Easter is that magical time of year when the sun shines a little brighter, the pastels come out in full force, and suddenly your kitchen smells like ham, cinnamon, and a little bit of chaos.
It’s the perfect excuse to gather with loved ones, show off your brunch game, and maybe eat your body weight in chocolate bunnies. No judgment here. But before you panic-buy enough food to feed a small army (or, let’s be real, your extended family), let’s talk strategy.
Not every Easter food belongs in your cart—or your fridge. Some dishes are pure tradition, absolutely essential. Others? They’re just taking up space and collecting polite-but-awkward “oh, interesting choice” comments.
So here’s your no-fluff, all-fun guide to 8 Easter Staple Foods You Should Stock Up On—and 8 You Can Totally Skip Without Missing a Beat.
1. Eggs (Lots of Them!)
Eggs are the unsung heroes of Easter, not just for dyeing but for so much more. Imagine starting your day with a savory breakfast casserole or delighting guests with a platter of deviled eggs.
Not to mention, the humble egg salad sandwich can bring smiles to everyone around the table. You can truly never have too many eggs during this holiday.
Whether hard-boiled, scrambled, or poached, eggs provide endless possibilities. They’re affordable, versatile, and can be transformed to fit any meal. Plus, they’re a protein-packed way to keep everyone satisfied.
2. Ham
Ham takes center stage at Easter dinner, often stealing the spotlight from everything else on the table. Its juicy, savory goodness is something that everyone looks forward to each year.
Whether you opt for a classic spiral-cut or a honey-glazed variety, ham is a crowd-pleaser. Leftovers? They transform into delicious sandwiches or a hearty breakfast hash.
The fragrance of a cooking ham fills the air with warmth and nostalgia, inviting everyone to gather and feast. It truly is the cornerstone of an Easter meal.
3. Hot Cross Buns
Hot cross buns are more than just a sweet treat; they’re a tradition that brings comfort and joy. These spiced buns, dotted with raisins and marked with a cross, have a delightful way of making mornings special.
Paired with a steaming cup of tea, they make for a perfect brunch or afternoon snack. Their rich aroma and soft texture invite you to savor every bite.
Whether enjoyed warm from the oven or toasted the next day, hot cross buns are a staple you won’t want to miss this Easter.
4. Asparagus
Asparagus is the embodiment of spring, bringing a fresh and vibrant touch to any Easter meal. Its crisp texture and earthy flavor are simply irresistible when roasted to perfection.
Whether served as a side dish or incorporated into a tart, asparagus adds a pop of color and nutrients to your plate. The simplicity of grilling or steaming enhances its natural taste.
It pairs beautifully with lemon and parmesan, creating a dish that’s as delightful as it is nutritious. Asparagus is a must-have for a truly refreshing Easter spread.
5. Scalloped Potatoes
Scalloped potatoes bring a creamy, cheesy richness that’s hard to resist at any Easter gathering. Layered with tender slices of potatoes and smothered in a velvety cheese sauce, they offer comfort in every bite.
This dish complements the savory flavors of ham and balances the sweetness of other Easter favorites. Plus, it’s a crowd favorite that leaves plates clean.
As they bake, the aroma wraps your home in a warm embrace, inviting everyone to the table. Scalloped potatoes are a must for any Easter menu.
6. Carrots
Carrots, with their vibrant orange hue, are a delightful addition to any Easter menu. These versatile veggies can be roasted to caramelized perfection or glazed with honey for a sweet finish.
Not only do they appeal to the Easter Bunny, but they also bring a touch of natural sweetness to your plate. Shredded into a fresh salad, they add crunch and color.
Carrots are a healthy, tasty way to round out your Easter meal, satisfying both kids and adults alike.
7. Dinner Rolls
Dinner rolls are the unsung heroes of any meal, perfectly fluffy and irresistible. Whether you use them to mop up gravy or enjoy them with a pat of butter, they’re a must-have.
Their simplicity is what makes them stand out, complementing the rich flavors of other dishes without stealing the show. They’re always a hit, disappearing quickly from the basket.
Warm, soft, and comforting, dinner rolls make every meal feel complete. Be sure to have plenty on hand for your Easter feast.
8. Chocolate Bunnies & Candy Eggs
Easter wouldn’t be complete without the playful delight of chocolate bunnies and candy eggs. These sweet treats are loved by kids and secretly enjoyed by adults too.
Whether they’re tucked into baskets or used for egg hunts, these sugary delights add a touch of whimsy to the celebration. The variety of chocolates and candies ensures there’s something for everyone’s sweet tooth.
No Easter is complete without indulging in these festive confections. Stock up to keep the holiday spirit alive!
1. Lamb (Unless It’s a Family Tradition)
Lamb might be a bit of a wildcard when it comes to Easter menus. If it’s not a family tradition, you might find it’s a hit-or-miss with your guests.
This meat can be pricey and its distinct flavor isn’t for everyone. Often, guests prefer sticking to familiar favorites like ham or chicken.
If lamb isn’t a staple for your family, consider skipping it and focusing on more crowd-pleasing options. Your guests will thank you!
2. Fruitcake
Fruitcake is often associated with holidays, but it doesn’t quite fit the spring vibe of Easter. Its dense texture and mix of candied fruits feel more at home during winter festivities.
Despite its rich flavor, fruitcake tends to polarize opinions, and many find it too heavy for an Easter dessert spread. Save it for Christmas, where it can shine a little brighter.
Easter calls for lighter, fresher desserts that celebrate the blossoming season. Consider other sweet options that align with the springtime spirit.
3. Overly Elaborate Salads
Elaborate salads, while visually stunning, often get overlooked at Easter gatherings. Their complexity might be more suited for a health-focused brunch than a festive family meal.
The intricate mix of ingredients like arugula, pomegranate, and avocado can be more effort than they’re worth. Simpler, fresh salads often receive more appreciation.
Stick to straightforward dishes that focus on flavor and balance, and leave the elaborate creations for another time.
4. Pre-Made Veggie Trays
Pre-made veggie trays promise convenience but often fall short in delivery. The veggies can dry out quickly, losing their crispness and appeal.
Ranch dressing, while a popular choice, doesn’t scream Easter, and the presentation can feel lackluster for a festive occasion. Making your own fresh veggie platter is a tastier alternative.
Skip the store-bought trays and opt for vibrant, freshly prepared vegetables that will truly wow your guests.
5. Jelly Beans (In Bulk)
Jelly beans are quintessentially Easter, but buying them in bulk might lead to leftovers that linger long after the holiday is over.
While they’re great for decorating and filling baskets, rarely do people polish off a jumbo bag. A small selection usually suffices and keeps waste to a minimum.
Consider buying just enough to enjoy the tradition without going overboard. Your pantry and waistline will appreciate it!
6. Too Many Pies
Pies are delicious, no doubt, but having too many can turn your Easter dessert spread into a sugar overload.
While variety is nice, overwhelming guests with choices can detract from the occasion’s joy. One or two well-loved pies are usually more than enough.
Choose a couple of classic flavors and let them shine, leaving room for other delightful desserts. Simplifying your selection keeps things enjoyable and less chaotic.
7. Canned Cranberry Sauce
Cranberry sauce is a Thanksgiving staple, and its rich, tangy flavor doesn’t quite fit the fresh vibe of spring. Easter calls for lighter, fruit-based sauces.
Replace this traditional favorite with something like a vibrant berry compote or citrus glaze that complements the season’s brightness. Your taste buds will thank you.
Leave cranberry sauce in its rightful holiday, and embrace the flavors of spring with open arms.
8. Fancy Cheese Boards
Cheese boards are trendy and look stunning but can overshadow your Easter meal’s main attractions.
While they offer a range of flavors and textures, guests often gravitate towards traditional favorites like ham and potatoes. The intricate setup can feel more suited for wine tasting than a family meal.
Focus your efforts on the classic dishes that everyone loves, and save the fancy cheese board for a more fitting occasion.
Leave a comment