Pennsylvania’s food scene goes way beyond cheesesteaks and pretzels. Hidden throughout the Keystone State are amazing restaurants that locals treasure but tourists often miss. From cozy countryside spots to urban hidden gems, these nine underrated eateries deliver unforgettable meals that will have you planning your next visit before you’ve finished dessert.
1. Fireplace Restaurant (Tunkhannock)
Nestled along the Susquehanna River, this charming family-owned establishment has been warming hearts and filling bellies since 1975. The stone fireplace centerpiece creates an instantly cozy atmosphere that makes you feel at home.
Their homemade bread alone is worth the trip, but don’t miss their perfectly seared steaks and fresh seafood options. The generous portions and reasonable prices keep locals coming back regularly.
Weekend brunch features their famous blueberry pancakes that practically melt in your mouth. For a truly memorable experience, request a table near the fireplace during winter months.
2. Lumberville General Store (Lumberville)
Time seems to slow down at this historic 1800s general store turned charming eatery. Situated along the Delaware Canal towpath, it’s a favorite rest stop for cyclists and hikers exploring the scenic surroundings.
The breakfast sandwiches, made with locally sourced eggs and artisanal bread, have achieved legendary status among regulars. Their lunch menu showcases creative sandwiches with unexpected flavor combinations that somehow work perfectly together.
What truly sets this place apart is the peaceful outdoor patio where you can watch the world go by while sipping their excellent coffee. Don’t leave without trying one of their famous sticky buns!
3. The Trapp Door Gastropub (Emmaus)
Behind an unassuming exterior lies beer lover’s paradise with over 100 craft brews and a menu that elevates pub food to gourmet status. The basement location adds to its speakeasy charm – you’ll feel like you’ve discovered a delicious secret.
Their duck fat fries topped with truffle oil and parmesan have inspired many return visits. The rotating beer selection ensures even regular patrons always find something new to try.
Chef crafts seasonal specials using ingredients from nearby farms, resulting in dishes that surprise and delight. The intimate space fills quickly on weekends, so reservations are highly recommended for this hidden Lehigh Valley gem.
4. Huszar (Pittsburgh)
Family recipes passed down through generations bring authentic Hungarian cuisine to Pittsburgh’s North Side neighborhood. The warm welcome from owners makes first-timers feel like regulars instantly.
Chicken paprikash with homemade spaetzle transports diners straight to Budapest with its rich, creamy sauce and perfectly balanced spices. Their stuffed cabbage rolls, made exactly as grandmother used to make them, offer comfort in every bite.
The bar serves traditional Hungarian spirits you won’t find elsewhere in the city. Live folk music on select evenings adds to the authentic experience. This hidden cultural treasure offers a genuine taste of Central Europe without leaving Pennsylvania.
5. Revival Kitchen (Reedsville)
Farm-to-table isn’t just a buzzword at this intimate Mifflin County gem – it’s their entire philosophy. Chef Quintin and his wife Liz forage many ingredients themselves from nearby woods and work directly with local farmers.
The ever-changing menu reflects what’s freshest that week, often featuring unexpected ingredients like ramps, fiddlehead ferns, and heirloom vegetables you’ve never tried before. Their tasting menu option lets the chef surprise you with his latest creative inspirations.
The restaurant’s rustic-chic interior, housed in a renovated historic building, creates the perfect backdrop for food that tells the story of Pennsylvania’s landscape. Their commitment to sustainability extends to every aspect of operation.
6. A Little Pizza Heaven (Scranton)
Forget what you know about chain pizza – this small Scranton pizzeria has been perfecting their craft for over 30 years. The secret lies in their dough, which ferments for three days before being stretched by hand.
Their signature “Heavenly Special” combines unexpected toppings that create a flavor explosion with every bite. The family atmosphere makes everyone feel welcome, whether you’re a first-timer or someone who’s been coming since childhood.
Beyond pizza, their homemade pasta dishes deserve special mention, particularly the baked ziti that locals rave about. The modest storefront might not catch your eye, but the aroma wafting from inside will certainly grab your attention as you walk by.
7. Don’s Diner (Pittsburgh)
Stepping into this Pittsburgh institution feels like traveling back to the 1950s, complete with chrome accents and vinyl booths. The vintage jukebox still works, playing everything from doo-wop to early rock and roll.
Breakfast is served all day, featuring enormous pancakes that hang over the edge of the plate and perfectly crispy hash browns that will ruin all other hash browns for you forever. The coffee keeps flowing thanks to attentive servers who know most customers by name.
Their famous meatloaf sandwich has remained unchanged for decades – because perfection doesn’t need improvement. Cash only and closed by mid-afternoon, Don’s embodies the authentic diner experience that chain restaurants try but fail to replicate.
8. Native (Honesdale)
This modern farm-to-table restaurant brings big-city culinary innovation to small-town Pennsylvania. Located in a beautifully renovated historic building in downtown Honesdale, the minimalist décor lets the food be the star.
Seasonal ingredients from nearby farms transform into artistic plates that look almost too beautiful to eat. The sourdough bread, made in-house daily, comes with cultured butter that will make you wonder why you ever ate ordinary butter before.
The carefully curated wine list features many Pennsylvania vineyards alongside international selections. Owner-chef Caleb, who returned to his hometown after training in renowned kitchens, creates dishes that tell the story of the region while introducing unexpected global influences.
9. Stone Row Pub And Eatery (Jim Thorpe)
Housed in a pre-Civil War stone building in picturesque Jim Thorpe, this gastropub seamlessly blends historic charm with contemporary cuisine. The exposed stone walls and original wooden beams create an atmosphere that feels both timeless and trendy.
Their beer cheese soup, made with local craft brews, has achieved legendary status among visitors to this tourist town. The burger menu features creative combinations using grass-fed beef from nearby farms, each named after local landmarks.
The outdoor patio offers stunning views of the surrounding mountains during warmer months. Live acoustic music on weekends features talented local musicians who add to the laid-back vibe that makes this place special.
Leave a comment