Skip to Content

I Tried 6 Store-Bought Mac and Cheeses and Found Just One Worth the Hype

Exploring the world of store-bought mac and cheese can be an adventure filled with surprises, both delightful and disappointing. With a plethora of options on the shelves, each promising creamy, cheesy perfection, the challenge becomes finding the one truly worth the hype. Join me as I delve into six popular brands to uncover which ones live up to their promises.

6. Annie’s Macaroni & Classic Cheddar

Annie’s Macaroni & Classic Cheddar
© Walmart

Starting with Annie’s, the packaging is inviting. The bright colors hint at a vibrant dish inside. What you actually get is a classic that leans on nostalgia but falls short in texture. While the cheese flavor is pleasant, the pasta lacks the desired creaminess.

The taste might remind you of childhood dinners, yet it doesn’t quite hit the mark. If you’re looking for simplicity, this might suffice, but it’s not the standout in the lineup. A reliable choice, perhaps, but certainly not groundbreaking in flavor or texture.

5. Banza Cheddar Elbows

Banza Cheddar Elbows
© Banza pasta

Banza offers a twist with chickpea pasta, aiming for a healthier spin. Initially, the texture is intriguing, a departure from traditional flour-based macaroni. For those open to adventure, this alternative can be appealing.

The cheese sauce, however, doesn’t quite make a memorable impression, lacking the depth expected from a classic comfort food. It’s a great choice if you prioritize nutrition, but flavor seekers might find it lacking. A health-conscious option that doesn’t entirely capture the essence of what makes mac and cheese beloved.

4. Cheetos Bold & Cheesy Mac ‘N Cheese

Cheetos Bold & Cheesy Mac ‘N Cheese
© Walmart

Cheetos lovers rejoice! This mac and cheese captures the essence of the classic snack, transforming it into a pasta dish. The bold orange color is eye-catching, sure to appeal to fans of the Cheetos brand.

The taste mirrors the beloved crunchy snack, offering a cheesy explosion. It’s a playful take on tradition, perfect for those who enjoy a bit of fun in their meals. While it might not satisfy purists, it certainly hits the mark for those looking for a quirky twist on a classic.

3. Kraft Original Mac & Cheese

Kraft Original Mac & Cheese
© Garden Grocer

Kraft’s iconic offering remains a staple in many homes. Its familiar yellow sauce evokes a sense of comfort, reminiscent of countless meals shared over the years. There’s a simplicity to its flavor that continues to resonate with fans.

Though it doesn’t claim to elevate the mac and cheese game, it does deliver a reliable and comforting experience. This isn’t the option for gourmet seekers but remains a cherished classic. Sometimes, familiarity and simplicity win the day, and Kraft certainly embodies that notion.

2. Mac-A-Roni Creamy Cheddar

Mac-A-Roni Creamy Cheddar
© Shoppers

Mac-A-Roni aims to impress with a creamy cheddar experience. From the first bite, the smooth texture of the cheese sauce is apparent, enveloping the pasta in richness.

This brand promises and delivers on creaminess, setting a high bar for others. It’s a delight for those who crave a more indulgent mac and cheese experience. While some might find it a bit too rich, others will revel in its luxurious texture. For those who seek a decadent twist on tradition, this is a frontrunner.

1. Goodles Cheddy Mac

Goodles Cheddy Mac
© The Kitchn

Goodles Cheddy Mac takes the crown with its exceptional balance of flavor and texture. The pasta is cooked to perfection, and the cheese is both creamy and flavorful without being overwhelming.

This brand stands out for its ability to satisfy without compromise, offering a taste that delights both new and seasoned mac and cheese fans. It’s no wonder this one is worth the hype. If you are looking for the ultimate mac and cheese, Goodles delivers in every way. Truly a star in the store-bought world.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *