Starbucks might be the biggest name in coffee, but it’s far from the only one brewing greatness. While the green mermaid may dominate the spotlight, Caribou Coffee and Dunkin’ are quietly serving up drinks that many fans swear leave Starbucks in the dust. From indulgent mochas and sweet swirls to bold brews and refreshing iced favorites, these under-the-radar gems pack serious flavor. Most of them can be ordered hot or cold, so there’s something for every mood and season. Here are 7 drinks from Caribou and 7 from Dunkin’ that don’t just compete—they straight-up outshine Starbucks.
1. CARIBOU: Medium Roast Blend Coffee
Unlike Starbucks’ bold Pike Place Roast, Caribou’s signature medium roast leans into a smoother, more balanced profile with gentle notes of hazelnut and cocoa. It’s the kind of brew that’s rich without being bitter, with a mellow finish that makes it easier to sip black. Fans praise its approachable flavor, which never overwhelms the palate. Where Starbucks sometimes veers too strong or burnt for casual drinkers, Caribou nails that sweet spot between depth and drinkability. For coffee lovers seeking a smooth, flavorful cup that doesn’t need cream or sugar to shine, this blend sets a higher bar.
2. CARIBOU: Turtle Mocha
Caribou’s Turtle Mocha is dessert in a cup—but with balance. Rich chocolate blends seamlessly with buttery caramel and nutty hazelnut, swirled into bold espresso and creamy steamed milk. Topped with whipped cream and a caramel drizzle, it’s indulgent without being cloying.
Unlike Starbucks’ mochas, which can taste overly sweet or one-note, this drink delivers a harmonious trio of flavors that complement each other beautifully. The hazelnut adds an extra layer of warmth and depth, making each sip feel like a treat. For mocha lovers craving complexity and a less sugary edge, this is a true upgrade.
3. CARIBOU: Campfire Mocha
Inspired by fireside nostalgia, the Campfire Mocha is a s’mores lover’s dream. Espresso and steamed milk blend with chocolate and toasted marshmallow flavor, then it’s all topped off with whipped cream, chocolate drizzle, and mini marshmallows.
Unlike anything in the Starbucks lineup, this drink offers a playful, cozy flavor experience that captures childhood memories in a grown-up way. While Starbucks leans more into traditional mocha territory, Caribou’s twist brings both novelty and depth. It’s rich, sweet, and slightly smoky—perfect for anyone who likes their coffee with a touch of whimsy and a lot of taste.
4. CARIBOU: Mahogany Blend
Deep, rich, and undeniably bold, the Mahogany Blend is Caribou’s answer to dark roast perfection. It brings together beans from Guatemala, El Salvador, and Sumatra, producing a layered flavor with hints of molasses, aromatic wood, and raw sugar. While Starbucks’ dark roasts often skew toward over-roasted or bitter, Mahogany holds its ground with a clean, full-bodied taste that’s complex without being overwhelming. Its earthy depth and slight sweetness make it a favorite for those who want intensity without ashiness. For dark roast drinkers tired of Starbucks’ heavy hand, this one is a refined and flavorful alternative.
5. CARIBOU: Caramel High Rise
Caribou’s Caramel High Rise offers a dreamy take on a caramel latte. It starts with smooth espresso, layered with steamed milk and luscious caramel syrup, then crowned with whipped cream and a second caramel swirl. The sweetness is present but never overpowering—unlike Starbucks’ Caramel Macchiato, which can sometimes feel syrup-heavy and uneven. Here, the caramel enhances rather than dominates, letting the espresso shine through. Each sip is creamy, comforting, and balanced, making it a consistent favorite for those who love a sweet coffee drink that doesn’t sacrifice flavor for sugar.
6. CARIBOU: Vanilla White Mocha
This creamy concoction starts with robust espresso and layers in silky steamed milk, sweet vanilla, and velvety white chocolate. The result? A rich, dessert-like drink that manages to stay smooth and refined. Starbucks’ White Chocolate Mocha tends to skew heavy and overly sweet, but Caribou’s version achieves a better flavor balance, with the vanilla adding brightness to cut through the richness. It’s comforting yet not overwhelming, offering a nuanced take on a classic flavor combination. Whether hot or iced, it’s the kind of drink that turns an ordinary coffee run into a decadent ritual.
7. CARIBOU: Mint Condition Mocha
Caribou’s Mint Condition Mocha brings a refreshing twist to the classic chocolate-and-espresso combo. Cool mint cuts through the richness of the mocha, offering a bold yet balanced flavor that wakes up your taste buds. Starbucks offers minty options seasonally, but they rarely match the year-round consistency and flavor clarity of this drink. With whipped cream and chocolate mints on top, it feels like an Andes mint melted into a cozy coffee hug. If you’re craving something decadent with a crisp edge, this minty mocha delivers a clean, invigorating finish you won’t get from your average peppermint latte.
8. CARIBOU: BOUsted Green Tea Lemonade
BOUsted Green Tea Lemonade is the ultimate refreshment, combining the invigorating power of green tea with the zesty kick of lemonade. This energizing drink is perfect for hot, lazy afternoons, offering a burst of citrusy brightness with every sip. Served in a mason jar with lemon slices and mint sprigs, it’s a visual and sensory delight. Ideal for those looking for a non-coffee option, this drink provides a refreshing lift, making it a staple for tea lovers and adventurers alike.
9. DUNKIN’: Original Blend Coffee
There’s a reason Dunkin’s Original Blend is a daily go-to for so many. It’s smooth, mellow, and remarkably easy to drink—especially compared to Starbucks’ bolder, often over-roasted brews. This medium roast delivers subtle notes of sweetness and a gentle nuttiness without the bitterness that can dominate other chains’ basic black coffee. Dunkin’ keeps it approachable and consistent, making it ideal for both coffee purists and casual sippers. Where Starbucks can overwhelm the palate, Dunkin’s blend offers a comforting, familiar cup that’s both flavorful and effortlessly drinkable. It’s the kind of everyday brew that never oversteps its welcome.
10. DUNKIN’: Cold Brew Coffee
Dunkin’s cold brew wins on smoothness. Steeped for 12 hours, it produces a crisp, full-bodied drink with low acidity and natural sweetness—something Starbucks’ more aggressive cold brew often lacks. Dunkin’s version is refreshingly drinkable on its own, with a silky texture and bold flavor that doesn’t need cream or sugar to taste good. It’s ideal for those who want their cold brew rich, not bitter. Even when customized with syrups or milk, the flavor holds its strength. For coffee lovers seeking a refreshing, less acidic cold brew, Dunkin’ delivers a dependable, flavorful option that easily beats Starbucks.
11. DUNKIN’: Caramel Swirl Latte
Sweet without being sickly, Dunkin’s Caramel Swirl Latte manages to highlight the espresso rather than hide it. The caramel swirl is buttery and rich, blending smoothly with the milk and coffee to create a warm, satisfying flavor. Starbucks’ caramel drinks often feel over-engineered, with syrup dominating the experience.
Dunkin’s take is more straightforward—and more enjoyable. It’s the perfect balance of sweetness and substance, ideal for someone who wants indulgence without sacrificing the taste of the coffee itself. Its approachable flavor and creamy texture make it an irresistible treat that doesn’t drown out the essence of a good latte.
12. DUNKIN’: French Vanilla Swirl Coffee
Soft and soothing, the French Vanilla Swirl at Dunkin’ adds a creamy richness to regular brewed coffee that never feels artificial or overpowering. Starbucks’ vanilla offerings can veer too sweet or too bland, but Dunkin’s strikes a comforting middle ground—mellow, smooth, and flavorful without being fussy.
It’s great hot or iced, and the flavor holds up even when mixed with dairy alternatives. The vanilla itself has a subtle depth that lingers pleasantly after each sip. For those who want a flavored coffee that’s more about cozy comfort than high-fructose overload, Dunkin’s version stands tall against Starbucks’ vanilla lineup.
13. DUNKIN’: Caramel Macchiato
Dunkin’s Caramel Macchiato offers a harmonious blend of rich espresso, creamy milk, and sweet caramel flavor. This beverage is crafted by pouring two shots of bold espresso over steamed milk, infused with a buttery caramel swirl, and topped with a caramel drizzle for added indulgence.
Unlike some of Starbucks’ caramel beverages, which can be overly sweet or heavy, Dunkin’s version strikes a balance between the robustness of espresso and the sweetness of caramel, resulting in a smooth and satisfying drink. Available in both hot and iced versions, it caters to different preferences and provides a delightful coffee experience for those seeking a flavorful yet balanced caramel-infused beverage.
14. DUNKIN’: Butter Pecan Swirl Coffee
This fan-favorite seasonal treat from Dunkin’ delivers big flavor in every sip. The buttery, nutty notes of roasted pecans meld beautifully with sweet cream and coffee, creating a rich, indulgent drink that’s both cozy and exciting. Starbucks doesn’t offer anything quite like it, giving Dunkin’ the edge in creativity and taste. The swirl is bold but not overwhelming, and the flavor lingers pleasantly without being cloying. Whether served hot or iced, it’s a decadent option that feels special. Coffee drinkers looking for a unique, dessert-like experience with real depth will find this swirl far more memorable than any Starbucks seasonal.
15. DUNKIN’: Dunkaccino®
Yes, we know—the Dunkaccino® has been officially discontinued. But let’s be real: it’s an OG that earned its place on this list as an honorable mention. The legendary blend of hot chocolate and coffee created a perfectly balanced drink—sweet, smooth, and comforting without tipping into sugar overload.
It had a rich, creamy body that Starbucks’ mochas never quite matched, always landing either too bitter or too syrupy. The Dunkaccino® struck flavor harmony that felt nostalgic and satisfying all at once. Even in retirement, it lives on in memory as the mocha hybrid that beat Starbucks at its own game.
Leave a comment