Let’s face it—pizza is more than just food. It’s a lifestyle, a love language, and for some of us… a personality trait.
But for all the odes we sing to that glorious combo of dough, sauce, and cheese, we’ve been fed a surprising number of pizza-related fibs.
Yup, turns out a lot of the things we think we “know” about pizza are as fake as a plastic Parmesan shaker at an all-you-can-eat buffet. Some of these myths are charming. Others? Just plain cheesy.
1. Pizza Was Invented in the United States
Contrary to popular belief, the origin of pizza isn’t the United States. It all started in Naples, Italy, where the classic Margherita pizza was crafted in the late 1800s. The blend of tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil was a tribute to the Italian flag and Queen Margherita.
Italian immigrants brought pizza with them to the U.S., where the dish became a culinary sensation. Over the years, American styles emerged, but the roots remain firmly planted in Italy. Next time you savor a slice, remember its rich history beyond U.S. borders.
The U.S.’s contribution lies in popularizing it globally, but the heart of pizza always beats in Naples. Explore this rich tradition, and you’ll appreciate every bite even more.
2. All Pizza Must Have Tomato Sauce
The idea that every pizza must be adorned with tomato sauce is a common misconception. White pizzas, also known as pizza bianca, challenge this notion spectacularly. They often feature olive oil, garlic, or luscious cream-based sauces as alternatives to tomato.
These variations create delightful new flavors, proving that pizza is versatile and innovative. By opening your mind to different sauce options, you unlock a world of culinary creativity.
Next time you’re dining out, why not try a white pizza and taste the magic yourself? After all, tradition doesn’t always mean adherence to one ingredient.
3. Hawaiian Pizza Was Invented in Hawaii
Hawaiian pizza doesn’t hail from Hawaii at all! In fact, it was a creative invention by Greek immigrant Sam Panopoulos in Canada back in the 1960s. He dared to combine ham and pineapple, sparking a debate that continues today.
This international collaboration brought a sweet and savory twist to the pizza world. Despite its name, Hawaiian pizza owes more to Canadian innovation than to any island tradition.
So, when you next hear someone bemoan pineapple on pizza, share the story of its surprising origins. It’s a delicious tale of culinary curiosity that defies geographical expectations.
4. New York Has the Best Pizza Water
There’s a long-standing belief that New York City’s tap water gives its pizzas a unique and irreplaceable quality. While water plays a role in dough-making, it’s not the secret ingredient some claim it to be.
Baking science points to technique and high-quality ingredients as the true keys to great pizza. Many cities have replicated NYC-style pizza successfully without needing its water.
So, while the legend of NYC water persists, remember that great taste often comes from the hands of a skilled pizza maker, not just the tap.
5. Deep Dish Pizza Is the Original American Pizza
Chicago’s deep dish pizza is a hearty, cheesy delight, but it’s not the original American pizza. The first pizzas in the U.S. were thin-crust, brought by Italian immigrants in the early 1900s.
These early pies were simple yet flavorful, setting the stage for future innovations like the deep dish. Chicago’s culinary scene eventually reimagined pizza, creating their famous pie.
The legacy of these first pizzas is evident in the variety of styles enjoyed today. From thin to deep, each has its place in the heart of American cuisine.
6. It’s Always Round
If you think all pizzas come in circular form, think again. Pizza can be square, oblong, or even served by the meter, as seen in Italy’s pizza al metro.
Sicilian and Detroit-style pizzas are often square, providing a different texture and crust experience. These variations highlight pizza’s adaptability to different preferences and regional tastes.
Next time you order a pizza, why not try a different shape? It’s a simple way to experience pizza anew and appreciate its endless versatility.
7. All Mozzarella Is the Same
Mozzarella cheese is synonymous with pizza, yet not all mozzarella is created equal. Traditional Neapolitan pizza boasts mozzarella di bufala, made from buffalo milk, offering a rich, creamy texture.
In contrast, American pizzas often feature low-moisture cow’s milk mozzarella, which provides a different melt and flavor profile. Each type serves a purpose, enhancing the pizza in distinct ways.
Exploring mozzarella varieties can elevate your pizza experience. Try different cheeses and discover the unique flavors they bring to your favorite dish.
8. Frozen Pizza Is a Modern Invention
Frozen pizza might seem like a modern convenience, but it actually dates back to the 1950s. Post-war America saw companies like Totino’s and Celeste pioneering the frozen pizza market.
These early frozen pizzas became household staples, offering a quick and easy meal option for busy families. Their success paved the way for today’s diverse frozen pizza offerings.
When you pop a frozen pizza in the oven, you’re enjoying a slice of culinary history, one that’s been evolving for decades. It’s an enduring testament to innovation in the food industry.
9. Pizza Is Always Unhealthy
Pizza often gets a bad rap as an unhealthy food choice, but it doesn’t have to be that way. Opting for a thin crust with plenty of fresh vegetables and moderate cheese can offer a balanced and nutritious meal.
It’s all about the ingredients and portion control. A well-made pizza can fit into many healthy eating plans, debunking the myth that pizza is always a guilty pleasure.
So, the next time you’re craving pizza, remember that with the right choices, it can be both delicious and nutritious.
10. Pizza Is a Dinner-Only Food
In Italy, pizza is often enjoyed for lunch, breaking the stereotype of it being a dinner-only dish. The Italian custom of enjoying a leisurely midday meal includes pizza as a flavorful option.
And let’s not forget the joy of leftover pizza for breakfast, a beloved tradition for many. Whether hot from the oven or cold from the fridge, pizza is versatile enough for any meal.
Why limit pizza to dinner? Embrace its all-day appeal and savor it whenever the craving strikes. It’s a culinary delight that knows no time constraints.
11. Pineapple on Pizza Is a Modern Gen Z Trend
The debate over pineapple on pizza might feel like a modern phenomenon, but it dates back to the 1960s with the invention of Hawaiian pizza. Long before Gen Z, this topping choice was making waves.
Its combination of sweet and savory flavors continues to divide opinion. Yet, its historical roots show that trends often repeat, and what seems new isn’t always the case.
Next time you’re discussing pizza toppings, remember pineapple’s storied place in pizza history. It’s a classic choice with a legacy that predates many of today’s diners.
12. Pizza Needs to Be Cooked in a Brick Oven
A brick oven can elevate a pizza’s crust and flavor, but it’s not the only way to achieve delicious results. Home ovens, cast iron pans, and pizza stones provide excellent alternatives.
These methods allow pizza enthusiasts to experiment with different textures and flavors in their own kitchens. The key is in the technique, not just the oven type.
So, if you don’t have access to a brick oven, don’t worry. With a little practice, you can create mouth-watering pizzas right at home.
13. The More Toppings, the Better
Adding a mountain of toppings to your pizza isn’t always the best approach. Sometimes, simplicity allows the flavors to shine without overwhelming each other.
A few well-chosen ingredients can create a harmonious blend, enhancing the overall taste experience. Overloading can lead to a soggy crust and muddled flavors.
When crafting your next pizza, consider the art of restraint. You might find that less really is more when it comes to creating the perfect pie.
14. Pepperoni Is an Italian Invention
Think pepperoni is an Italian classic? Think again. This spicy delight is actually an American invention, developed by Italian-American butchers.
In Italy, you won’t find pepperoni pizzas like those in the U.S. Instead, salami and other cured meats are more common. Pepperoni’s unique American twist makes it a beloved staple across the nation.
Embrace this flavorful creation and delight in its distinct place in pizza history. It’s a testament to the culinary fusion that defines American cuisine.
15. You Can’t Reheat Pizza Properly
Reheating pizza can feel like an art form, but it’s easier than you think. While microwaves often result in soggy slices, a skillet or oven can bring your pizza back to life.
Using a hot skillet, you can revive that crispy crust and melty cheese, making leftovers taste freshly baked. The oven offers a similar effect, allowing heat to distribute evenly.
Next time you’re faced with leftover pizza, try these methods and rediscover the joy of reheated perfection. It’s a delicious way to enjoy your favorite dish all over again.
16. Pizza Has Always Been Popular
Pizza’s widespread popularity is a relatively modern affair. It wasn’t until after World War II that pizza became a staple in the U.S., thanks to returning soldiers who had developed a taste for Italian cuisine.
Before this, pizza was mostly confined to Italian immigrant communities. The post-war era saw its rise to fame, eventually becoming an American icon.
Today, pizza is ubiquitous, but its journey to popularity is a testament to its irresistible appeal and adaptability across cultures.
17. Pizza Delivery Is a Recent Thing
Picture this: a pizza being delivered to royalty in the 19th century. Long before the age of smartphones and apps, Queen Margherita of Italy allegedly received a pizza delivery to her palace in 1889.
This early instance of pizza delivery shows that the concept isn’t as modern as we might think. It adds a touch of historical charm to a service we take for granted today.
So next time you order pizza, remember its regal past. From palaces to your doorstep, pizza delivery has a rich history that continues to evolve.
Leave a comment