Walking into Jersey Mike’s is a sensory experience—the warm aroma of freshly baked bread, the rhythmic slicing of cold cuts, and the crisp snap of lettuce tumbling onto a roll. It’s a sub lover’s paradise. But even in this sandwich sanctuary, one wrong move can turn your lunchtime masterpiece into a soggy, flavorless regret. The truth is, most people don’t even realize how easy it is to fumble their order at Jersey Mike’s. And by the time they take their first bite, the damage is already done.
Whether you’re a die-hard fan of the #13 Original Italian or a newcomer to the “Sub in a Tub” life, what you say—and don’t say—at the counter matters. There’s a flow to the ordering process, a rhythm that seasoned customers respect and rookies unknowingly derail. From misunderstanding “Mike’s Way” to choosing the wrong bread for your fillings, small slip-ups can lead to a disappointing sub experience that no amount of hot pepper relish can rescue.
And let’s not forget the secret menu, online rewards, or size options that make a world of difference if you actually use them right. So before you find yourself silently eating a sandwich that’s too wet, too bland, or just plain wrong, take a minute to brush up on the pitfalls that can sabotage your order. We’ve compiled the 15 biggest mistakes customers make when ordering at Jersey Mike’s—some common, some surprising, but all completely avoidable.
Read on to make sure your next Jersey Mike’s run results in a sub that’s stacked, sauced, and satisfying from the very first bite to the last crumb. Because when you know what not to do, you’re one step closer to sandwich perfection.
1. Ordering “Mike’s Way” Without Understanding It
The famous “Mike’s Way” topping combination sounds great, but do you know what you’re getting? This standard mix includes onions, lettuce, tomatoes, red wine vinegar, olive oil blend, and spices that pack a flavorful punch.
However, all those wet ingredients can quickly turn your bread into a soggy mess if you don’t plan to eat right away. The vinegar especially soaks through quickly!
Consider asking for vinegar and oil on the side if you’re taking your sub to-go or saving it for later. This simple adjustment preserves the bread’s texture while still letting you enjoy the classic Jersey Mike’s flavor.
2. Ordering a Giant Sub Just for Yourself
Those giant subs look amazing in the photos, but they’re designed to feed a small gathering, not just one hungry person! Measuring over a foot long and packed with generous portions of meat and cheese, these monsters can lead to serious overeating or food waste.
Many first-timers underestimate just how massive these sandwiches truly are. Even if you’re planning for leftovers, remember that cold cuts and fresh vegetables don’t always keep well once dressed with oil and vinegar.
A regular-sized sub provides a satisfying meal for most appetites. Save the giant for your next office lunch or family gathering when you can share the Jersey Mike’s experience with friends.
3. Approaching the Counter Without Checking the Menu
Nothing creates anxiety like reaching the front of the line only to realize you haven’t decided what to order! The person behind you sighs audibly while you frantically scan the menu board, feeling pressured to make a quick decision.
This rushed choice often results in ordering something you don’t really want or forgetting to customize your sandwich properly. Jersey Mike’s offers dozens of combinations, and taking time to consider your options is important.
Do yourself and everyone else a favor by reviewing the menu while waiting in line. Many locations even offer paper menus you can study, or better yet, check out their website before arriving to streamline your ordering experience.
4. Forgetting About Breadless Options
Stuck in a sandwich rut? Many customers don’t realize Jersey Mike’s offers alternatives beyond traditional subs. Their “Sub in a Tub” option serves all your favorite fillings in a convenient bowl without the carbs from bread.
This option is perfect for those following keto or low-carb diets, or anyone who simply wants to lighten up their meal. You still get all the fresh ingredients and flavors without feeling weighed down afterward.
They also offer wraps for a handheld option with fewer carbs than traditional sub rolls. Next time you visit, consider breaking away from your usual order and trying one of these alternatives for a refreshing change.
5. Requesting Free Bacon Add-Ons
We all love bacon, but asking for it as a free addition puts staff in an awkward position. Bacon is one of Jersey Mike’s premium toppings with a set price for good reason – it’s expensive for the restaurant too!
Some customers try to charm their way into free extras, not realizing this puts employees at risk of breaking company policy. Staff members who give away free toppings could face disciplinary action, even if they’re just trying to be nice.
If you’re craving that smoky, salty goodness, simply ask how much the bacon add-on costs and decide if it’s worth the splurge. Respecting the pricing structure makes for a better experience for everyone involved.
6. Assuming That There Are No Gluten-Free Options
Many people mistakenly believe that Jersey Mike’s has no gluten-free options, but that’s no longer true. The chain now offers a gluten-free sub roll, thanks to its partnership with Udi’s. This allows those with gluten sensitivities to enjoy a proper sandwich without having to ditch the bread altogether.
That said, it’s not a fully gluten-free environment, and cross-contamination is still a risk. Subs are prepared on shared surfaces, so customers with celiac disease or severe allergies should exercise caution and communicate their needs clearly when ordering.
Still, the option itself is a big deal. It signals progress toward inclusivity and gives more people access to Jersey Mike’s signature flavors.
7. Missing Out on Secret Menu Items
Psst! Did you know Jersey Mike’s has hidden gems that don’t appear on their standard menu? Items like the “Romo Special” (named after NFL quarterback Tony Romo) feature unique combinations that regular customers swear by.
Another insider favorite is the “Cancro Special,” named after the CEO Peter Cancro, featuring roast beef and pepperoni with provolone cheese. These creative combinations offer exciting flavor profiles you might never discover by sticking to the numbered menu.
Don’t be afraid to ask your sandwich maker about off-menu options or create your own signature combination. The staff often enjoys the challenge of crafting something special, and you might discover your new favorite sandwich!
8. Jumbling Your Ordering Sequence
Ever noticed how your sandwich falls apart after just a few bites? The culprit might be the order in which you requested ingredients! Professional sandwich makers follow specific layering techniques to ensure structural integrity.
Mentioning meat and cheese before toppings isn’t just about communication—it affects how your sandwich is built. Heavier ingredients belong on the bottom, while lighter ones go on top. This creates a stable foundation that prevents everything from sliding out when you take a bite.
Next time, try ordering in this sequence: bread, meat, cheese, and then toppings. You’ll be amazed at how much better your sub holds together, allowing you to enjoy every bite without wearing half of it on your shirt.
9. Missing Online Deals and Coupons
Paying full price unnecessarily? Jersey Mike’s regularly offers digital promotions that can save you serious money on your order. From BOGO deals to percentage discounts, these specials often don’t require much effort to redeem.
Check their website, app, or social media accounts before heading out. Many locations also send exclusive offers through email or text if you’ve signed up for their rewards program. Even better, some promotions support charitable causes through their Month of Giving or other community initiatives.
This means you can enjoy a discounted meal while supporting local organizations—a win-win that makes your sandwich taste even better knowing you’ve contributed to something positive.
10. Overlooking Limited-Time Offers
Creatures of habit miss out on some of Jersey Mike’s most exciting creations! The chain regularly introduces seasonal specials and limited-time offerings that showcase unique flavor combinations not found on the permanent menu.
From holiday-themed subs to collaborations with other brands, these temporary additions often feature premium ingredients or special preparation methods. Many become cult favorites, with fans eagerly awaiting their return year after year.
Keep an eye on the special promotions board near the register or check their social media accounts before visiting. Taking a chance on these featured items might introduce you to flavor combinations you’d never think to create yourself—and might become your new favorite!
11. Failing to Customize Your Sub
Stuck ordering the same old #13 exactly as described on the menu? Jersey Mike’s prides itself on customization, yet many customers never take advantage of this flexibility!
Maybe you love everything about the Club Supreme except the mayo, or perhaps you’d prefer double meat on your Turkey and Provolone. The staff is happy to accommodate reasonable requests to make your sandwich perfect for your unique taste preferences.
Don’t be shy about asking for more of what you love and less of what you don’t. Whether it’s extra pickles, light on the vinegar, or swapping turkey for chicken, speaking up ensures you’ll get exactly what you’re craving rather than settling for a standard configuration.
12. Ignoring Bread Selection Options
White bread isn’t your only option! Many customers automatically default to the standard roll without considering how bread choice affects the entire sandwich experience. Jersey Mike’s typically offers white, wheat, and rosemary parmesan options, each bringing different flavors and textures to your sub.
The rosemary parmesan adds a savory, herbaceous quality that pairs beautifully with Italian meats, while wheat provides a nuttier foundation perfect for turkey or veggie options.
The bread isn’t just a vessel—it’s approximately 40% of your sandwich by volume! Taking a moment to consider which option best complements your fillings can elevate your lunch from good to memorably delicious.
13. Bypassing the Hot Pepper Relish
That unassuming container of chopped peppers might not look special, but Jersey Mike’s hot pepper relish has a dedicated fan club for good reason! This zesty, slightly spicy condiment adds a perfect kick that brightens up even the most basic sandwich.
Made from cherry peppers, the relish delivers a tangy-sweet heat that’s flavorful without being overwhelming. Many first-timers skip it, fearing it might be too spicy, but the heat level is actually quite approachable for most palates.
Ask for a small amount on the side if you’re hesitant. You might discover it’s the missing ingredient that takes your regular order from satisfying to crave-worthy, joining the ranks of customers who specifically request extra relish on every visit!
14. Skipping the Rewards Program
Paying full price every time? That’s a rookie mistake! Jersey Mike’s offers a straightforward points program that rewards loyal customers with free subs and special perks, yet many regular visitors never bother to sign up.
The system is refreshingly simple: earn points with each purchase, then redeem them for free food. You’ll also receive birthday rewards and exclusive offers not available to non-members. Registration takes less than a minute via their app or website, and your digital account makes ordering even faster.
If you visit more than once a month, the rewards add up quickly—essentially giving you free lunch every few visits just for eating sandwiches you were going to order anyway!
15. Rushing Through Your Order
Feel pressured by the line behind you? Many customers race through their order, mumbling or skipping details, then end up disappointed when their sandwich isn’t quite right.
Taking just a few extra seconds to clearly communicate your preferences makes all the difference. Specify exactly how much of each condiment you want, whether you prefer your bread scooped out, or if you’d like your sandwich toasted.
Remember that sandwich artists can’t read minds! They want to make your perfect sub, but they need clear direction. Speaking at a reasonable pace and making eye contact ensures they catch every detail of your order, resulting in a sandwich that truly satisfies your specific cravings.
Leave a comment