If you think all peanut butter tastes the same, think again. From crunchy to creamy, natural to sweetened, peanut butter isn’t just a pantry staple—it’s a fiercely competitive category where texture, flavor, and spreadability can make or break your loyalty. Whether you slather it on toast, swirl it into oatmeal, or eat it straight from the jar with a spoon (no judgment here), your peanut butter says a lot about your taste preferences. But with so many brands lining grocery store shelves, which ones are truly worth your hard-earned dollars?
To settle the debate once and for all, we taste-tested and analyzed 12 of the most popular peanut butter brands in America. From classic childhood staples to organic, minimalist spreads with just one ingredient, this list covers the full spectrum. Some offered nostalgic comfort with a silky-smooth finish, while others fell flat with oily textures and underwhelming flavor. We judged them on everything that matters—flavor, consistency, ingredient quality, and how well they held up in both savory and sweet pairings.
Whether you’re a diehard Skippy fan or on the hunt for the cleanest, most natural jar on the market, our ultimate ranking separates the peanutty champs from the forgettable flops. You might be surprised to see where your go-to lands—or discover a new favorite that changes your spread game entirely. So grab a spoon (and maybe a slice of bread), and dive into the definitive peanut butter list that every PB lover needs to read before their next grocery run. The winner? It’s smooth, it’s satisfying, and it just might be hiding in plain sight on your supermarket shelf. Let the peanut butter showdown begin!
12. Once Again Creamy Organic Peanut Butter
Once Again Creamy Organic keeps it simple with just organic peanuts and salt, but the results disappoint. The jar opens with a thick oil layer and a dense base that’s tough to stir, making it messy from the start.
The texture stays uneven, with clumps and grit that never fully smooth out. Many users report a dry, hard bottom that’s difficult to spread by mid-jar.
Flavor-wise, it’s underwhelming—earthy but lacking the roasted depth found in better brands. It might work in recipes, but for everyday spreading, Once Again ranks last for both taste and texture.
11. Smucker’s Natural
The trusted name in jelly unfortunately stumbles when it comes to peanut butter. Despite the admirable simplicity of ingredients (just peanuts and salt), Smucker’s Natural never quite comes together as a cohesive spread.
The texture presents the biggest challenge – persistently gritty even after vigorous stirring, with oil that separates aggressively overnight. Many users report the dreaded “dry bottom” phenomenon where the last third of the jar becomes nearly impossible to spread.
Flavor-wise, an unexpected bitter undertone detracts from what should be clean peanut taste. While it might work in recipes where texture isn’t crucial, for straight spreading applications, Smucker’s Natural ranks as a disappointment from an otherwise reliable brand.
10. MaraNatha Organic
Small-batch vibes come through in every spoonful of MaraNatha Organic. The lightly roasted peanuts create a more delicate flavor profile that peanut connoisseurs describe as “sophisticated” compared to mainstream brands.
The texture deserves special mention – remarkably creamy yet somehow maintaining tiny bits of peanut that provide subtle textural interest. Yes, you’ll need to stir it initially, but the oil incorporates more easily than with many natural competitors.
While the runnier consistency can make for messier sandwiches, it transforms into a luxurious addition to smoothies and oatmeal. MaraNatha represents the artisanal end of widely available peanut butters – for those who appreciate nuance over intensity in their spread.
9. Peter Pan Original
Flying under the radar between titans like Jif and Skippy, Peter Pan has cultivated a dedicated following over decades. Fans describe its distinctive flavor profile as slightly saltier and sweeter than competitors – a bold choice that either wins you for life or sends you searching elsewhere.
The texture hits that commercial sweet spot – smooth enough for easy spreading but with enough body to hold its own on a sandwich. Many bakers swear by it for cookie recipes, claiming it produces a more pronounced peanut flavor in the finished treats.
While not winning any awards for natural ingredients, Peter Pan delivers consistent results and nostalgic satisfaction. Sometimes a childhood favorite remains exactly that – comfort food that reliably delivers the familiar taste you remember.
8. Reese’s Peanut Butter
Sweet-toothed peanut butter lovers, this one’s for you! The same company behind those iconic orange-wrapped cups brings unmistakable dessert vibes to the spread aisle. One taste reveals its candy-inspired heritage – significantly sweeter than traditional options.
Bakers consider this their secret weapon for cookies, cakes, and frostings. The silky-smooth consistency and pronounced sweetness create spectacular desserts without additional sugar. The distinctive orange lid signals its special-occasion status in many households.
While too sweet for everyday sandwich duty, Reese’s excels when paired with chocolate or incorporated into treats. For those moments when you’re craving something indulgent but don’t want to unwrap a candy, this jar delivers pure comfort in spreadable form.
7. Good & Gather Creamy
Target’s house brand delivers a knockout performance that rivals premium labels at a fraction of the price. The moment you twist off the lid, you’re greeted with a velvety surface that needs no stirring – a convenience rarely found in natural peanut butters.
The flavor hits all the right notes: pronounced nuttiness with just enough salt to enhance without overwhelming. Sandwich-makers will appreciate how it clings perfectly to bread without becoming gloppy or running off the edges.
Store brands often get overlooked, but Good & Gather proves that assumption needs rethinking. This budget-friendly option demonstrates that quality peanut butter doesn’t require fancy packaging or a premium price tag to deliver outstanding results.
6. Crazy Richard’s 100% Peanuts!
Minimalists, rejoice! Crazy Richard’s takes purity to the extreme with literally just one ingredient: peanuts. No salt, no sugar, no oils – nothing but ground nuts in their most honest form. The ultra-thin consistency might surprise first-timers.
It pours more than scoops, making it perfect for drizzling into smoothies or stirring into oatmeal. The flavor delivers pure, unadulterated peanut essence that lets you taste the legume’s natural sweetness.
This brand requires commitment – you’ll need to stir thoroughly and store it in the fridge. But for those seeking the cleanest label possible or controlling their sodium intake, Crazy Richard’s represents peanut butter in its most fundamental state.
5. Justin’s Classic
Founded by a guy who started making nut butter in his kitchen, Justin’s brings character to the peanut butter aisle. The slightly grainy yet pleasantly spreadable texture offers a sensory experience that feels more artisanal than mass-produced.
Health-conscious shoppers appreciate the transparent ingredient list and sustainable sourcing. The flavor strikes a remarkable balance – distinctly peanutty without being overwhelming, lightly sweetened without tasting artificial.
While the price point sits higher than conventional brands, devotees insist the quality justifies every penny. Justin’s proves that “better for you” doesn’t have to mean sacrificing taste – a rare achievement in the world of natural peanut butters.
4. Good Good Creamy
Good Good Creamy is a relative newcomer that manages to strike the perfect balance between old-school comfort and modern nutrition. Its ultra-smooth texture immediately stands out, spreading effortlessly without the oily mess or hard clumps found in many natural options.
Taste-wise, it leans sweet and salty in a way that feels nostalgic—like the peanut butter you grew up with, just a bit more grown-up. It’s a crowd-pleaser that doesn’t sacrifice flavor for simplicity.
With fewer additives and no artificial aftertaste, Good Good earns its place near the top. It’s proof that cleaner ingredients don’t have to mean compromising on joy.
3. Jif Creamy
“Choosy moms choose Jif” isn’t just a catchy slogan – it’s the reason this iconic blue-lidded jar remains a fixture in American pantries. The unmistakable creamy texture spreads like a dream, never tearing bread or requiring refrigeration.
What makes Jif special is its perfect harmony of sweetness and saltiness. The flavor hits that nostalgic sweet spot that transports you right back to elementary school lunches.
While natural peanut butter enthusiasts might scoff at its ingredients list, nobody can deny Jif’s consistent performance. From sandwiches to apple slices, this crowd-pleaser remains the standard by which many judge all other peanut butters.
2. Teddie All Natural
Imagine the most intense peanut flavor concentrated into one jar – that’s Teddie All Natural for you. With just two ingredients (peanuts and salt), this no-nonsense spread delivers an authentic taste that peanut enthusiasts crave.
The thick, hearty texture feels substantial on your spoon and satisfying between your teeth. You’ll need some muscle to stir it initially, but the reward is worth every effort.
Teddie shines brilliantly on whole grain toast where its robust flavor can take center stage. For those who believe peanut butter should taste primarily of peanuts rather than additives, this brand stands as a testament to simplicity done right.
1. Skippy Natural Creamy
Crowned as our ultimate winner, Skippy Natural Creamy delivers everything you want in peanut butter without any fuss. The perfect balance of salt and sweetness makes each spoonful taste like childhood memories.
Unlike many natural options, this jar requires zero stirring – just open and enjoy that consistently smooth texture. Spreading easily on even the softest bread without tearing, it’s the reliable friend that never disappoints.
Whether making PB&J sandwiches or baking cookies, Skippy Natural performs flawlessly every time. No wonder it’s earned its place as the gold standard that other brands struggle to match!
Leave a comment