Trader Joe’s cheese section is a treasure trove of affordable luxury that can transform any meal from ordinary to extraordinary. Whether you’re planning a fancy charcuterie board or just want to elevate your sandwich game, knowing which cheeses to grab can make all the difference.
I’ve spent years sampling my way through their dairy department to bring you this ultimate list of must-try cheeses that offer the perfect balance of quality and value.
1. Unexpected Cheddar
This legendary cheese lives up to its name with every bite. What looks like ordinary aged white cheddar transforms into an extraordinary flavor experience when the subtle Parmesan-like tang hits your taste buds.
The texture strikes the perfect balance – crumbly yet creamy, with tiny crystals that add delightful complexity. Many shoppers admit to buying multiple blocks at once because one simply isn’t enough.
Try melting it into mac and cheese for an instant upgrade or pair it with crisp apples for a simple snack that feels fancy. At under $5, it’s the MVP of affordable cheese indulgences.
2. Triple Crème Brie
Velvety, decadent, and impossibly creamy – this French-style cheese delivers pure indulgence without emptying your wallet. Unlike many imported bries that require warming to reach spreadable perfection, this triple crème wonder maintains its buttery texture straight from the refrigerator.
The mild flavor has just enough mushroomy earthiness to please connoisseurs while remaining approachable for cheese beginners. It’s the perfect canvas for sweet accompaniments.
Spread it on warm bread, pair it with fig jam and marcona almonds, or feature it as the star of your next cheese board. Guests will think you splurged at a specialty shop.
3. English Cheddar with Caramelized Onions
This inspired creation combines two culinary soulmates – sharp cheddar and sweet caramelized onions – into one unforgettable cheese. The marbled appearance hints at the flavor adventure awaiting inside, with ribbons of golden-brown onions running throughout the creamy base.
Each bite delivers a perfect harmony of contrasting flavors: the savory, slightly tangy cheddar foundation complemented by mellow sweetness from slow-cooked onions. It’s like someone took your favorite French onion soup and transformed it into cheese form.
Melt it into the ultimate grilled cheese, crumble over burgers, or simply enjoy with a robust red wine. This cheese disappears quickly at gatherings!
4. Manchego
This traditional Spanish cheese made from sheep’s milk brings centuries of artisanal craftsmanship to your shopping cart. The distinctive herringbone pattern on its rind hints at the complex flavors within – nutty, slightly sweet, with a subtle tang that lingers pleasantly.
Manchego’s semi-firm texture makes it incredibly versatile. It’s firm enough to slice cleanly for a cheese board yet soft enough to enjoy on its own without feeling dry or chalky.
Pair it with quince paste (membrillo) for an authentic Spanish experience, or try it with honey and marcona almonds. The reasonable price point makes this imported delicacy an accessible luxury for everyday enjoyment.
5. Blueberry Vanilla Chevre
Imagine the tangiest, creamiest goat cheese transformed into something that could double as breakfast and dessert. That’s the magic of this vibrant purple-swirled creation that balances sweet fruit with cheese’s natural tartness.
The vanilla adds subtle warmth without overwhelming the distinctive goat cheese flavor. Each bite starts with the familiar tangy chevre experience before melting into sweet blueberry goodness that’s never artificial-tasting.
Spread it on morning toast, crumble over a salad with candied pecans, or serve with honey and crackers for an easy dessert. Even goat cheese skeptics have been converted by this approachable, fruit-forward version.
6. Baked Lemon Ricotta
When this seasonal gem appears in the cheese case, experienced TJ’s shoppers know to grab it immediately – it won’t last long! The bright, citrusy aroma hits you before the first taste, promising something special.
Unlike traditional ricotta, this version is baked to create a cake-like texture that’s simultaneously light and rich. The lemon flavor is authentic and balanced – bright enough to notice but never overwhelming the delicate cheese base.
Serve it with fresh berries for a sophisticated no-effort dessert or spread on toasted brioche for breakfast. Pro tip: buy an extra to freeze for later when the seasonal stock runs out.
7. Toscano Cheese with Black Pepper
Imagine if Parmesan and aged cheddar had a sophisticated Italian cousin – that’s this distinctive Toscano with its robust flavor profile and eye-catching black pepper studded rind. The cheese itself has a nutty sweetness similar to Parmesan but with a smoother, less crystalline texture.
What makes this version special is how the freshly cracked black pepper infuses every bite with aromatic warmth. The pepper isn’t just on the rind – it permeates throughout, creating a perfect counterpoint to the cheese’s natural richness.
Shave it over pasta, cube it for antipasto platters, or enjoy with dried fruit and honey. It’s sophisticated enough for entertaining yet affordable enough for everyday indulgence.
8. Syrah Soaked Toscano
The dramatic purple rind on this wine-soaked beauty makes it an instant conversation starter on any cheese board. But its appeal goes beyond looks – the Syrah wine bath creates a complex flavor profile that evolves with each bite.
The cheese’s interior remains creamy and nutty like traditional Toscano, while the wine-soaked exterior adds fruity, slightly tannic notes reminiscent of berries and oak. The contrast between the pale interior and vibrant rind creates a stunning visual when sliced.
Pair with charcuterie, dried fruits, or simply enjoy with a glass of the same wine used in its creation. For maximum impact, serve at room temperature to fully appreciate its nuanced flavors.
9. Burrata
Cutting into a ball of this fresh mozzarella treasure reveals its secret – a lusciously creamy center that spills out like dairy silk. It’s the same luxurious experience you’d expect at a high-end Italian restaurant, now available in your home refrigerator.
The outer shell provides just enough structure to contain the rich stracciatella center – a mixture of cream and shredded mozzarella that creates an unmatched texture experience. The flavor is delicately milky with the perfect touch of saltiness.
Simply drizzle with good olive oil and flaky salt for a traditional approach, or pair with summer tomatoes and basil for caprese perfection. Use within days of purchase for the freshest experience.
10. Gruyère
This Swiss masterpiece delivers everything you want in a premium melting cheese – nutty complexity, superior meltability, and versatile flavor that enhances everything it touches. The slightly sweet, earthy notes develop during its careful aging process.
While it costs a bit more than some TJ’s cheese options, the quality rivals specialty cheese shops charging nearly double. The texture transforms from firm when cold to magnificently gooey when heated, without ever becoming greasy or separating.
Use it for authentic French onion soup, the world’s best grilled cheese, or homemade fondue. It also pairs beautifully with apples and toasted walnuts for a simple but elegant snack.
11. Creamy Toscano Soaked in Chardonnay
Wine-soaked cheeses often intimidate casual cheese eaters, but this Chardonnay-infused Toscano bridges the gap between everyday and gourmet. Unlike its bolder Syrah-soaked sibling, the Chardonnay creates a gentler flavor profile with subtle notes of apple and vanilla.
The cheese itself has a buttery texture that’s firmer than brie but softer than aged cheddar – perfect for both slicing and spreading. The wine treatment adds complexity without overwhelming the cheese’s natural flavor.
Serve with green grapes and honey for a simple pairing that highlights its fruity notes. This approachable option pleases both cheese novices and connoisseurs, making it ideal for gatherings with mixed palates.
Leave a comment