There’s something magical about that first cold, creamy bite of ice cream on a blazing summer day, the kind that makes the heat fade and your taste buds cheer. Whether you’re scooping up a swirl of homemade salted caramel or cracking open a pint of your favorite store-bought classic, ice cream is the ultimate summer companion. This year, don’t settle for the same old vanilla routine. From bold brambleberry swirls to the comforting richness of honeycomb crunch, these 9 homemade recipes and 9 store-bought champions will turn every scoop into a moment worth savoring, one blissful bite at a time.
1. Salted Caramel Swirl Sensation
Golden ribbons of homemade salted caramel dance through velvety vanilla ice cream, creating magic in every spoonful. The contrast between sweet and salty elements transforms a simple dessert into something extraordinary.
Making this at home allows you to control the caramel’s depth—let it cook longer for deeper flavor or pull it sooner for lighter notes. The salt cuts through the sweetness perfectly, preventing the caramel from becoming cloying.
Serve this sophisticated treat in warmed bowls to slightly soften the edges while keeping the center firmly frozen. A sprinkle of flaky sea salt on top just before serving adds both visual appeal and flavor intensity.
2. Mint Chocolate Chunk
Fresh mint leaves steeped in warm cream create a natural flavor that store-bought versions can’t match. Unlike artificial mint that tastes like toothpaste, real mint infusion offers subtle complexity with bright, herbaceous notes.
Hand-chopped dark chocolate chunks provide irregular pieces that create texture surprises—some bites deliver substantial chocolate satisfaction while others offer delicate flecks. The combination of cooling mint with rich chocolate creates the perfect temperature and flavor contrast.
Growing your own mint makes this recipe even more special. Most varieties work beautifully, though chocolate mint adds an interesting dimension if you can find it at a garden center.
3. Brown Butter Pecan Paradise
Transforming ordinary butter into its nutty, caramelized version elevates this ice cream to gourmet status. Browning butter releases compounds that create complex toffee and butterscotch notes impossible to achieve any other way.
Toasted pecans amplify the nutty profile while adding satisfying crunch against the silky base. Unlike traditional butter pecan recipes, this version’s depth comes from the butter itself rather than excessive sugar or artificial flavoring.
For best results, cool the browned butter completely before incorporating it into your custard base. Make extra toasted pecans to sprinkle on top when serving—their warm, woody aroma enhances the sensory experience as you enjoy each spoonful.
4. Lavender Honey Bliss
Culinary lavender transforms ordinary cream into an aromatic delight reminiscent of Provençal fields. The key lies in restraint—too much lavender creates a soapy taste, while the perfect amount offers subtle floral notes that intrigue without overwhelming.
Local honey provides both sweetness and complexity, with different varieties creating entirely different profiles. Wildflower honey brings mild floral notes, while buckwheat honey adds earthy depth and orange blossom honey contributes citrus undertones.
Steep dried lavender buds in hot cream, then strain thoroughly before proceeding with your ice cream base. A touch of lemon zest brightens the flavor and prevents the floral notes from becoming too perfume-like, resulting in a sophisticated dessert.
5. Chocolate Fudge Brownie Overload
Cocoa powder and melted chocolate combine to create an intensely rich base that satisfies serious chocolate cravings. Using both ingredients provides complex flavor—cocoa for intensity and chocolate for smoothness.
Chewy brownie chunks maintain their texture even when frozen, creating delightful pockets of fudgy goodness throughout. Make brownies slightly underbaked specifically for this purpose, as they’ll firm up in the frozen ice cream but remain satisfyingly soft.
The hot fudge swirl creates temperature variations as it freezes differently than the base, resulting in a multi-textured experience. This indulgent creation might seem complicated, but it’s actually forgiving for beginners since any imperfections hide within the chocolate-on-chocolate layers.
6. Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake
Cream cheese creates a tangy base that mimics cheesecake’s distinctive flavor while maintaining ice cream’s smooth texture. Adding lemon zest provides bright citrus notes that cut through the richness, preventing heaviness.
Blueberry compote swirled throughout adds fruity bursts and beautiful purple-blue streaks. Fresh berries work wonderfully in summer, but frozen berries make this a year-round possibility without sacrificing flavor.
Graham cracker crust pieces complete the cheesecake illusion while adding textural contrast. Crushing some pieces finely and leaving others chunky creates varied texture throughout each scoop. For an impressive presentation, serve in small graham cracker crusts as individual ice cream tarts.
7. Maple Bacon Breakfast
Real maple syrup infuses cream with woodsy sweetness impossible to replicate with artificial flavoring. Grade B or dark amber maple syrup provides the strongest flavor, though any pure maple variety works beautifully.
Candied bacon pieces offer surprising savory notes and addictive crispness that keeps you coming back for more. The salt and smoke from the bacon balance the sweet maple base in unexpected ways, creating a flavor combination that sounds strange but tastes remarkable.
For best results, candy the bacon until very crisp and chop it just before adding to the nearly-frozen ice cream. This prevents sogginess and ensures the bacon maintains its texture contrast. A sprinkle of cinnamon adds warmth that ties everything together.
8. Pistachio Cardamom Dream
Freshly ground pistachios create a naturally pale green base with authentic nutty flavor far superior to artificially colored versions. Toasting the nuts before grinding intensifies their flavor and releases essential oils that perfume the entire mixture.
Cardamom adds aromatic complexity that complements pistachios perfectly—the spice’s citrusy, floral notes enhance the nuts’ natural sweetness. Grinding whole cardamom pods rather than using pre-ground powder makes a noticeable difference in freshness and intensity.
A touch of almond extract amplifies the nutty profile without overwhelming the delicate pistachio flavor. Reserve some chopped pistachios to fold in at the end for textural contrast and visual appeal, creating a sophisticated dessert that feels both exotic and comforting.
9. Earl Grey Tea & Honey
Bergamot-scented tea leaves steep directly in warm cream, infusing it with distinctive floral citrus notes. Using loose-leaf tea rather than tea bags provides better flavor control and higher quality bergamot oil.
Honey sweetens naturally while adding its own floral complexity that pairs beautifully with the tea. Different honey varieties create entirely different results—try orange blossom honey for complementary citrus notes or wildflower honey for added dimension.
A splash of vanilla enhances the creaminess while binding the tea and honey flavors together harmoniously. For an elegant presentation, serve small scoops in vintage teacups alongside shortbread cookies. The sophisticated flavor appeals to adults while remaining accessible enough for adventurous younger palates.
1. Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia
Named after Grateful Dead guitarist Jerry Garcia, this iconic flavor has maintained cult status since its 1987 debut. The genius lies in balancing sweet cream, tart cherries, and rich chocolate without any element overwhelming the others.
Whole cherry pieces provide bursts of fruit flavor and slight chewiness against the creamy background. The fudge flakes aren’t just ordinary chocolate chips—they’re irregular and thin, creating a satisfying snap when bitten rather than waxy hardness.
Finding this in your grocery freezer feels like discovering an old friend. While many brands have attempted cherry chocolate ice creams, none quite capture the perfect balance of this beloved original that somehow tastes like summer concerts and carefree days.
2. Häagen-Dazs Dulce de Leche
Ribbons of authentic caramelized milk weave through exceptionally dense vanilla ice cream, creating a luxurious texture that coats your palate. The slow-cooked caramel offers depth impossible to achieve with quick caramel sauces, featuring notes of toasted milk solids and gentle sweetness.
Häagen-Dazs uses minimal air incorporation during manufacturing, resulting in a significantly heavier product than competitors. This density creates a slow-melting experience that allows flavors to develop gradually on your tongue.
Particularly delicious slightly softened, this flavor transforms ordinary desserts into special occasions. Try it between warm cookies, alongside fruit crisps, or simply enjoyed straight from the container when nobody’s watching—its rich flavor stands beautifully on its own.
3. Jeni’s Brambleberry Crisp
Blackberries and black raspberries create a vibrant jam that marbles through Jeni’s signature vanilla ice cream. The berries maintain their bright, authentic flavor rather than tasting artificially sweetened or cooked down too far.
Oat streusel pieces provide surprising crunch and buttery, toasted notes throughout each scoop. Unlike many mix-ins that become soggy, these maintain their texture through special preparation techniques that prevent moisture absorption.
Founded by Jeni Britton, this Ohio-based company revolutionized artisanal ice cream with innovative flavors and techniques. Though pricier than supermarket brands, the quality justifies the splurge for special occasions. The balanced sweet-tart profile and contrasting textures make this a standout even among Jeni’s creative lineup.
4. Van Leeuwen Honeycomb
Crunchy honeycomb candy shatters between your teeth as you enjoy this Brooklyn-born brand’s sweet cream base. The candy pieces create a delightful textural surprise—some dissolve immediately while larger chunks maintain their structure.
Made through a process of caramelizing sugar with baking soda, the honeycomb candy develops air pockets that create its distinctive texture. These golden pieces offer notes of caramel, toffee, and subtle honey throughout the premium ice cream.
Van Leeuwen began as a food truck before expanding nationwide, maintaining their commitment to simple ingredients without stabilizers or artificial flavors. Their minimalist yellow packaging reflects the straightforward approach to quality that has earned them a devoted following among ice cream enthusiasts seeking pure flavors.
5. Tillamook Oregon Strawberry
Hood strawberries from the Pacific Northwest give this ice cream its authentic berry flavor and natural pink hue. These special berries offer more intense flavor than conventional varieties, with perfect sweet-tart balance.
Family-owned since 1909, Tillamook uses milk from their farmer-owned cooperative, ensuring consistent quality and ethical production. Their slow-churning process incorporates less air than budget brands, resulting in a denser, creamier texture that melts slowly.
Unlike artificial strawberry flavors that taste candy-like, this version captures real fruit essence with visible berry pieces throughout. The simple ingredient list focuses on quality rather than additives, making this a go-to choice for strawberry purists seeking genuine flavor without artificial aftertaste.
6. Talenti Sea Salt Caramel Gelato
Argentine-inspired gelato offers a silkier texture than traditional ice cream thanks to lower fat content and less air incorporation. The dense mouthfeel creates a luxurious experience that coats your palate without heaviness.
Ribbons of sea salt caramel weave throughout the sweet cream base, creating flavor variations with each spoonful. Some bites deliver stronger salt notes while others highlight the buttery caramel, making each serving a unique experience.
Talenti’s signature clear containers showcase the beautiful caramel swirls while allowing you to see exactly what you’re getting. The plastic jars often find second lives as storage containers after the gelato disappears. Slightly softer than traditional ice cream even when fully frozen, this treat reaches optimal texture after five minutes at room temperature.
7. Trader Joe’s Coffee Bean Blast
Finely ground coffee beans infuse this ice cream with robust flavor while creating subtle texture throughout each scoop. Unlike coffee-flavored varieties that taste artificial, this version delivers authentic roasted notes and gentle bitterness balanced by cream.
Trader Joe’s sources beans specifically for this product, selecting varieties that maintain their distinctive coffee character even when frozen. The result tastes like a frozen version of quality cold brew rather than generic coffee flavoring.
Caffeine sensitive individuals should note this contains actual coffee, not just flavoring. The affordable price point makes this a standout among premium ice creams, delivering gourmet quality at Trader Joe’s characteristic value. Coffee enthusiasts particularly appreciate the unapologetically bold flavor that doesn’t fade into blandness.
8. Kirkland Signature Super Premium Vanilla (Costco)
Real Madagascar vanilla beans create distinctive black specks throughout this exceptionally rich ice cream. The vanilla flavor develops complexity rather than tasting flat or artificial, with notes of rum, caramel, and subtle floral elements.
Costco’s house brand delivers remarkably high butterfat content comparable to brands twice its price. The dense, velvety texture comes from quality ingredients and minimal air incorporation during manufacturing.
Professional bakers often select this as their secret weapon for elevating homemade desserts. Perfect for pairing with warm pies, brownies, or fresh fruit, its clean flavor complements without competing. The substantial two-pack offers excellent value for families or entertaining, though the quality might have you finding excuses to serve dessert more frequently.
9. Aldi’s Specially Selected Vanilla Super Premium
Budget-friendly yet surprisingly luxurious, this European-inspired ice cream delivers remarkable quality at a fraction of premium brand prices. The rich vanilla flavor comes from actual vanilla extract rather than artificial flavoring, creating authentic taste without chemical aftertaste.
Higher butterfat content than typical grocery store brands creates silky texture and slower melting. The minimalist ingredient list focuses on quality components rather than stabilizers or fillers.
Aldi’s rotating stock means this isn’t always available, creating a treasure-hunt mentality among devoted fans. Smart shoppers grab multiple containers when they spot it. The simple black packaging with gold accents reflects the European premium positioning without flashy gimmicks, letting the product’s quality speak for itself.
Leave a comment