Costco’s bakery section is a treasure trove of delights, but not all items are created equal. For every standout treat, there’s one that might not hit the spot. Here’s a guide to help you navigate your next bakery run with confidence, featuring seven must-try delights and seven you might want to leave behind.
1. Carrot Bar Cake
Carrot cake fans, brace yourselves. While this carrot bar cake might seem tempting, it’s the raisins that often deter many. Some love the chewy surprise, but others find it interrupts the moist texture of the cake.
The frosting, however, is sweet and creamy, offering a delightful contrast to the spiced cake. Still, if raisins aren’t your thing, you might want to give this a pass. Consider opting for a raisin-free option if you’re a purist at heart.
2. Braided Apple Strudel
Beautifully golden and inviting, the braided apple strudel certainly catches the eye—but its flavor doesn’t always live up to the presentation. The crisp exterior sets high expectations, yet the filling often leans too sweet and lacks a true apple-forward taste.
While it can make for a comforting snack alongside a warm drink, it may not impress at a dinner party. If you’re after a classic, fruit-filled pastry experience, this one might not hit the mark.
3. Banana Cream Pie
Banana cream pie enthusiasts might find Costco’s version a bit too creamy. The banana flavor seems overshadowed by the heavy cream layer, which might not suit everyone’s palate.
For those who enjoy a cream-dominant pie, it might be a hit. However, if you’re after a balanced banana and cream experience, this could miss the mark. Consider trying another bakery pick for a more fruity punch.
4. Mini Chocolate Muffins
At first glance, these mini chocolate muffins seem like a no-brainer treat—but don’t let looks fool you. While they may appear rich and decadent, the flavor tends to be surprisingly mild, lacking that deep cocoa punch chocolate lovers crave.
They’re a decent snack for kids, but if you’re seeking a more indulgent option, Costco’s bakery has better chocolate offerings worth exploring.
5. Kirkland Signature Chocolate Chunk Cookies
Costco’s chocolate chunk cookies are a favorite for some, but not all. The generous chocolate chunks are a highlight, yet the cookie itself can be overly sweet.
While they make for a convenient snack, those with a preference for a balanced sweetness might not find these appealing.
Pairing with a bitter coffee could offer some contrast, but these aren’t everyone’s cookie of choice.
6. Sugar Bowl Bakery Apple Fritters
There’s something nostalgic about apple fritters—but these fall a bit flat. The sugary glaze tends to overpower the subtle apple chunks, resulting in a sweetness that lacks balance.
They’ll satisfy a quick craving in a pinch, but for those chasing a true apple-forward pastry, this option might leave you wanting more. A different bakery pick could offer a better fruit-to-sweet ratio.
7. La Boulangere French Crepes
Crepes are often associated with a touch of indulgence—but these pre-packaged French crepes miss the mark. Their texture tends to be dry, and the flavor lacks the light, buttery nuance that makes homemade crepes so special.
Dressed up with fresh fruit or a drizzle of sauce, they can pass as a convenient breakfast or dessert, but they’re unlikely to win over true crepe enthusiasts. For a more satisfying experience, making them from scratch might be the way to go.
Now, let’s shift gears and take a look at the Costco bakery items that are worth adding to your cart.
1. Butter Sugar Cookies with Spring Sprinkles
Butter sugar cookies with spring sprinkles are a visual delight in Costco’s bakery. These cookies offer a melt-in-the-mouth experience, with just the right amount of sweetness.
The sprinkles add a fun, festive element, making them a hit at gatherings. They’re perfect for those who love a classic, buttery cookie with a playful twist. Ideal for sharing, these cookies are sure to bring smiles to any occasion.
2. Garlic Parmesan Butter Dinner Rolls
These garlic parmesan butter dinner rolls are the epitome of comfort. Soft and fluffy, each bite offers a savory blend of garlic and parmesan, making them a perfect accompaniment to any meal.
They’re a star at family dinners or friendly gatherings, adding an irresistible aroma to the table. For those who appreciate a well-seasoned roll, these are a must-try delight from the Costco bakery.
3. Tiramisu Cheesecake
If you’re torn between cheesecake and tiramisu, Costco’s tiramisu cheesecake offers the best of both worlds. This dessert layers velvety creaminess with bold coffee notes, creating a harmonious blend that’s both rich and satisfying.
Every bite delivers a luxurious taste that fans of indulgent sweets will appreciate. It’s no surprise this hybrid treat has become a standout favorite in the bakery section.
4. Kirkland Signature Cheesecake
Kirkland Signature cheesecake is a staple that seldom disappoints. Creamy and smooth, it offers a perfect canvas for toppings like fresh fruit or chocolate sauce.
It stands as a versatile dessert, suitable for various occasions, from casual get-togethers to festive celebrations.
For those who appreciate a classic, straightforward cheesecake, this is a go-to choice that consistently pleases.
5. Four Berry Pie
Packed with vibrant flavor, Costco’s four berry pie delivers a juicy medley of berries in every slice. The sweet-tart filling strikes a satisfying balance, while the golden, flaky crust ties it all together beautifully.
It’s a go-to pick for fruit dessert fans and pairs perfectly with a scoop of vanilla ice cream—bringing a taste of summer to the table no matter the season.
6. Croissant Loaf
The croissant loaf is a unique find at Costco. It combines the buttery flakiness of a croissant with the convenience of a loaf, making it versatile for sandwiches or toast.
Its texture and flavor make it stand out, offering a touch of gourmet to everyday meals. For those who love croissants but seek more versatility, this loaf is a must-try.
7. Mantecada Muffins
Subtly sweet and wonderfully tender, Costco’s mantecada muffins are a quiet hit among bakery shoppers. Their soft, buttery texture makes them an ideal companion to a morning coffee or afternoon tea.
They’re not flashy or overly rich, but that’s exactly their charm—simple, satisfying, and just sweet enough. If you prefer a muffin that’s more comforting than indulgent, this is one to grab.
Leave a comment