When summer hits hard, a cold treat from Dairy Queen feels like the ultimate reward. But not every Blizzard or sundae deserves your hard-earned cash—or the calories. Some DQ favorites actually deliver the sweet, creamy relief you’re craving on a scorching day, while others melt into a disappointing puddle of regret. We taste-tested, compared, and sifted through fan favorites to find out which treats live up to the hype and which ones are total letdowns you’ll wish you skipped. Before your next drive-thru run, here’s what’s worth it—and what you should leave off your order.
1. S’mores Blizzard
Imagine the perfect summer campfire transformed into a frosty treat! The S’mores Blizzard captures nostalgic outdoor memories with its heavenly blend of graham cracker pieces, marshmallow-filled chocolate chunks, and DQ’s signature vanilla soft serve.
Each spoonful delivers that magical combination of crunch, gooey sweetness, and creamy ice cream that perfectly mimics the beloved campfire snack. The graham crackers maintain their texture even when mixed, providing that authentic s’mores experience.
Available only during certain seasons, this Blizzard has developed a cult following who eagerly await its return each year. Smart fans know to indulge while they can!
2. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Blizzard
Peanut butter lovers, rejoice! This legendary Blizzard combines two American favorites: creamy DQ soft serve and chunky Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. The temperature contrast between cold ice cream and room-temperature peanut butter creates a uniquely satisfying mouthfeel.
What makes this treat special is how the chocolate coating on the Reese’s cups breaks into shards throughout the mixture while the peanut butter filling maintains its distinct flavor.
The result is a symphony of textures and tastes in every bite. A permanent fixture on the DQ menu, this Blizzard consistently ranks among their top sellers year after year. One taste explains why!
3. Oreo Blizzard
Sometimes the simplest combinations create the most enduring classics. The Oreo Blizzard exemplifies this principle with its straightforward yet irresistible mix of crushed Oreo cookies blended into vanilla soft serve.
The magic happens when those iconic chocolate cookies soften slightly in the ice cream while still maintaining their distinct flavor and just enough crunch. Unlike some Blizzard varieties where add-ins might sink to the bottom, Oreo pieces distribute evenly throughout the mixture.
For decades, this has remained Dairy Queen’s best-selling Blizzard flavor worldwide. Its universal appeal spans generations, making it the perfect choice when you can’t decide what to order.
4. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Blizzard
Raw cookie dough has a forbidden allure that makes this Blizzard especially tempting. Generous chunks of cookie dough and chocolate chips create a textural wonderland when mixed into DQ’s silky soft serve.
The brilliance lies in the contrasts – cold ice cream against room-temperature dough, smooth vanilla against chunks of chocolate. Each spoonful delivers a slightly different combination of these elements, making every bite a new discovery.
Cookie dough lovers appreciate that DQ doesn’t skimp on the mix-ins here. You’ll find substantial pieces throughout the entire treat, not just a few token chunks. This consistency makes it a reliable choice for beating summer heat.
5. Cotton Candy Blizzard
Bright blue and whimsically sweet, the Cotton Candy Blizzard transports you straight to childhood fairgrounds. This limited-time treat features cotton candy-flavored bits mixed into vanilla soft serve, creating a colorful dessert that’s as fun to look at as it is to eat.
The pastel blue hue comes from the cotton candy pieces that dissolve partially into the ice cream. What remains are small, crunchy candy bits that provide unexpected texture against the smooth base.
While definitely on the sweeter side of the Blizzard spectrum, the cold temperature of the ice cream balances the sugar rush. Kids absolutely adore this flavor, making it a perfect family-friendly summer choice during its seasonal appearances.
6. Salted Caramel Truffle Blizzard
Sophisticated palates appreciate this grown-up Blizzard that masterfully balances contrasting flavors. Salted caramel truffles, crunchy toffee pieces, and ribbons of chocolate fudge create a multi-layered taste experience in every spoonful.
The genius of this creation lies in its perfect sweet-to-salty ratio. The salt enhances the caramel’s depth without overwhelming, while the chocolate adds richness. The toffee pieces provide textural interest that keeps the dessert from becoming one-dimensional.
Unlike purely sugary options, this Blizzard offers complex flavor development that evolves as you eat it. The salted caramel notes linger pleasantly, making this a more memorable choice than simpler varieties.
7. Non-Dairy Dilly Bar
Finally, a dairy-free option that doesn’t feel like a compromise! The Non-Dairy Dilly Bar features coconut milk-based vanilla frozen dessert dipped in rich chocolate coating, creating a refreshing treat accessible to those avoiding dairy.
The coconut base provides a naturally creamy texture that rivals traditional soft serve. Surprisingly, the coconut flavor remains subtle, letting the vanilla shine through. The chocolate shell cracks satisfyingly with each bite, just like the original.
Perfect for hot days, this plant-based treat melts more slowly than dairy versions, giving you extra minutes to enjoy before it drips. Lactose-intolerant ice cream lovers rejoice – you can join the DQ experience without discomfort!
1. Butterfinger Blizzard
The Butterfinger candy bar is famous for its distinctively crispy texture and bold peanut butter flavor. Unfortunately, these signature qualities get lost in translation when blended into a Blizzard. The problem starts when those crispy Butterfinger pieces absorb moisture from the soft serve.
Instead of maintaining their satisfying crunch, they transform into soggy, indistinct bits that lack the candy’s characteristic texture. The flavor becomes muted too, with just hints of peanut butter instead of the intense taste you’d expect.
What should be a textural playground ends up feeling one-dimensional and bland. Your money is better spent on Blizzard varieties where the mix-ins hold their own against the ice cream.
2. Brownie and Oreo Cupfection
The Brownie and Oreo Cupfection looks impressive in advertisements – a towering creation of brownies, Oreos, soft serve, and marshmallow topping. Reality delivers a sugar bomb that overwhelms rather than delights.
Each component competes for attention rather than complementing the others. The brownies quickly become soggy under the ice cream, while the marshmallow topping adds unnecessary sweetness to an already sugar-heavy creation.
Even dedicated sweet-tooths find this combination excessive. The portion size compounds the problem – it’s simply too much of too many things. About halfway through, palate fatigue sets in, leaving you with a melting mess you’ll likely abandon. Save your calories for more balanced options.
3. Peanut Buster Parfait
The Peanut Buster Parfait has been on DQ menus for decades, but nostalgia alone can’t save this outdated creation. The layered structure – alternating soft serve, hot fudge, and peanuts – sounds promising but delivers an inconsistent eating experience.
The fundamental flaw lies in the peanut distribution. Whole peanuts concentrate in certain bites while remaining absent in others. The fudge often congeals into chewy masses against the cold ice cream instead of providing smooth ribbons of chocolate.
By the time you reach the bottom, you’re left with a pool of melted vanilla and a handful of plain peanuts. Modern Blizzards with their evenly distributed ingredients have made this parfait obsolete – a relic best left in DQ’s past.
4. Turtle Pecan Cluster Blizzard
The concept seems foolproof – pecans, caramel, and chocolate blended into vanilla soft serve to mimic the beloved turtle candy. Yet this Blizzard consistently underdelivers on its promising ingredients list. The main culprit is poor distribution.
The caramel tends to form frozen, hard streaks rather than integrating smoothly. Pecans often sink to the bottom, leaving many spoonfuls with nothing but plain vanilla. The chocolate pieces become lost entirely, barely detectable in the mix.
When you do get all components in one bite, the flavors work well together. The problem is how rarely this happens throughout the eating experience. For the price, this inconsistent treat rarely satisfies turtle candy cravings.
5. Snickers Blizzard
The Snickers bar combines nougat, caramel, peanuts, and chocolate into a chewy, satisfying candy. Sadly, the Snickers Blizzard captures none of this textural magic. When chopped and mixed into cold soft serve, Snickers pieces freeze solid, losing their signature chewiness.
The nougat becomes brittle, the caramel hardens uncomfortably, and the overall effect bears little resemblance to the candy bar experience. The frozen peanuts can even become tooth-threatening hazards.
Temperature is the enemy here – what makes Snickers great at room temperature makes it problematic when frozen. If you’re craving that distinctive Snickers flavor profile, you’re better off enjoying the actual candy bar alongside a simple vanilla cone.
6. Heath Blizzard
Heath bars feature delicate toffee with a thin chocolate coating – a combination that fails spectacularly when incorporated into a Blizzard. The primary issue becomes immediately apparent with your first spoonful: the toffee pieces freeze into tooth-threatening shards.
What should be a pleasant buttery crunch transforms into rock-hard fragments that require careful navigation to avoid dental damage. The frozen toffee loses its distinctive buttery flavor, becoming merely sweet with none of the nuance that makes Heath bars enjoyable at room temperature.
Even when the Blizzard begins to melt, the toffee pieces remain problematically firm. With so many better mix-in options available, this potential dental emergency isn’t worth the risk.
7. Plain Vanilla Cone
Sometimes simplicity works beautifully in desserts. Unfortunately, Dairy Queen’s plain vanilla cone represents simplicity without character – the blank canvas without any artistry. The soft serve itself lacks the rich vanilla flavor that makes premium ice cream special.
There’s a notably artificial quality to both the taste and texture, with a chemical aftertaste that becomes more pronounced as you eat. The cone adds little excitement, being neither particularly crisp nor flavorful.
In a world of creative frozen treats, this cone feels like a missed opportunity. When Dairy Queen offers so many interesting mix-ins and flavor combinations, settling for this basic option leaves you with nothing but regret and a lingering artificial sweetener taste.
Leave a comment