Massive Ice Cream Recall Hits U.S.—Plastic Found in These 22 Products

A trusted name in frozen treats, Wells Enterprises—also known as Wells Dairy—has issued a voluntary recall of 22 ice cream and frozen yogurt varieties across the U.S.

The reason? Possible plastic contamination that could pose a safety risk to consumers.

The recall was initiated on April 25 and has been classified as a Class II recall by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), meaning consumption may lead to temporary or medically reversible health consequences, although the likelihood of serious harm is considered low.

Why the Recall Was Issued

The recall stems from concerns that hard plastic fragments may be present in some of the affected ice cream products. While not lethal, these foreign materials can potentially cause choking, dental injuries, or oral lacerations, prompting the manufacturer to take swift precautionary action.

In an interview with Newsweek, Professor Byron D. Chaves, a food safety expert at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln, emphasized the risks:

“Hard plastic may come from ingredients or equipment used in production, like mixing paddles. While rare, even packaging can be a source.”

He added that these materials can become physical hazards if consumed, possibly causing cuts, choking, or damage to the tongue, gums, and teeth.

Although the situation is serious, Chaves explained that the Class II designation implies that either the product was intercepted before reaching consumers or the plastic pieces are large and visible enough to be avoided.

Who Is Affected

The recalled products are packaged in 3-gallon tubs, intended primarily for restaurants, cafeterias, and food service centers, not typical retail grocery stores.

However, distributors and food service operators are being urged to check their inventories immediately and remove affected stock from circulation.

Full List of Recalled Products

Here is the complete list of products affected by the recall, each noted for potential plastic contamination:

• Rocky Road Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640050314, Lot 50009
• Mocha Almond Fudge Ice Cream – UPC: 070640050420, Lot 50016
• Peanut Butter ‘N Fudge Ice Cream – UPC: 070640050574, Lot 50012
• Country Rich Vanilla Ice Cream – UPC: 070640600052, Lot 50085
• Scooper Hero Ice Cream – UPC: 070640050642, Lot 50011
• Cotton Candy Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640050482, Lot 50018
• GFGB Vanilla Bean Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640000272, Lot 50024
• Quick Blend Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640050604, Lot 50034
• Planet Smoothie ZSA Vanilla Fat Free Frozen Yogurt – UPC: 070640005567, Lot 50014
• Johnny Rockets Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640006564, Lot 50029
• BIPC Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640008025, Lot 50024
• Vanilla Frozen Yogurt – UPC: 00070640022144, Lot 50002
• Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640022250, Lot 50005
• GFGB 12 Percent Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 070640018451, Lot 50004
• Gordon Choice Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 00093901820730, Lot 50003
• Vanilla Bean Ice Cream (Madagascar Vanilla) – UPC: 50758108658085, Lot 50026
• Glenview Farms Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 50758108118398, Lot 50066
• Glenview Farms Chocolate Ice Cream – UPC: 50758108118404, Lot 50033
• Glenview Farms French Vanilla Ice Cream – UPC: 50758108392668, Lot 50015
• Sysco French Vanilla Ice Cream – UPC: 00074865257275, Lot 50025
• Keith Valley Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 046045065871, Lot 50004
• Ellington Farms Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream – UPC: 046045065833, Lot 50003

The largest affected batch includes 5,280 tubs of Vanilla Frozen Yogurt. All recalled items have “Best If Used By” dates ranging from March to October 2026.

How Does Contamination Happen?

Contamination with foreign objects like plastic can occur at various stages of manufacturing—during blending, adding toppings, or through damaged equipment. According to Chaves, even packaging materials like cracked lids can introduce fragments into the product.

Though rare, these occurrences highlight the need for strict supplier controls and strong manufacturing practices, particularly in ready-to-eat items like ice cream.

What You Should Do

If you’re a distributor or food service provider, the following steps are recommended:

• Check all inventory for matching UPCs and lot numbers.
• Isolate and remove any affected batches immediately.
• Contact Wells Enterprises or your product distributor for guidance on returns or refunds.

Consumers who think they may have been affected should consult a healthcare provider if they experience any unusual symptoms or injuries after eating these products.

While the risk is relatively low, the recall underscores the importance of transparency, timely intervention, and consumer safety in the food industry. Wells Enterprises’ quick response and the FDA’s involvement aim to ensure that potential issues are addressed before causing harm.

Stay informed by checking the FDA’s official recall listings or contacting Wells Enterprises for ongoing updates.