When it comes to fast food, customers usually stick to what they know—maybe a Big Mac, a classic Frosty, or a tried-and-true slice of pepperoni pizza. But behind every register, fryer, and drive-thru window is someone who knows the menu inside and out—and perhaps more importantly, knows which items are truly worth ordering. Fast food workers aren’t just slinging burgers and pouring shakes—they’re also the ultimate insiders, and when they crave something on the clock, they’re not reaching for the basics.
So what do these seasoned employees actually eat themselves? The answers might surprise you. From inventive off-menu mashups to underrated side items and dessert hacks that never make it into the commercials, these selections represent the real bestsellers—according to the people who make them. Whether it’s a Doritos Crunchwrap upgrade from Taco Bell or a custom-loaded grilled cheese at Five Guys, each item on this list has been vetted by the most reliable source possible: the folks behind the counter.
We’ve rounded up 17 must-try menu items recommended by current and former fast food workers across the country—some are hidden gems, some are regional rarities, and others are well-known favorites made just a little bit better with insider tweaks. These are the bites they order on their break, crave after hours, and suggest to friends in the know.
If you’re tired of the same old combo meal and ready to explore what the pros are actually eating, you’re in for a treat. From savory upgrades to sweet surprises, this list goes beyond the usual drive-thru fare to uncover what’s truly worth your next order. Let’s dig in—fast food just got a whole lot more interesting.
1. Popeye’s Cinnamon Apple Pie
Fast food workers at Popeye’s can’t stop raving about their Cinnamon Apple Pie. Unlike the more famous McDonald’s version, this Southern-inspired treat features a distinctively crispy, flaky crust that shatters delightfully with each bite.
The filling strikes the perfect balance between tart Granny Smith apples and warm cinnamon spice, creating a pocket of gooey goodness inside. Many employees grab one at the end of their shift as a reward.
The pies are freshly fried throughout the day, giving them an edge over many other fast food desserts that might sit under heat lamps for hours.
2. Subway’s Chicken Pizziola
Subway employees know the Chicken Pizziola is the chain’s best-kept secret. This hybrid creation marries two comfort food favorites in one handheld delight.
Tender grilled chicken strips nestle alongside pepperoni slices, while marinara sauce adds a tangy kick that perfectly complements the melted mozzarella. The combination creates a pizza-sandwich mashup that satisfies multiple cravings at once.
Workers often customize it further with banana peppers or parmesan for extra zing. Though it occasionally disappears from the official menu, most locations can still make it if you ask – a fact that employees take full advantage of during lunch breaks.
3. Burger King’s Rodeo Burger
Hidden among Burger King’s flashier offerings, the humble Rodeo Burger holds a special place in employees’ hearts. This flavor-packed creation stacks crispy onion rings and tangy BBQ sauce atop a flame-grilled beef patty.
The textural contrast between the crunchy rings and juicy burger creates a satisfying mouthfeel that keeps staff coming back. At just a couple bucks in most locations, it delivers remarkable value compared to premium menu items.
Many workers consider it the perfect quick meal during short breaks. The smoky-sweet flavor profile offers a welcome change from standard cheeseburgers while still delivering that classic fast food comfort.
4. Arby’s Jamocha Shake
Baristas aren’t the only ones who appreciate a good coffee fix. Arby’s employees regularly treat themselves to the chain’s Jamocha Shake when sweet cravings strike during shifts.
This velvety blend combines rich chocolate syrup with coffee extract, creating a caffeinated dessert that’s simultaneously refreshing and indulgent. The thick consistency is perfect for dipping Arby’s curly fries – a secret combination many workers swear by.
Unlike trendy coffee shop concoctions that cost a small fortune, this affordable treat delivers complex flavor without breaking the bank. The shake has maintained its cult following among staff even as menu items come and go around it.
5. Wendy’s Frosty Float
Wendy’s employees have perfected the art of the Frosty Float, a creation that combines two beloved classics. They start with a cup of chocolate or vanilla Frosty, then top it with Coca-Cola, Sprite, or even Dr. Pepper for a fizzy twist.
The carbonation creates a creamy foam at the top while the soda slowly integrates with the frozen dessert below. The result is reminiscent of an old-fashioned soda shop treat but with Wendy’s signature Frosty base.
Staff members appreciate how this simple hack transforms an everyday menu item into something special. The contrast between cold, creamy Frosty and bubbly soda creates a textural experience that’s greater than the sum of its parts.
6. Taco Bell’s Cheesy Gordita Crunch with Doritos Shell
Taco Bell insiders have elevated the already-popular Cheesy Gordita Crunch by swapping in a Doritos Locos taco shell for the standard crunchy corn shell. This simple modification creates a flavor explosion that employees consider worth the extra charge.
The soft, pillowy flatbread exterior hugs the crunchy, nacho cheese-dusted shell, while spicy ranch sauce creates the perfect creamy counterpoint. Seasoned beef, lettuce, and cheese complete this textural masterpiece.
Workers particularly appreciate how the Doritos shell adds an extra dimension of flavor without compromising the structural integrity of the original. The combination represents everything great about Taco Bell’s customizable menu approach.
7. Starbucks’ Oreo Frappuccino
Starbucks baristas have mastered the art of crafting this secret menu favorite during their breaks. Though not officially listed, employees know exactly how to make this cookies-and-cream dream by blending java chips into a mocha Frappuccino base.
The resulting drink mimics the beloved cookie’s flavor profile with surprising accuracy. Topped with whipped cream and an optional mocha drizzle, it satisfies sweet tooth cravings while providing a gentle caffeine boost.
Many workers prefer this to standard menu options because it strikes the perfect balance between coffee and dessert. The java chips add a pleasant textural element that regular Frappuccinos lack, creating tiny bursts of chocolate throughout each sip.
8. McDonald’s Southern Style Chicken and Waffles
McDonald’s employees in select southern regions have discovered a brilliant breakfast hack. They combine the crispy Southern Style Chicken Biscuit with the chain’s hotcakes, creating an improvised chicken and waffles experience.
The savory, perfectly-seasoned chicken cutlet pairs surprisingly well with the sweet pancakes and maple syrup. Some workers take it further by adding a hash brown for extra crunch or a slice of cheese for creamy richness.
This off-menu creation showcases the ingenuity of fast food workers who maximize flavor from limited ingredients. Though availability depends on location and timing, employees who can access both items rarely order them separately anymore.
9. Taco Bell’s Cheesy Fiesta Potatoes
When Taco Bell briefly removed Cheesy Fiesta Potatoes from their menu, employees were among the most vocal protesters. These seasoned potato bites have developed an almost cult-like following among staff for good reason.
The crispy exterior gives way to fluffy, perfectly-seasoned interiors that serve as the ideal vehicle for nacho cheese sauce and cool sour cream. Many workers enhance them further with jalapeños, onions, or even crushed Doritos for added texture.
Beyond their delicious taste, these potatoes represent exceptional value. Staff members appreciate how filling and satisfying they are compared to their modest price point, making them a frequent choice during lunch breaks.
10. Domino’s Chocolate Lava Crunch Cake
Domino’s delivery drivers confess they often can’t resist the allure of the chain’s Chocolate Lava Crunch Cakes. These baseball-sized desserts feature a chocolate cake exterior that develops a delicate crisp during baking.
The magic happens inside, where molten chocolate awaits like hidden treasure. The temperature contrast between the warm, gooey center and the slightly firmer exterior creates a textural experience that far exceeds expectations for a pizza chain dessert.
Employees particularly appreciate these treats during closing shifts. Many workers consider them superior to similar desserts at fancy restaurants, citing the perfect portion size and consistent quality as key advantages.
11. Five Guys’ Loaded Grilled Cheese
Five Guys employees have elevated the humble grilled cheese into something extraordinary. Starting with the standard sandwich, they add a burger patty, bacon, grilled mushrooms, and practically any other topping the restaurant offers.
The result is a gooey, indulgent creation that delivers all the flavors of a burger with the added comfort of melted American cheese hugging both sides of the bread. Staff particularly love how the toasted inside-out bun gets extra crispy, providing structural support for the mountain of fillings.
This modification transforms an item normally considered an afterthought into a crave-worthy main attraction. Many workers consider it superior to standard burgers because the cheese-to-meat ratio creates perfect umami balance.
12. Subway’s Bacon and Tuna Sub
Subway sandwich artists raise eyebrows when they reveal their favorite protein combination: tuna salad topped with crispy bacon. Though it sounds unusual, employees swear by this savory pairing.
The creamy, mayonnaise-rich tuna provides a smooth base that contrasts beautifully with the salty crunch of well-done bacon. Staff typically add provolone cheese and toast the whole creation until the edges get slightly crispy.
Workers recommend completing this unconventional masterpiece with red onions, pickles, and a splash of vinegar to cut through the richness. This combination demonstrates how Subway employees use their intimate knowledge of ingredients to create flavor profiles that most customers would never think to try.
13. Taco Bell’s Dorito Crunchwrap Supreme
Taco Bell employees have perfected a modification that takes the already-popular Crunchwrap Supreme to new heights. By substituting a Doritos Locos taco shell for the standard tostada disk, they create a flavor-packed hexagonal wonder.
The nacho cheese dust from the Doritos shell infuses every bite, complementing the seasoned beef, nacho cheese sauce, and sour cream. The tortilla exterior gets perfectly grilled, creating a portable package that doesn’t sacrifice flavor for convenience.
Staff particularly appreciate how this hack maximizes the textural experience – soft tortilla, crunchy Doritos shell, and creamy fillings create a symphony in each bite. Many workers consider this modification essential and wonder why it hasn’t become an official menu option.
14. Wendy’s Side of Melted Cheese
Wendy’s employees have unlocked a secret that transforms ordinary menu items into extraordinary indulgences: requesting a side cup of melted cheese. This simple addition costs just cents but elevates everything from fries to chicken nuggets.
The cheese maintains the perfect dipping consistency – thick enough to cling to food but flowing enough to ensure even coating. Workers particularly enjoy dunking the chain’s spicy nuggets into this molten goodness, creating a flavor combination that rivals any fancy restaurant’s appetizer.
Some staff members take it further by mixing in a packet of Wendy’s chili seasoning for a kicked-up cheese sauce. This affordable upgrade demonstrates how insider knowledge can transform standard fast food into something special.
15. Starbucks’ Undertow
Starbucks baristas rely on the Undertow when they need a quick energy boost during hectic shifts. This secret menu item features cold milk and flavored syrup at the bottom of a cup, topped with hot espresso shots that float on top.
The magic happens when you drink it – hot espresso rushes over cold, sweet milk creating distinct temperature layers that hit your palate in waves. Most employees prefer vanilla syrup, but caramel and hazelnut variations have their devoted followers too.
This clever creation delivers immediate caffeine while being more interesting than a standard espresso shot. The Undertow has become so popular among staff that many locations now recognize the name despite its absence from official menus.
16. Wendy’s Cinnabon Pull-Apart
Morning shift workers at Wendy’s have a sweet secret – the chain’s Cinnabon Pull-Apart ranks among the best breakfast pastries in fast food. These shareable bites feature rich, buttery dough coated in cinnamon sugar and drizzled with cream cheese icing.
Employees particularly appreciate how the individual pieces allow for portion control during quick breaks. The exterior pieces develop a slight crispness while interior sections remain pillowy soft, creating textural variety throughout the container.
Staff members often warm them slightly longer than the standard time for customers, achieving the perfect balance of melted icing and warm dough. This underrated breakfast option outshines many of the chain’s more heavily advertised morning offerings.
17. KFC’s Chizza
KFC workers in select international locations rave about the Chizza – a revolutionary pizza-chicken hybrid that uses a flattened fried chicken breast as the “crust.” This protein-packed base gets topped with marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese, and pepperoni.
The genius lies in how the crispy chicken exterior maintains its crunch even under the toppings, while the juicy interior provides a satisfying bite that no flour-based crust could match. Employees often customize their versions with additional toppings like pineapple or jalapeños.
Though not widely available in the US, workers who’ve experienced it consider it the perfect comfort food fusion. The Chizza represents fast food innovation at its finest – surprising yet somehow making perfect sense.
Leave a comment