America’s obsession with Oreos goes far beyond the classic black-and-white cookie dunked in milk. From birthday cake explosions to zesty lemon and rich dark chocolate, Oreo has rolled out a parade of flavors that keep fans lining up for the next twist. But which of these flavors actually stand out when it comes to real-world sales and reviews? We sifted through the hype, the limited drops, and the evergreen staples to reveal the 25 Oreo flavors Americans can’t stop buying. Whether you’re a cookie connoisseur or a casual snacker, this definitive ranking will surprise your taste buds—and your curiosity.
25. Cherry Blossom Matcha Oreo
An exotic fusion that crossed oceans to reach American shelves in 2025. Originally crafted for Japanese consumers, this limited-edition treat combines delicate cherry blossom essence with earthy matcha green tea crème, all sandwiched between classic chocolate wafers.
Adventurous snackers praise its balanced flavor profile—neither too sweet nor too bitter. The subtle floral notes complement the grassy matcha undertones, creating a sophisticated cookie experience that stands apart from typical American flavor profiles.
While not topping sales charts, its unique cultural appeal and Instagram-worthy green-pink filling make it a collector’s item among Oreo enthusiasts and international snack hunters.
24. Fudge Covered Oreo
Chocolate decadence reaches new heights with these indulgent treats. The familiar chocolate sandwich cookie receives a luxurious makeover by being completely enrobed in rich, velvety fudge coating. Unlike traditional Oreos that invite twisting and dunking, these are designed for straight-up savoring.
The outer fudge layer adds a satisfying snap before giving way to the classic cookie-and-cream center. Perfect for special occasions or whenever chocolate cravings hit hard.
Though slightly more expensive than regular varieties, fans insist the premium price delivers a premium experience—like enjoying a fancy truffle and familiar cookie simultaneously.
23. Oreo Thins
Slimmed-down sophistication for the calorie-conscious cookie lover. These svelte versions maintain the signature Oreo taste while reducing thickness by about 40%, creating a more delicate, crisp texture that appeals to adult palates.
Many fans appreciate the satisfying snap and balanced cookie-to-cream ratio. The thinner profile actually intensifies the chocolate flavor, making each bite seem more concentrated. Available in various flavors beyond the original, Thins have carved out their own loyal following.
Perfect for those moments when you want the Oreo experience without the full caloric commitment—though many consumers admit that the “eat less” strategy often backfires when the entire package disappears!
22. Gluten-Free Double Stuf Oreo
Freedom from gluten without sacrificing that extra cream filling! Introduced after the success of regular gluten-free Oreos, this variant brings double the creamy center to those with dietary restrictions. Creating a gluten-free cookie that maintains the authentic Oreo texture proved challenging for Nabisco engineers. Yet consumers with celiac disease or gluten sensitivity report these taste virtually identical to the original Double Stuf, with the same satisfying twist-apart experience. While slightly pricier than standard versions, the emotional value of enjoying a childhood favorite again makes them worth every penny. The packaging’s prominent gluten-free labeling makes shopping easier for those navigating food sensitivities.
21. Gluten-Free Oreo
A groundbreaking addition that opened the Oreo experience to everyone. Launched after years of development, these cookies use specialized ingredients to eliminate gluten while preserving the iconic taste and texture that defines the brand. The familiar snap, chocolate flavor, and creamy center remain intact—a technical achievement considering how gluten contributes to traditional cookie structure. Taste tests between regular and gluten-free versions often stump even the most devoted Oreo fans. For people with celiac disease or gluten sensitivity, these cookies represent more than just a snack—they’re a return to normalcy, allowing participation in the shared cultural experience of enjoying America’s favorite cookie without health consequences.
20. Salted Caramel Brownie Oreo
Sweet meets salty in this sophisticated flavor mashup. These special-edition cookies feature two distinct cream layers—a light brown salted caramel and a darker brownie-flavored cream—creating a complex taste experience between the chocolate wafers.
The added salt crystals provide unexpected pops of flavor, cutting through the sweetness in a way that elevates the entire cookie. Texture fans particularly appreciate the slight crunch these salt flecks add to the otherwise smooth cream center.
While not quite reaching the popularity of more established flavors, these cookies developed a passionate following among adult Oreo enthusiasts. Their more nuanced flavor profile appeals to sophisticated palates looking beyond simple sweetness.
19. Apple Cider Donut Oreo
Autumn’s favorite fairground treat transformed into cookie form! These seasonal sensations pair golden-colored wafers with a spiced apple cider-flavored cream that captures fall’s essence. The aroma alone transports you to harvest festivals and hayrides.
Released as a limited autumn offering, these cookies consistently sell out as shoppers stock up for the season. The cream filling balances tart apple notes with warm cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove undertones.
Unlike some novelty flavors that feel gimmicky, these manage to translate the beloved donut experience convincingly. Many fans create annual traditions around their release, pairing them with hot apple cider or tea for the ultimate autumn treat—making them a seasonal phenomenon rather than just another flavor variant.
18. Pumpkin Spice Oreo
The cookie that launched a thousand memes about autumn obsessions. These seasonal favorites feature golden vanilla wafers embracing a vibrant orange pumpkin spice-flavored cream that captures the essence of fall’s favorite flavor profile.
Unlike some pumpkin spice products that go overboard with artificial flavoring, these cookies strike a balanced note. The cream delivers genuine cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, and ginger notes that complement the vanilla cookies rather than overwhelming them.
Released annually since 2014, they’ve become part of autumn’s ritual for many households. Their limited availability creates a frenzy when they hit shelves, with dedicated fans buying multiple packages to freeze for year-round enjoyment—explaining their consistently strong sales despite seasonal availability.
17. Brookie-O Oreo
Triple-threat deliciousness in one ambitious cookie! The Brookie-O boldly combines three distinct cream layers—chocolate brownie, original vanilla, and cookie dough—creating a dessert mashup between the familiar chocolate wafers.
Each layer maintains its individual flavor identity while creating something entirely new when experienced together. The technical achievement of three separate cream layers impressed even skeptical Oreo purists.
Initially released as a limited edition in 2021, strong sales and passionate fan response earned this flavor several returns to shelves. The name cleverly combines “brownie” and “cookie”—though some customers jokingly struggle with the meta concept of a cookie flavored like other cookies and brownies.
16. Java Chip Oreo
Morning coffee meets midnight snack in this caffeine-inspired creation. These cookies feature coffee-flavored cream studded with tiny chocolate chips, delivering a mocha-like experience between the standard chocolate wafers.
Coffee enthusiasts appreciate the authentic roasted flavor that avoids the artificial taste plaguing many coffee-flavored sweets. The mini chocolate chips add textural interest and enhance the mocha profile, creating a sophisticated cookie experience.
Marketed toward adult Oreo fans, these cookies found particular success among college students and office workers as mid-afternoon pick-me-ups. While they don’t contain actual caffeine, the psychological association with coffee creates a perceived energy boost that contributes to their popularity.
15. Toffee Crunch Oreo
Buttery richness meets satisfying crunch in this textural triumph. These special-edition cookies feature toffee-flavored cream embedded with sugar crystals that provide an unexpected but delightful crackle between the chocolate wafers.
The flavor profile masterfully balances butterscotch notes with caramelized sugar complexity. Unlike some overly sweet variations, the slight bitterness of properly cooked toffee adds sophistication to each bite. Originally introduced as a limited offering, consumer demand pushed this variety into semi-regular rotation.
The textural contrast between crunchy cookie, smooth cream, and crackling sugar crystals creates a multi-dimensional eating experience that keeps fans reaching for more—explaining its steady climb in popularity rankings.
14. Chocolate Hazelnut Oreo
Nutella fans rejoice! This European-inspired variation pairs golden vanilla wafers with a rich chocolate-hazelnut cream that captures the essence of everyone’s favorite breakfast spread. The nutty undertones complement the sweet chocolate notes perfectly.
Launched after recognizing the global Nutella phenomenon, these cookies quickly developed a devoted following. The golden wafers were a deliberate choice, allowing the distinctive hazelnut flavor to shine without competition from chocolate cookies.
Many fans enjoy these cookies slightly chilled, which firms up the filling and intensifies the hazelnut character. While legal reasons prevent Nabisco from mentioning Nutella directly, the inspiration is unmistakable—creating an accessible way to enjoy the popular flavor combination without the mess of spreading it yourself.
13. Dark Chocolate Oreo
Sophisticated indulgence for serious chocolate lovers! These intensified cookies feature dark chocolate cream between the standard chocolate wafers, creating a richer, less sweet experience that appeals to mature palates.
The deep cocoa notes provide complexity beyond regular Oreos, with subtle bitter undertones that chocolate connoisseurs appreciate. Many fans report these cookies pair beautifully with red wine or coffee, elevating the humble Oreo to dinner party status.
Despite initial concerns about being too bitter for mainstream audiences, these cookies found their audience among adults seeking more sophisticated flavors. Their success demonstrated that not every Oreo variety needs to cater to children’s sweet preferences—opening the door for more nuanced offerings in the product line.
12. Caramel Coconut Oreo
Tropical vacation vibes in cookie form! These innovative treats combine smooth caramel cream with real coconut pieces, creating a Girl Scout Samoa-inspired flavor profile between the classic chocolate wafers.
The textural contrast between crunchy coconut flakes and silky caramel cream provides a multi-dimensional eating experience. Each bite delivers a different ratio of flavors, keeping the taste experience interesting throughout.
Initially underestimated as just another novelty flavor, these cookies developed a passionate following that demanded their return after limited releases. Their popularity spans demographics, appealing to both tropical flavor enthusiasts and caramel lovers alike—proving that sometimes unexpected combinations create the most dedicated fan bases.
11. Cinnamon Bun Oreo
Breakfast pastry meets cookie jar favorite in this aromatic creation. These innovative treats feature cinnamon-spiced cookies embracing a sweet frosting-flavored cream that perfectly captures fresh-from-the-oven cinnamon roll essence.
The cinnamon-infused wafers provide warmth and spice in every bite, while the vanilla cream mimics the gooey icing that makes cinnamon buns irresistible. The aroma alone triggers nostalgic memories of mall food courts and Sunday morning breakfasts.
Originally released as a limited winter offering, strong sales prompted more regular appearances in stores. Many fans report microwaving them for 5-10 seconds creates the ultimate experience—warm, slightly softened cookies that truly deliver on the fresh-baked cinnamon bun promise.
10. Chocolate Oreo
Chocolate overload for the true cocoa devotee! These intensified cookies double down on chocolate flavor by replacing the traditional vanilla cream with rich chocolate filling between the familiar chocolate wafers.
The result is a more sophisticated, less sweet cookie that allows the complex cocoa notes to take center stage. Without vanilla cream providing contrast, these cookies deliver a pure chocolate experience that serious chocolate lovers appreciate.
While seemingly simple, this variation has consistently maintained strong sales since introduction. Many bakers seek these out specifically for recipes, as the all-chocolate profile works beautifully in cheesecakes, truffles, and cookie crusts without introducing competing vanilla flavors.
9. Lemon Oreo
Sunshine in cookie form! These bright, zesty treats pair golden vanilla wafers with vibrant lemon-flavored cream for a refreshing twist on the Oreo experience. The tangy citrus notes cut through sweetness, creating a perfectly balanced bite.
Unlike some fruit-flavored cookies that taste artificial, these capture authentic lemon essence—combining both the aromatic oils and tart juice notes. Many fans appreciate their versatility across seasons, working equally well as winter pick-me-ups or summer refreshments.
Originally introduced as a limited offering, strong sales quickly earned them permanent status in the Oreo lineup. Their popularity extends beyond typical cookie consumers, appealing to people who normally find traditional Oreos too sweet—opening the brand to new customer segments.
8. Red Velvet Oreo
Southern charm meets cookie aisle favorite! These distinctive treats feature reddish-brown, cocoa-infused wafers surrounding cream cheese-flavored filling—perfectly capturing the essence of the beloved cake in portable form.
The subtle cocoa notes in the cookies complement the tangy cream filling, creating the signature red velvet flavor profile that’s simultaneously familiar yet unique. The striking red color makes them particularly popular for Valentine’s Day and holiday gatherings.
Initially released as a limited edition in 2015, overwhelming consumer response earned them a permanent spot in the Oreo lineup. Their success demonstrated consumers’ growing interest in dessert-inspired flavors, paving the way for more cake and pastry variations in the product family.
7. S’mores Oreo
Campfire memories without the mosquitoes! These clever cookies recreate the classic outdoor treat using graham-flavored wafers that sandwich a dual-layer filling of marshmallow and chocolate creams.
Each component faithfully represents its campfire counterpart—the graham cookies provide that honey-cinnamon base, while the two-toned filling delivers both gooey marshmallow sweetness and rich chocolate in every bite. The nostalgic flavor profile triggers happy memories of summer evenings and outdoor adventures.
Released seasonally each summer since 2015, these cookies consistently sell out as families stock up for camping trips and backyard gatherings. Their popularity transcends age groups, appealing to both children experiencing s’mores for the first time and adults reliving childhood memories.
6. Peanut Butter Oreo
A match made in snack heaven! These beloved cookies combine America’s favorite flavor duo by sandwiching smooth peanut butter cream between the classic chocolate wafers. The result is reminiscent of a Reese’s cup in cookie form.
The slightly salty, nutty cream balances perfectly against the sweet chocolate cookies. Unlike some novelty flavors, these deliver authentic peanut butter taste that satisfies serious nut butter enthusiasts. Introduced in the early 1990s, these cookies have maintained consistent popularity for decades.
Their enduring appeal spans generations, with parents who enjoyed them as children now sharing them with their own kids—creating a legacy flavor that continues to perform strongly in both sales and consumer satisfaction surveys.
5. Birthday Cake Oreo
Party in a package! Created to celebrate Oreo’s 100th anniversary in 2012, these festive cookies feature birthday cake-flavored cream studded with colorful sprinkles between the traditional chocolate wafers.
The vanilla-forward cream captures the essence of classic birthday cake frosting, while the rainbow sprinkles add both visual appeal and a subtle crunch. The familiar celebration flavor triggers happy memories for most consumers, creating an emotional connection beyond mere taste preference.
Originally planned as a limited commemorative release, overwhelming consumer demand earned them permanent status. Their popularity extends beyond children’s parties to adult celebrations, office gatherings, and anytime a bit of festive flavor is desired—proving that birthday joy transcends age demographics.
4. Mint Oreo
Cool refreshment meets chocolate indulgence in this perennial favorite! First introduced in 2002, these cookies pair the classic chocolate wafers with vibrant green mint-flavored cream that delivers a refreshing after-dinner experience.
The cooling sensation of real peppermint oil creates a pleasant contrast against the rich chocolate cookies. Unlike some mint products that taste medicinal, these achieve the perfect balance—reminiscent of high-end chocolate mint patties rather than toothpaste.
Their popularity spans seasons, though sales particularly spike during winter holidays when mint flavors traditionally shine. Many fans store them in the refrigerator to enhance the cooling effect, while others use them crushed in ice cream recipes—demonstrating versatility beyond straight-from-the-package enjoyment.
3. Golden Oreo
Vanilla revolution in the chocolate-dominated Oreo world! Introduced in 2004, these distinctive cookies swap the traditional chocolate wafers for vanilla-flavored golden cookies while maintaining the classic white cream center.
The buttery, almost shortbread-like cookies provide a softer flavor profile that appeals to those who find chocolate cookies too intense. Their vanilla-forward taste offers versatility across different eating occasions and pairing options. Initially met with skepticism from Oreo purists, these cookies quickly won over consumers on their own merits.
Their success proved the Oreo concept could transcend its chocolate origins, opening the door for countless flavor innovations. Today they rank among the top three best-selling varieties, particularly popular with younger children and vanilla enthusiasts.
2. Double Stuf Oreo
More of what you love! These indulgent cookies deliver exactly what the name promises—twice the creamy filling between the same chocolate wafers that made the original famous. Introduced in 1974, they addressed the most common Oreo hack—twisting apart multiple cookies to create one super-stuffed version.
The increased cream-to-cookie ratio creates a more luxurious mouthfeel and sweeter overall experience that many consumers prefer. Despite costing slightly more than original Oreos, Double Stuf consistently ranks as the second-best-selling variety.
Their popularity spawned even more extreme versions like Mega Stuf and The Most Stuf, though Double Stuf maintains the perfect balance for most consumers—proving sometimes more is indeed better.
1. Original Oreo
The timeless classic that started it all back in 1912! Two embossed chocolate wafers embrace a sweet vanilla cream filling in perfect proportion—creating the iconic sandwich cookie that defines the category.
The simple yet sophisticated flavor combination achieves the ideal balance—bitter cocoa notes from the cookies contrast with sweet, smooth cream. The distinctive design, with its ornate pattern and brand name stamped into each wafer, remains virtually unchanged for over a century.
Generating over $2 billion in annual sales and available in more than 100 countries, Original Oreos represent approximately 75% of all Oreo purchases. Despite countless competitors and flavor variations, the original formula maintains its crown as America’s best-selling cookie—proving that sometimes perfection needs no improvement.
Leave a comment