Skip to Content

We Tried All 14 Goldfish Cracker Flavors — Here’s How They Ranked

Goldfish crackers, the beloved snack with a smile, come in a variety of flavors that delight taste buds everywhere. Not all Goldfish are created equal, though. Here’s a fun and engaging ranking of 14 Goldfish cracker flavors to help you decide which ones are worth munching and which to leave on the shelf.

14. Cinnamon Roll Grahams

Cinnamon Roll Grahams
© Walmart

When it comes to capturing the essence of a bakery-fresh cinnamon roll, these Goldfish Grahams are a commendable attempt. The flavor is reminiscent of weekend mornings filled with the aroma of cinnamon and sugar swirling through the air. As you crunch into these snacks, they evoke a comforting sensation akin to biting into a fresh pastry.

Though delightful, they might not fully replace the real thing. With subtle notes of cozy spices, it’s an appealing choice for those with a sweet tooth. However, if you’re looking for a robust cinnamon experience, this might fall a bit short.

13. Strawberry Shortcake Grahams

Strawberry Shortcake Grahams
© Amazon.com

The classic summer dessert is transformed into a bite-sized cracker with these Strawberry Shortcake Grahams, capturing the whimsical essence of a sun-drenched picnic. The combination of strawberry and cream flavors brings a playful sweetness that is both fruity and indulgent.

While they offer a pleasant divergence from the ordinary, their impact may not be as strong as expected. For those who dream of the real dessert, this might serve better as a lighthearted snack than a true substitute. Their cheerful nature makes them a delightful treat for casual munching.

12. Mega Bites Cheddar Jalapeño

Mega Bites Cheddar Jalapeño
© Amazon.com

Spice enthusiasts will revel in the zesty kick of the Mega Bites Cheddar Jalapeño Goldfish. This bold flavor brings together the tangy sharpness of cheddar with the fiery notes of jalapeño, making each bite a tantalizing assault on the taste buds. It’s the perfect snack for those who crave a bit of heat.

Despite the excitement, the spiciness can be overwhelming for some, overshadowing the cheesy undertones. Ideal for adventurous eaters, these crackers offer a daring twist on the classic cheddar taste. Proceed with caution if sensitive to spice!

11. Mega Bites Sharp Cheddar

Mega Bites Sharp Cheddar
© King Soopers

For cheese lovers, Mega Bites Sharp Cheddar offers a rich and intense flavor experience. Think of a sophisticated cheese platter condensed into a playful cracker. The sharpness of the cheddar is striking and indulges those who appreciate a bolder cheese taste.

The robust flavor profile is perfect for anyone who finds regular cheddar a bit too mild. However, its intensity might dominate other subtle flavors. A great choice for pairing with your favorite soup or enjoying solo, it elevates snack time to a cheese connoisseur’s delight.

10. Flavor Blasted Xtra Cheddar

Flavor Blasted Xtra Cheddar
© H-E-B

If cheese is your calling, look no further than the Flavor Blasted Xtra Cheddar Goldfish. Packed with extra cheesy goodness, these crackers are a celebration of all things cheddar. The intense cheese flavor is unmistakable, and each bite provides a burst of savory delight.

These are not for the faint-hearted, as the cheese powder can leave fingers happily coated in orange dust. They’re perfect for those who can’t get enough cheesy flavor. Pair them with a cold beverage, and you’ve got a snacking experience that’s hard to beat.

9. Cheddar Baked With Whole Grain

Cheddar Baked With Whole Grain
© Walmart

Whole grain enthusiasts will appreciate the Cheddar Baked With Whole Grain Goldfish, combining the classic cheddar taste with a heartier texture. The whole grain aspect delivers a satisfying crunch, making it a wholesome snack option for health-conscious eaters.

Though slightly more subdued in flavor than their non-whole grain counterparts, they offer a guilt-free way to enjoy a cheesy snack. These crackers provide a subtle nod to nutrition without compromising on taste, perfect for a mindful yet enjoyable snacking experience.

8. Parmesan

Parmesan
© H-E-B

For those with a penchant for Italian flavors, the Parmesan Goldfish crackers bring a taste of Italy to your snack plate. The tangy sharpness of Parmesan cheese is evident in every crunchy bite, creating a rich and savory experience.

These crackers stand out as a sophisticated twist on the traditional cheese snack. They’re ideal for those who appreciate the nuanced flavors of aged cheese. Enjoy them as a standalone snack or as an accompaniment to a cheese platter for an added touch of elegance.

7. Pretzel

Pretzel
© Walmart

A classic choice for any snacking occasion, Pretzel Goldfish crackers offer a satisfying crunch with a hint of saltiness. Their simple yet delightful flavor makes them an ideal snack for those who enjoy the traditional pretzel taste in a fun, fish-shaped form.

These crackers are versatile enough to accompany a variety of dips or can be enjoyed on their own. Whether you’re hosting a party or simply looking for a quick snack, Pretzel Goldfish deliver a timeless appeal that never goes out of style.

6. Baby Cheddar

Baby Cheddar
© Walmart

Tiny yet mighty, Baby Cheddar Goldfish crackers pack a punch with their classic cheddar flavor in a smaller, bite-sized form. Perfect for little hands, they make snacking fun and easy for kids, while still satisfying the cheddar cravings of adults.

Their compact size doesn’t compromise on taste, delivering the same delightful cheese flavor as their larger counterparts. These are great for on-the-go snacking or for packing in lunchboxes, offering a playful twist on a traditional favorite.

5. Flavor Blasted Xtra Cheesy Pizza

Flavor Blasted Xtra Cheesy Pizza
© Amazon.com

For pizza lovers, Flavor Blasted Xtra Cheesy Pizza Goldfish provide a taste of your favorite pie in a playful snack form. The combination of cheese, tomato, and herbs evokes the essence of a freshly baked pizza, creating a savory and satisfying experience.

These crackers offer a fun twist on the classic pizza flavor, making them a hit at parties and gatherings. The bold taste ensures they stand out in any snack lineup, perfect for those who can’t resist a cheesy, pizza-flavored treat.

4. Cheddar

Cheddar
© Walmart

The timeless favorite, Cheddar Goldfish crackers continue to hold a special place in the hearts of snack lovers. The classic cheddar flavor delivers a comforting taste that never goes out of style.

These crackers are perfect for any occasion, whether you’re packing them in a lunchbox or enjoying them during a movie night. Their familiar taste and delightful crunch make them a reliable choice for both kids and adults. A true staple in the world of snacks, Cheddar Goldfish never disappoint.

3. Pizza

Pizza
© Walmart

Pizza Goldfish crackers bring the essence of a cheesy, tomato-rich pizza to the snack aisle. The blend of herbs, cheese, and tomato flavors makes them a delightful choice for pizza enthusiasts looking to satisfy their cravings in a miniature form.

These crackers capture the spirit of a pizza party, infusing every bite with a taste of fun. Perfect for those who can’t get enough of the iconic pizza flavor, they are a staple for casual snacking with a twist.

2. Original

Original Goldfish crackers offer a simple yet satisfying snacking experience. Their mild flavor and iconic fish shape make them a beloved choice among snackers of all ages.

The versatility of these crackers allows them to pair well with a variety of dips or to be enjoyed alone. Their classic nature ensures they remain a staple in pantries everywhere, providing a reliable snack option that’s hard to resist.

1. Frank’s RedHot

Frank's RedHot
© CSP Daily News

For those who enjoy a spicy kick, Frank’s RedHot Goldfish bring the heat with their bold and fiery flavor. Infused with the famous hot sauce, these crackers deliver a mouth-watering punch that’s perfect for spice lovers.

The heat is nicely balanced with a hint of tanginess, making them an exciting snack for adventurous palates. They’re perfect for those who want to add a little spice to their snack routine. Just be prepared for the spicy sensation that follows each crunchy bite!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *