When it comes to unforgettable seafood, few shows dish it out quite like Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives. Guy Fieri has taken us coast to coast, diving fork-first into America’s best joints serving up everything from buttery lobster rolls to deep-fried catfish.
If you’ve got a craving for crab, shrimp, or any fish under the sea, you’re in the right place. Whether it’s a mom-and-pop grill in the South slinging shrimp po’boys or a beachside shack in California flipping fish tacos with flair, these places aren’t just good—they’re straight-up flavor bombs.
Each one has earned the Fieri stamp of approval, which means you know it’s not just hype—it’s seriously delicious.
These restaurants don’t just serve seafood; they celebrate it. And we’re not talking about fussy fine dining here. These are the joints where the floors are sticky, the vibes are chill, and the seafood? Out of this world.
The kind of places where the locals gather, the beer’s always cold, and the chowder is rich enough to ruin your plans for the rest of the day.
This list is for the true seafood fanatics—the people who don’t just want a nice piece of salmon, but want it blackened, drenched in house-made aioli, and served with a side of buttery cornbread.
You’ll find oysters fresh from the dock, clams that taste like the ocean, and sauces so good you’ll be licking your fingers in public.
1. Garbo’s Grill – Key West, Florida
Nestled in the vibrant heart of Key West, Garbo’s Grill is a seafood gem known for its lively atmosphere and mouth-watering lobster burritos. The food truck, a local favorite, is a hub of flavor and fun.
Imagine the zesty flavors of freshly caught fish, wrapped in a warm tortilla, mingling with the tropical Key West vibe.
This spot captures the essence of island life with every bite. Locals and tourists alike flock to Garbo’s for its signature dishes, which Guy Fieri himself couldn’t resist. The fish tacos, a popular choice, are a symphony of flavors – a tribute to the rich bounty of the sea.
Whether you’re a seafood aficionado or a curious traveler, Garbo’s Grill promises a culinary experience that’s as unforgettable as a Key West sunset. It’s not just a meal, it’s a destination.
2. Panini Pete’s – Fairhope, Alabama
In the quaint town of Fairhope, Panini Pete’s offers a delightful escape into the world of gourmet seafood. Known for their scrumptious crab cakes topped with house-made mozzarella, this eatery is a testament to culinary creativity.
The welcoming ambiance invites diners to relax and indulge in dishes prepared with love and precision. Panini Pete’s is not just about food; it’s an experience that celebrates the art of cooking.
Each bite of their signature crab cakes is a journey into the rich flavors of the Gulf, capturing the essence of Alabama’s culinary heritage. It’s a place where tradition meets innovation, making it a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts seeking a unique and memorable dining adventure.
3. The Crab Shack – Tybee Island, Georgia
Welcome to The Crab Shack on Tybee Island, where seafood dreams come true! This bustling eatery is famed for its Low Country Boil, a hearty blend of shrimp, crab, and sausage that makes the taste buds dance.
Surrounded by the island’s natural beauty, diners can enjoy a meal that’s both a feast for the eyes and the stomach. The Crab Shack offers a casual environment where the whole family can dig into succulent seafood while watching the sunset over the water.
Each visit is a celebration of Georgia’s coastal flavors, served in generous portions. It’s a place where the spirit of the South shines through in every dish, inviting you to return time and again for a taste of island hospitality.
4. Blue Water Seafood Market & Grill – San Diego, California
San Diego’s Blue Water Seafood Market & Grill is a seafood lover’s paradise. Known for their grilled local fish sandwiches, this spot offers a true taste of California’s bountiful coast.
The market atmosphere ensures that every dish is fresh and flavorful, capturing the essence of the ocean in every bite. Patrons can savor seafood tacos that are as vibrant as the San Diego sun.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Blue Water Seafood Market & Grill is a must-visit for those seeking culinary adventure. It’s where the laid-back Californian lifestyle meets the rich flavors of the sea, providing an unforgettable dining experience.
5. Duarte’s Tavern – Pescadero, California
Duarte’s Tavern, a historic landmark in Pescadero, is synonymous with comfort and tradition. Famous for its cioppino and creamy oyster stew, this tavern offers a taste of California’s coastal culinary heritage.
Walking into Duarte’s is like stepping back in time, where the charm of a bygone era meets the warmth of family-run hospitality. Each dish tells a story, woven with flavors that speak of the region’s rich seafood bounty.
It’s a place to gather, share stories, and enjoy hearty meals that have stood the test of time. For seafood lovers, Duarte’s Tavern is more than a restaurant; it’s a cherished piece of California’s dining history.
6. Louie’s – Cos Cob, Connecticut
Louie’s in Cos Cob is a love letter to New England’s classic seafood traditions. Known for their lobster rolls, this restaurant captures the heart of coastal Connecticut in every bite.
The nautical-themed decor sets the stage for a dining experience that celebrates the ocean’s bounty. Each lobster roll is a masterpiece, brimming with succulent lobster meat that’s perfectly seasoned.
At Louie’s, every meal is a journey into the flavors that define New England’s culinary landscape. It’s a haven for those who appreciate quality seafood and the rich traditions that come with it.
7. The Lobster Shanty – Salem, Massachusetts
In the historic town of Salem, The Lobster Shanty offers a quirky twist on classic seafood dishes. Lobster mac and cheese and fish ‘n chips are the stars of the menu, providing comfort and flavor in equal measure.
The restaurant’s playful ambiance is a nod to Salem’s colorful history, inviting diners to relax and enjoy hearty portions of seafood delights. Each dish is crafted with care, ensuring a memorable dining experience.
For those seeking a taste of New England’s maritime past with a modern flair, The Lobster Shanty is the perfect destination. It’s a place where tradition meets creativity, and every meal is a delightful discovery.
8. Seaside Grill – Fort Lauderdale, Florida
Seaside Grill in Fort Lauderdale is a tropical paradise for seafood lovers. Known for its blackened mahi-mahi and coconut shrimp, this grill offers a taste of coastal Florida with every dish.
The beachside location provides the perfect backdrop for a meal that’s as refreshing as the ocean breeze. Diners can savor the flavors of the sea while soaking up the sun and enjoying the relaxed vibe.
Seaside Grill is more than just a restaurant; it’s an escape to a world where seafood reigns supreme. It’s a must-visit for those seeking a culinary adventure that’s as exciting as a day at the beach.
9. South Beach Bar & Grille – San Diego, California
South Beach Bar & Grille is a San Diego hotspot known for its Baja-style fish tacos and oyster shooters. The lively atmosphere is perfect for gathering with friends and enjoying a vibrant seafood feast.
The grill’s location offers stunning views of the ocean, enhancing the dining experience with a touch of coastal magic. Each dish is prepared with the freshest ingredients, reflecting the essence of the Pacific.
At South Beach Bar & Grille, every meal is a celebration of California’s seafood culture, offering a delightful escape into a world of flavor and fun. It’s a destination that promises great food and good times.
10. J.J. McBrewster’s – Bowling Green, Kentucky
In the heart of Kentucky, J.J. McBrewster’s offers a unique twist on seafood with its hickory-smoked catfish and bourbon-glazed shrimp. This rustic eatery is a testament to the creative fusion of local flavors and seafood delights.
The restaurant’s warm and inviting atmosphere mirrors the hearty, flavorful dishes served with a touch of Southern charm. Each meal is a celebration of Kentucky’s culinary heritage, offering a dining experience that’s both comforting and innovative.
J.J. McBrewster’s is a must-visit for those seeking an adventurous taste of seafood, where tradition meets new and exciting flavors. It’s a culinary gem in Bowling Green, promising a memorable meal for all who visit.
Leave a comment