Pizza: the universal love language. A warm, cheesy canvas that unites friends, families, and late-night cravings across the globe. But if we’re being really honest with ourselves, we have to admit that not all toppings are created equal.
For every pepperoni that makes your mouth water, there’s a rogue anchovy lurking in the shadows, waiting to ruin your perfect slice. Some toppings are beloved icons, others are just… still on the menu for reasons science has yet to explain.
So, in the name of crust-loving truth, we’re slicing deep into the world of pizza toppings. Seven that everybody fights to get the biggest piece of—and seven that are the reason someone always says “I’ll just pick it off.”
1. Anchovies
There’s bold, and then there’s fish on your pizza bold. Anchovies are the salty curveball that somehow made it onto the topping roster and just… never left.
The moment someone lifts that box lid and catches a whiff of the ocean, the whole room takes a collective step back. They’re briny, intense, and unapologetically fishy—traits that don’t exactly scream “comfort food.” And even if you pick them off, their strong flavor haunts the slice like a seafood ghost.
Sure, some folks defend them with artisan pride, but let’s be honest: anchovies are the black sheep of the pizza family. Most people never asked for them, and they definitely don’t miss them when they’re gone.
2. Green Bell Peppers
They might look fresh and festive, but these crunchy little intruders have a way of hijacking the flavor of an entire pie.
Green bell peppers don’t play nice with cheese and sauce. Instead, they overpower everything with their grassy, slightly bitter bite. It’s like they walked into the party, turned the music down, and asked everyone about their tax returns.
Even worse? They don’t even soften up in the oven half the time. So you’re left chewing through awkward slices of vegetable armor when you just wanted melty, savory bliss. For many, bell peppers are a filler—an afterthought topping thrown on to convince you that your pizza is “healthy.”
Newsflash: it’s still pizza. And bell peppers didn’t save it.
3. Pineapple
Sweet and juicy on a hot summer day? Absolutely. But baked into molten cheese and tomato sauce? That’s a pineapple plot twist too far for many.
The whole “Hawaiian pizza” thing divides households and friendships alike. For every person that swears by the sweet-and-savory contrast, there’s another who views it as a culinary crime against dough.
And the worst part? Pineapple doesn’t just sit quietly—it seeps. Its sugary juice creeps across the crust, giving your pepperoni a candied glaze no one asked for.
If you love it, you’re passionate. If you hate it, you’re really passionate.
Let’s just say pineapple on pizza didn’t walk into the conversation—it cannonballed into it.
4. Olives
They roll onto the scene looking harmless, but olives are sneaky. One bite and suddenly your entire pizza tastes like a salty brine bath.
Whether it’s black or green, sliced or whole, olives bring a pungent punch that refuses to share the stage. They’re like the person at the potluck who insists on telling loud travel stories while you’re trying to enjoy your meal.
Some appreciate the tangy flair—Mediterranean vibes and all—but most people are just trying to pick them off without making a scene.
And let’s not even talk about the texture.
Squishy and firm at the same time? Pick a lane, olive.
5. Artichokes
Someone decided that pizza needed to be more “elevated,” and suddenly artichokes started showing up where they clearly didn’t belong.
These leafy, fibrous thistles might work in a dip, but on a pizza? They feel out of place—like a guest who showed up to a barbecue in formalwear.
The texture is confusing: chewy in the middle, papery at the edges. And their earthy flavor doesn’t exactly complement gooey cheese and spicy meats. It’s more like… someone dropped a salad on your slice.
You chew, you question your life choices, and you quietly vow never to order the “gourmet” pizza again. Artichokes on pizza are trying too hard. And nobody asked them to.
6. Eggplant
Soft, bland, and often drowning in oil—eggplant brings little to the pizza party except confusion.
It’s the introverted cousin of zucchini that always needs babysitting in the oven. Undercooked, it’s spongy and bitter. Overcooked, it’s a slippery mess. When done just right, sure, it can be tolerable. But pizza isn’t supposed to be a culinary gamble, and eggplant is one risky bet most of us don’t want to take.
Even when layered with sauce and cheese, eggplant rarely holds its own. It’s like the background extra in a scene full of flavor-packed stars, quietly hoping someone notices it… but no one ever does.
7. Capers
Tiny, tangy, and totally divisive—capers show up when someone tries to “chef up” a pizza.
Their flavor is sharp and vinegary, and they burst with a sour tang that instantly overpowers milder ingredients. Think of them as little flavor bombs that detonate right on your taste buds.
Some people adore their pickled punch, but most pizza lovers are just confused: “Wait… are those peas? Why do they taste like pickle juice?”
Capers are like surprise plot twists you didn’t sign up for. They belong in delicate Mediterranean dishes—not smack dab in the middle of your Friday night comfort food.
1. Pepperoni
Crackly edges, spicy bite, and pools of glorious orange grease—pepperoni is the Beyoncé of pizza toppings.
It’s flavorful without being overpowering, spicy without scaring your taste buds, and just greasy enough to make you forget about your diet entirely. When the oven does its magic, pepperoni curls into crispy little cups that trap cheesy goodness like edible treasure chests. It’s not just a topping—it’s an experience.
From toddlers to grandpas, carnivores to picky eaters, pepperoni unites us in cheesy harmony. If pizza were high school, pepperoni would win “Most Popular” and “Best Dressed.” Hands down.
2. Mushrooms
Earthy, juicy, and totally underrated—mushrooms are the unsung heroes of the pizza world.
They soak up flavors like a sponge and bring a depth that balances cheese and sauce like a culinary middleman. Sautéed beforehand, they develop a meaty texture that even veggie skeptics can get behind. Paired with garlic? Game over.
Whether you’re a veggie-lover or just looking to mix it up, mushrooms hit that savory umami note that makes each bite feel fuller, richer, better. They’re not flashy—but they’re loyal. Mushrooms always show up and do the job right.
3. Italian Sausage
Every bite of sausage comes with a kick of flavor and a burst of meaty satisfaction.
Whether it’s spicy, sweet, or herby, this topping knows how to command attention without being obnoxious. Sausage has texture, character, and that crumbly-yet-juicy magic that makes your pizza feel like a full-blown meal. It’s like biting into pizza with a side of Sunday dinner.
And let’s not forget how beautifully it pairs with mushrooms, onions, or peppers (yes—even the green ones sometimes). Sausage is that dependable topping that elevates every pie it touches. It’s the meat lover’s dream—and no one’s ever mad to see it on a slice.
4. Extra Cheese
Let’s face it—there’s no such thing as too much cheese. That bubbling, stretchy, golden layer of heaven is the very soul of pizza.
Extra cheese takes what we already love and turns the dial up to eleven. It oozes over the edges, creates those iconic cheese pulls, and clings lovingly to every bite. It’s warm, comforting, and indulgent in the best way.
No drama, no controversy—just cheesy unity. Whether it’s mozzarella, provolone, or a fancy blend, more cheese equals more joy. Ask any pizza lover: if a slice isn’t extra cheesy, is it even worth it?
5. Bacon
When crispy, smoky bacon lands on a pizza, everything changes.
It adds texture, saltiness, and that unmistakable sizzle of indulgence. Bacon doesn’t just blend in—it boosts the flavor of everything around it. Pair it with onions, mushrooms, or even pineapple (if you’re that kind of person), and the magic happens instantly.
Each bite delivers a satisfying crunch and that rich, savory flavor that makes bacon one of the few things people are willing to fight over. On pizza, it’s less breakfast food and more flavor MVP. Bacon makes every slice better. Period.
6. Onions (especially caramelized)
They’re sweet, they’re savory, and when they’re caramelized? Absolute perfection.
Onions don’t just add flavor—they bring balance. They cut through the richness of cheese and meat, adding just the right hint of sharpness or sweetness, depending on how they’re cooked. Raw red onions bring a nice bite, but when they’re sautéed to a golden brown, they practically melt into the pie.
They play well with everyone—from sausage to mushrooms—and never steal the spotlight. Onions are the quiet MVP of flavor, making everything just a little more interesting without asking for too much attention.
7. Fresh Basil
A sprinkle of basil can take a pizza from “nice” to “chef’s kiss” in two seconds flat.
It’s not about punchy flavors or bold textures—it’s about that pop of freshness. The slight sweetness, the herbal lift, the “I-feel-like-I’m-in-Italy” aroma. Whether it’s laid on raw after baking or crisped slightly in the oven, basil brings class to any slice it graces.
And let’s be real: visually, it turns a pizza into art. Basil is the final flourish—the garnish that whispers, yes, this is gourmet. Simple, elegant, and universally loved.
Leave a comment