Meal delivery kits have exploded in popularity—and for good reason. In theory, they promise the ultimate weeknight trifecta: fresh ingredients, curated recipes, and the convenience of skipping the grocery store. But not all boxes are created equal. Some deliver culinary joy right to your doorstep, while others leave you with a pile of subpar produce and disappointing dinners that make takeout look gourmet.
With so many options competing for your subscription, the challenge isn’t finding a meal kit—it’s finding one that actually delivers.
The best services offer more than just pre-measured ingredients and colorful recipe cards. They make cooking feel effortless, enjoyable, and—dare we say it—fun. From gourmet-quality dishes to customizable plans that adapt to your lifestyle, these kits take the guesswork out of mealtime and consistently leave you satisfied.
On the flip side, there are kits that overpromise and underdeliver. Whether it’s misleading cook times, tiny portion sizes, poor ingredient quality, or frustrating instructions, some meal kits quickly turn dinnertime into a chore. And with prices creeping higher across the board, wasting your money on a subpar box is more than just annoying—it’s expensive.
We tried and reviewed 10 popular meal delivery services to help you separate the must-try from the must-avoid. Whether you’re feeding a family, managing dietary goals, or just trying to survive the week without resorting to cereal for dinner, this list will help you find the kits that are worth your subscription—and steer clear of the ones that aren’t.
Here are five meal delivery services that truly impress—and five that will have you wondering why you didn’t just order pizza instead.
1. HelloFresh: Convenience Without Compromise
HelloFresh stands out in the crowded meal kit marketplace with consistently fresh ingredients that arrive properly chilled and ready to cook. The recipe cards feature clear, step-by-step instructions with helpful photos that even kitchen novices can follow without confusion.
What really sets HelloFresh apart is their impressive variety of weekly menu options. From quick 20-minute meals to gourmet selections, they balance familiar comfort foods with adventurous global flavors that expand your culinary horizons.
The portion sizes are generous enough to satisfy hungry adults, and many subscribers report having leftovers for lunch the next day – an unexpected bonus that stretches your food budget even further.
2. Blue Apron: Restaurant-Quality Dining at Home
Blue Apron transforms ordinary weeknight cooking into a culinary adventure with sophisticated flavor combinations you might expect from upscale restaurants.
Their chefs develop unique recipes using specialty ingredients you’d rarely buy yourself – think truffle butter, exotic spices, or artisanal cheeses that elevate simple proteins. The detailed recipe cards explain cooking techniques clearly, helping home cooks master skills like properly searing fish or creating reduction sauces.
Portion sizes strike the perfect balance – substantial enough to satisfy without overwhelming your plate. Blue Apron particularly excels with their wine pairing subscription add-on, suggesting bottles specifically selected to complement your meals. This thoughtful touch creates a complete dining experience rather than just another home-cooked dinner.
3. Home Chef: Customization Champion
Home Chef breaks the rigid meal kit mold by letting you customize almost everything about your weekly delivery. Don’t like shrimp in that pasta? Swap for chicken. Need extra protein after gym days? Double the portions. This flexibility makes Home Chef uniquely adaptable to changing household needs.
Their online platform remembers your preferences, making future selections even easier as the system learns what you enjoy. The meals themselves strike an appealing balance between familiar comfort foods and interesting variations that introduce new flavors without being intimidating.
Particularly impressive is Home Chef’s packaging system, which organizes ingredients by recipe in labeled bags. This small but thoughtful touch eliminates the frustrating scavenger hunt through your refrigerator when cooking time arrives.
4. Sunbasket: Nutrition Meets Flavor
Sunbasket caters to health-conscious eaters without sacrificing taste, a rare achievement in the meal kit world. Their commitment to organic produce and responsibly sourced proteins is immediately apparent when opening each delivery – the vibrant colors and farm-fresh quality speak volumes.
Unlike other services that offer token ‘healthy’ options, Sunbasket designs their entire menu around nutritional goals. They expertly accommodate specialized diets like paleo, gluten-free, Mediterranean, and diabetes-friendly without resorting to bland, joyless meals.
Each recipe incorporates creative touches like house-made sauces or spice blends that transform simple ingredients into crave-worthy dishes. The nutritional transparency is refreshing too – detailed information helps you make informed choices without feeling like you’re sacrificing flavor for health.
5. EveryPlate: Budget-Friendly Brilliance
EveryPlate proves affordable meal kits don’t require sacrificing quality or flavor. At nearly half the price of premium competitors, this service focuses on straightforward, satisfying meals without fancy ingredients or complicated techniques that drive up costs.
The menu features crowd-pleasing classics with clever twists – think upgraded burgers, creative pasta dishes, and one-pan wonders that minimize cleanup. While you won’t find exotic ingredients or specialized diet options, the recipes consistently deliver on taste and satisfaction.
EveryPlate achieves its impressive price point through smart strategies: simpler packaging, fewer ingredients per recipe, and streamlined delivery logistics. For families watching their budget or meal kit beginners testing the waters, EveryPlate offers exceptional value without the premium price tag.
6. Dinnerly: Disappointing Basics
Dinnerly markets itself as the most affordable meal kit option, but the savings come with significant compromises. Recipes often rely heavily on pasta, rice, and other inexpensive fillers while skimping on vegetables and protein portions that leave you wondering where your money went. Many subscribers report receiving wilted produce or ingredients past their prime, suggesting quality control issues in their supply chain.
The digital-only recipe cards (a cost-cutting measure) frequently contain confusing instructions or missing steps that frustrate even experienced cooks. While the price point seems attractive, the bland, repetitive meals rarely inspire culinary excitement.
Most dishes taste like something you could easily throw together from pantry staples without a subscription, making the convenience factor questionable at best.
7. Factor_: Overpriced Mediocrity
Factor_ positions itself as a premium ready-to-eat meal service, but the hefty price tag creates expectations the food simply doesn’t meet. The pre-cooked meals require only microwave reheating, promising convenience for busy professionals willing to pay for quality. Unfortunately, many customers report dishes arriving with odd textures – mushy vegetables, dry proteins, and sauces that separate unappetizingly upon reheating.
The portion sizes skew surprisingly small considering the premium pricing, leaving many subscribers still hungry after finishing their meals. While the nutritional focus deserves praise, the actual eating experience often disappoints. The flavors frequently fall flat, relying too heavily on salt rather than balanced seasoning.
For the same price, many customers could enjoy restaurant takeout with superior taste and freshness.
8. Gobble: Complex Confusion
Gobble boldly claims their meals take just 15 minutes to prepare, an attractive promise for time-starved households. Reality tells a different story, with many subscribers reporting actual cooking times double or triple the advertised duration due to complicated multi-step processes. The preparation complexity stems from Gobble’s attempt to deliver restaurant-quality meals in express time – an admirable goal that falls short in execution.
Recipes often require juggling multiple pans simultaneously while performing precision techniques better suited to experienced cooks than busy parents. Adding insult to injury, the finished dishes rarely justify the effort. Flavors tend toward bland or strangely unbalanced despite the complex preparation.
The premium pricing makes these shortcomings particularly difficult to overlook when simpler meal kits deliver more consistent results.
9. Martha & Marley Spoon: Celebrity Disappointment
Martha Stewart’s meal kit promises her signature elegant simplicity, but frequently delivers frustration instead. The most common complaint? Wildly inconsistent portion sizes that leave you with either too much or too little of critical ingredients, making recipes difficult to execute as written.
Packaging problems plague this service, with reports of leaking meat containers, crushed produce, and missing items occurring far too frequently. When ingredients arrive damaged or unusable, the carefully planned meal becomes impossible to create, defeating the entire purpose of a meal kit. The recipes themselves show promise with creative flavor combinations, but execution issues undermine the experience.
For a premium-priced service carrying a celebrity namesake, these quality control problems are particularly disappointing and suggest resources are being directed toward marketing rather than operations.
10. Purple Carrot: Plant-Based Monotony
Purple Carrot fills an important niche as a fully plant-based meal kit, but quickly falls into a creativity rut that vegans and vegetarians know all too well. After a few weeks, subscribers notice repetitive ingredient combinations repackaged into slightly different forms – another grain bowl, another stuffed vegetable, another pasta with vegetables.
The reliance on processed meat alternatives feels particularly uninspired. Rather than showcasing the natural diversity of plant foods, many recipes center around imitation products that never quite satisfy like the real thing. Preparation often requires specialized equipment or techniques that aren’t mentioned until you’re midway through cooking.
While ingredient quality remains consistently high, the monotonous menu and complex preparation make Purple Carrot difficult to sustain as a long-term meal solution despite its admirable plant-based mission.
Leave a comment