Pancakes are a gift. Fluffy, golden, syrup-soaking sponges of joy that turn any morning into a mini celebration. But let’s be real—what’s a pancake without syrup? Just a sad, dry flap of carbs begging for help.
And while drizzling syrup may seem like a simple, innocent task, not all syrups deserve a place on your stack. Some are sweet imposters pretending to be maple, while others are liquid gold straight from the trees of Vermont.
That’s right—there’s a major difference between the real deal and the sugar-laced knockoffs lining grocery store shelves. Some syrups are basically melted candy bars with a “breakfast” label slapped on, while others are rich, amber treasures that make you wonder why you ever settled for anything less.
Here are 7 pancake syrups you should avoid like a soggy bottom, and 7 that deserve a permanent spot in your pantry.
1. Aunt Jemima Original Syrup (now Pearl Milling Company)
Once a household name, Aunt Jemima Original Syrup, now rebranded as Pearl Milling Company, is a staple in many homes. However, its ingredients list reads like a science experiment, with high fructose corn syrup topping the list.
The syrup is also flavored with an array of artificial additives that leave it tasting more like candy than natural maple syrup.
Consuming it might satisfy your sweet cravings momentarily, but don’t expect any nutritional benefits. There’s not a drop of real maple syrup in this concoction, making it a sugary filler masquerading as the real deal.
When you’re pouring it over your pancakes, remember that moderation is key. Consider saving up for the genuine stuff occasionally; your taste buds might thank you!
2. Hungry Jack Original Syrup
Everyone loves a bit of nostalgia, and Hungry Jack Original Syrup often brings back those childhood breakfast memories. Its sweet, thick texture is undeniably appealing, but when you turn the bottle around, you’ll find a recipe in preservatives and artificial colors.
If you’re on a mission to reduce processed foods in your diet, this syrup isn’t the best choice. It offers a quick sugar fix but little else, providing no real nutritional value.
For those trying to make healthier choices, consider this a treat rather than a daily staple. It’s okay to indulge now and then, but don’t let it be a regular guest at your breakfast table.
3. Log Cabin Original Syrup
Log Cabin Original Syrup might evoke images of rustic breakfasts and cozy family gatherings, but its contents tell another story. Filled with caramel coloring and artificial flavors, this syrup can taste more like maple-flavored sugar water rather than the authentic experience.
Using it on your pancakes might remind you more of a candy store than a maple grove. There’s a comfort in its familiarity, but real maple syrup lovers may find it lacking in depth and quality.
If authenticity is what you’re after, this might not be your go-to. Seek out syrups that offer genuine maple content to enjoy a more wholesome breakfast experience.
4. Mrs. Butterworth’s Original Syrup
The distinctive figure of Mrs. Butterworth’s Original Syrup is easily recognizable in the syrup aisle. While its sweetness is off the charts, it’s mostly corn syrup and artificial flavorings at play here. The rich texture might remind you of childhood breakfasts, but don’t be fooled—there’s little nutritional value.
This syrup is essentially a sugar hit, giving you that quick energy boost followed by an inevitable crash. For those looking to maintain a balanced diet, it’s best enjoyed in moderation.
Consider pairing it with other breakfast options that offer more nutrients and less sugar to keep your energy levels stable throughout the morning.
5. Kroger Original Syrup
Budget-friendly and widely available, Kroger Original Syrup is often picked for its low price. However, this affordability comes at the expense of flavor and quality. High fructose corn syrup and artificial flavors dominate the bottle, leaving a taste that’s more synthetic than satisfying.
While it’s easy on the wallet, it might not be as kind to your health goals. If you’re trying to cut down on processed sugars, this syrup might not be your best ally.
Consider investing in a bottle of pure maple syrup when you can. It might cost more, but the taste and health benefits are worth the splurge.
6. Great Value Original Syrup (Walmart)
Walmart’s Great Value Original Syrup might catch your eye with its low price tag, but its contents are less appealing. Packed heavily with corn syrup and light on anything natural, it leaves a lot to be desired for maple syrup enthusiasts.
While it fits easily into a tight budget, its quality doesn’t match up to the real thing. For those who crave the rich, authentic taste of maple, this syrup might be a disappointment.
If you’re serious about your syrup, saving up for a higher-quality brand could make your morning pancakes something special, providing taste without compromise.
7. Market Pantry Syrup (Target)
Target’s Market Pantry Syrup is a convenient and affordable option, but it falls short in the flavor department. While it might be easier on the wallet compared to real maple syrup, the taste is flat and overly sweet, thanks to artificial flavorings.
This syrup doesn’t bring the same joy as the authentic stuff and could leave you wishing for more depth in taste. If you’re looking for a real maple experience, this isn’t the bottle to reach for.
Consider using it sparingly or in combination with other flavors to mask its shortcomings. A little creativity can go a long way in enhancing your breakfast enjoyment.
1. Coombs Family Farms 100% Pure Maple Syrup
Imagine waking up to a Vermont morning with the aroma of fresh pancakes and Coombs Family Farms 100% Pure Maple Syrup ready to pour. This syrup is a taste of authenticity from New England, offering a rich, robust flavor that embodies the essence of maple.
It’s organic and contains no additives, ensuring you get nothing but the real, honest maple experience.
Perfect for those cozy breakfasts, it pairs wonderfully with pancakes, waffles, and even adds a sweet twist to savory dishes. The syrup’s smooth texture and deep amber color make every meal a gourmet experience. Once you’ve tried it, you’ll understand why it’s a pantry staple for maple lovers.
Whether you’re topping classic pancakes or experimenting with new recipes, Coombs Family Farms syrup is your ticket to pure maple bliss.
2. Butternut Mountain Farm Maple Syrup
Butternut Mountain Farm Maple Syrup brings the flavor of Vermont to your table, offering a Grade A syrup that’s smooth and balanced. This trusted producer ensures every drop elevates your pancake stack to new heights. With its delightful taste, this syrup is more than just a topping; it’s an experience.
Whether you’re hosting a brunch or savoring a quiet breakfast, its versatility shines through, complementing both sweet and savory dishes. The syrup’s natural sweetness and subtle hints of maple make it a favorite among pancake enthusiasts.
Also perfect for baking, drizzling over oatmeal, or even sweetening your morning coffee, Butternut Mountain Farm syrup adds a touch of nature’s finest to every meal. Enjoy the balance of flavors that only a true Vermont syrup can provide.
3. Runamok Maple Syrup (Infused Varieties)
From Bourbon Barrel-Aged to Cinnamon Vanilla, each bottle promises a unique twist on the classic syrup. Pure maple syrup forms the base, with all-natural infusions enhancing the taste without overpowering it.
Perfect for adventurous foodies, these syrups bring excitement to pancakes and waffles alike. They also make fantastic additions to cocktails or desserts, providing a gourmet touch to everyday meals.
Runamok’s commitment to quality ensures that every pour is a journey of flavor exploration. Whether you’re indulging in brunch or looking to impress with your culinary skills, these infused syrups offer endless possibilities and a delightful departure from the ordinary.
4. Trader Joe’s Organic Maple Syrup
Trader Joe’s Organic Maple Syrup is a hidden gem for maple enthusiasts seeking quality and affordability. This syrup is 100% real maple, ensuring that every drizzle is packed with flavor. It boasts a good consistency, making it ideal for weekend brunching or everyday breakfasts.
Enjoy the rich, amber taste that complements everything from traditional pancakes to trendy breakfast bowls. Trader Joe’s syrup is not only delicious but also a wallet-friendly choice for those who appreciate fine ingredients.
Whether you’re a seasoned cook or a breakfast novice, this syrup offers simplicity and elegance in one bottle. Its organic certification adds peace of mind, knowing you’re savoring a product free from artificial additives. Elevate your breakfast game with this accessible yet exquisite maple syrup.
5. Maple Grove Farms 100% Pure Maple Syrup
Maple Grove Farms 100% Pure Maple Syrup is the perfect match for pancake lovers on a budget. You don’t have to sacrifice quality for affordability, as this syrup provides a genuine maple flavor without the premium price tag.
Its natural sweetness and smooth texture make it a delightful addition to your breakfast routine, whether you’re pouring it over pancakes, waffles, or French toast. This syrup also works wonders in baking recipes, adding a hint of maple magic to cakes and cookies.
With a commitment to quality, Maple Grove Farms ensures that every bottle brings a touch of the great outdoors to your table. Its taste and versatility make it a staple in kitchens looking for authentic maple syrup without breaking the bank.
6. Crown Maple Syrup
This ultra-premium syrup is almost too fancy for pancakes, yet it transforms any breakfast into a culinary delight. Sustainably sourced, Crown Maple is loaded with nuanced flavors that make each taste a moment to savor.
Perfect for special occasions or when you simply want to treat yourself, it pairs beautifully with a variety of dishes beyond pancakes, such as crepes and desserts. The syrup’s richness and complexity also complement savory items, making it a versatile addition to any meal.
For those who appreciate the finer things in life, Crown Maple Syrup offers an unforgettable experience. Indulge in its decadent taste and feel good about the sustainable practices behind this exquisite product.
7. Kirkland Signature Organic Maple Syrup (Costco)
Surprisingly top-tier, this syrup offers a rich, amber taste that’s perfect for your pancake mornings.
It’s a killer deal for a full quart, making it an economical choice for families or syrup enthusiasts. Despite being a bulk item, the syrup maintains high standards, offering pure maple goodness in every pour.
Whether you’re feeding a crowd or simply stocking up, Kirkland’s syrup provides the consistency and flavor you crave. Its organic certification ensures that you’re enjoying a product free from artificial additives, making it a smart choice for those who value both quality and quantity.
Leave a comment