If you’ve ever stared down the endless menu at Subway, unsure whether to play it safe or go bold, you’re not alone. With dozens of meats, sauces, and sandwich styles to choose from, it’s easy to get overwhelmed—and end up with a sub that’s more snooze than satisfying.
To make your next order a whole lot easier (and way tastier), we’ve rounded up the ultimate list of Subway sandwiches worth sinking your teeth into—and a few that are better left behind. These picks are based on pure flavor, not calorie counts or macros. Think juicy meats, melty cheese, bold sauces, and all the crave-worthy combinations that make a sub seriously unforgettable.
So whether you’re craving something rich and savory or fiery and adventurous, we’ve got the insider guide on what to order—and what to skip—next time you hit the sandwich line. Trust us, your taste buds will thank you.
1. Order: Elite Chicken & Bacon Ranch
The Elite Chicken & Bacon Ranch sandwich is a savory masterpiece. Imagine perfectly grilled chicken paired with crispy bacon and melted cheese. Each bite offers a delightful crunch from fresh veggies nestled within soft, warm bread.
This option is perfect for those seeking a hearty and satisfying meal. The combination of flavors creates a balanced taste that’s both rich and refreshing.
It’s a definite must-try on your next Subway visit.
2. Order: The Boss
If bold, saucy, and satisfying is your sandwich love language, The Boss delivers in spades. This powerhouse of a sub is loaded with juicy meatballs, spicy pepperoni, savory marinara sauce, and a generous layer of melted mozzarella—all tucked into soft, toasted Italian-style bread.
It’s like the lovechild of a meatball sub and a New York-style deli hero.
3. Order: Rotisserie-Style Chicken
The Rotisserie-Style Chicken sandwich is a classic choice for a reason. Juicy rotisserie chicken pairs beautifully with fresh greens and a soft, flavorful bun.
Whether you’re watching calories or simply want something wholesome, this sandwich provides comfort and flavor. It’s a great choice for chicken lovers.
4. Order: Italian B.M.T.
The Italian B.M.T. is a fan favorite at Subway, known for its layers of delicious meats and cheese. Salami, pepperoni, and ham come together to create a savory symphony.
This sandwich is perfect for meat lovers who appreciate a robust flavor profile. It’s filling and satisfying, making it suitable for any mealtime.
5. Order: Steak & Cheese
Steak & Cheese is a classic choice for those craving something hearty and savory. Tender slices of steak are topped with melted cheese, creating a luscious blend of flavors.
Whether for lunch or dinner, this option is bound to please those who enjoy a rich, meaty sandwich. Don’t miss out on this fulfilling choice.
6. Order: Spicy Italian
The Spicy Italian sandwich is not for the faint-hearted. Packed with pepperoni, salami, and hot peppers, it’s a fiery delight for spice enthusiasts.
If you’re seeking something adventurous and full of zest, the Spicy Italian is your go-to. It’s a lively choice that promises excitement and flavor.
7. Order: The Outlaw
If you’re looking for a sandwich with serious attitude, The Outlaw is here to bring the heat. This smoky, savory creation features tender steak, crispy bacon, pepper jack cheese, and a zesty layer of green peppers and red onions, all topped with creamy Baja Chipotle sauce on toasted bread.
The Outlaw doesn’t hold back—it’s intense, indulgent, and ideal for anyone craving a sandwich that breaks all the rules in the best way. If you’re into smoky-spicy combos, this one’s a must-order.
8. Skip: Titan Turkey
The Titan Turkey might sound impressive, but it often falls short. With simple turkey slices and basic veggies, it lacks the excitement many seek in a sandwich.
While it offers a lean protein option, the flavor profile can feel bland and uninspiring. It’s suitable for those preferring simplicity, but might not satisfy adventurous eaters.
If you’re looking for something with more flair, consider other options that provide a richer taste experience. This one might not be the most thrilling choice.
9. Skip: All-Pro Sweet Onion Teriyaki
The All-Pro Sweet Onion Teriyaki is loved by some, but not for everyone. The sweet onion teriyaki sauce can be overpowering for those who prefer subtle flavors.
This sandwich combines chicken with a sweet sauce, which may not align with everyone’s palate. It’s a hit or miss, depending on your taste preferences.
10. Skip: Black Forest Ham
The Black Forest Ham sandwich is a staple but not the most exciting. Featuring basic ham and standard toppings, it offers a straightforward, no-frills experience.
While it serves as a reliable choice for those wanting simplicity, it doesn’t stand out in terms of flavor or creativity. It might be worth skipping if you’re looking for something more adventurous and bold.
11. Skip: Tuna
The Tuna Sub is one of Subway’s most polarizing menu items—and for good reason. Made with a creamy mix of tuna and mayonnaise, it offers a rich, soft texture but can come across as one-note and heavy, especially without the right toppings to balance it out.
While some loyal fans appreciate its classic deli-style vibe, others find the flavor bland or overly fishy, and the mayo-heavy mix can feel mushy rather than fresh. Without bold veggies or zesty sauces, this sub risks falling flat in the flavor department.
12. Skip: Veggie Delite
The Veggie Delite is a go-to for vegetarians, but it can be underwhelming for others. Made with assorted vegetables, it offers a fresh yet simple taste.
While it’s a healthy option, the lack of protein can make it feel like a side dish rather than a main course. If you’re not a vegetarian, you might want to try something with more flavor depth.
13. Skip: Cold Cut Combo
The Cold Cut Combo is a traditional choice, but it may not excite all palates. Featuring assorted cold cuts, it offers a straightforward taste that’s familiar to many.
Consider this sandwich if you appreciate a no-nonsense, meat-focused meal. Otherwise, there are more flavorful and innovative options to explore at Subway.
14. Skip: Roast Beef
The Roast Beef sandwich is a classic, yet it tends to be more ordinary than extraordinary. With roast beef and standard toppings, it provides a reliable taste.
While it’s a solid choice for meat lovers, it doesn’t offer the unique flair that some other Subway options do.
If you favor a straightforward, familiar flavor, you might enjoy it. However, for those seeking something more distinctive, there are other choices that deliver more excitement.
Leave a comment