Cracker Barrel, a beloved American chain known for its Southern comfort food and charming country store, has a diverse menu that appeals to various tastes. However, not every dish has garnered praise.
Based on customer reviews, here are eight items you might consider skipping during your next visit. These dishes have sparked conversations and opinions, and we’re here to explore what makes them less appealing according to frequent diners.
1. French Toast

Who doesn’t love French toast? But reviews suggest Cracker Barrel’s rendition doesn’t hit the mark. Diners mention it’s often soggy, lacking the crisp exterior synonymous with a perfect French toast.
Some patrons found it excessively sweet, overshadowing the subtle flavors of the bread and spices. While the appearance might be inviting, the texture seems to disappoint.
If you’re a French toast aficionado, you might find this version underwhelming.
2. Biscuit Beignets

Biscuit Beignets sound like a delightful Southern treat, but some reviews recommend a pass. Customers frequently comment on their dense texture, which deviates from the expected light and airy profile of a beignet.
A few have noted an overpowering fried taste, which detracts from the sweet, buttery flavor one anticipates. Those hoping for a classic beignet experience might be left yearning for that New Orleans magic.
3. Broccoli

Broccoli at Cracker Barrel has been described as a letdown by some diners. Overcooked and lacking in that vibrant green hue, it often arrives looking rather unappealing.
Many have lamented its mushy texture, which strips away the fresh, crunchy experience of this healthy side. If you’re expecting a bright and crisp side dish, this might not be the broccoli for you.
4. Country Fried Steak

A hallmark of Southern cuisine, the country fried steak at Cracker Barrel doesn’t always leave diners impressed. Feedback often points to its greasy nature, with some finding the gravy too heavy.
The meat itself sometimes lacks the tenderness expected from this beloved dish, leading to dissatisfaction for some.
For those in search of an exemplary country fried steak, this may not meet the Southern standard they crave.
5. Cornbread Muffins

Cornbread Muffins at Cracker Barrel sometimes miss the mark, according to patrons. The texture often ventures into dry territory, lacking the moist, crumbly goodness many expect.
Some have critiqued the flavor, noting a blandness that doesn’t quite complement the rest of the meal. If you’re craving that sweet, buttery cornbread magic, you might find these muffins a bit disappointing.
6. Chicken N’ Dumplings

According to reviews, Chicken N’ Dumplings is a Cracker Barrel classic that doesn’t always deliver. Patrons often describe the dish as overly thick, with dumplings that lack the tender texture desired.
The flavor can be mundane, missing the savory depth that makes this dish a comfort food favorite.
For those anticipating a heartwarming experience, this version might not satisfy your culinary nostalgia.
7. Hashbrown Casserole Shepherd’s Pie

A fusion dish at Cracker Barrel, the Hashbrown Casserole Shepherd’s Pie seems to struggle in execution. Reviews often highlight uneven layers and a lack of cohesive flavor.
Diners have noted that the hashbrowns can be undercooked, which detracts from the overall experience. If you’re intrigued by this combination, it’s advised to temper expectations for a satisfying result.
8. Shrimp N’ Grits Skillet

Shrimp N’ Grits Skillet at Cracker Barrel has received mixed reviews. Some diners feel the dish lacks seasoning, leaving it bland and unexciting.
The grits themselves can be inconsistent, sometimes arriving with an undesirable texture. For those who are passionate about this Southern staple, this version might not satisfy the craving for a rich and flavorful meal.
Leave a comment