the flavors together.
8. Frenchi’s Deli
Family recipes passed down through generations make Frenchi’s an Ohio treasure. Their signature French dip sandwich features slow-roasted beef that simmers overnight in a secret blend of herbs and spices. The resulting au jus for dipping delivers a flavor bomb that transforms each bite.
Beyond the classics, Frenchi’s surprises with creative seasonal specials using local Ohio ingredients. Summer might bring a sandwich featuring heirloom tomatoes from nearby farms, while fall introduces apple-brined turkey with local cider reduction. Each location maintains its neighborhood charm while delivering consistent quality.
Leave a comment