Cheese can make or break a sub—it’s the element that ties flavors together, adds richness, and brings that irresistible gooey texture that sandwich lovers crave. A well-melted, flavorful cheese can elevate even the simplest ingredients, transforming an ordinary sub into a satisfying masterpiece. Unfortunately, not every sandwich delivers on its cheesy promise. Some fall flat with rubbery textures, uneven melt, or bland slices that disappear into the background rather than enhancing the overall bite.
On the other hand, there are subs that truly understand the assignment. These sandwiches feature cheese that oozes just the right way, complements the fillings, and adds that luscious, indulgent layer that lingers on the palate. From sharp provolone draped over roast beef to bubbling mozzarella in a meatball sub, the right cheese—and the way it’s melted—can define the entire experience. This guide takes a close look at six subs that disappoint when it comes to cheese, and nine that get it exactly right. Whether you’re a die-hard sandwich enthusiast or just someone on the hunt for the ultimate melt, these picks will help you discover where to find (or avoid) the cheesiest, most satisfying bites.
1. Quiznos
Once hailed for its toasted subs, Quiznos has some catching up to do in the cheese department. A customer might expect a gooey experience but find themselves yearning for more cheese. The lack of generous cheese portions leaves an unfulfilled promise of flavor.
The toasty exterior is not enough to compensate for the absence of rich, melted cheese. This can lead to a sub that’s more bread than cheese, leaving cheese enthusiasts disappointed. Cheese should be the hero, but here it feels more like a sidekick. The hunt for flavor in a Quiznos sub remains a quest unfulfilled for many.
2. Jimmy John’s
Speedy delivery doesn’t always translate to cheesy satisfaction at Jimmy John’s. The promise of a satisfying cheese pull is often unmet. Despite quality meats and fresh veggies, cheese often plays second fiddle.
For those who crave a bold cheese presence, Jimmy John’s may not hit the mark. The cheese feels like an afterthought, leaving fans of melted perfection wanting more. It’s a sub that excels elsewhere but misses the cheese-loving crowd. Ultimately, a sub with potential, yet it leaves cheese lovers pondering what could have been with more cheese.
3. Subway
Subway offers customization like no other, yet its cheese offerings sometimes fall flat. Customers looking for cheesy subs might find themselves with sparse slices instead of a melty indulgence. Despite the assortment of toppings, cheese can feel like a minor player.
The melt-in-your-mouth experience that many crave is missing, overshadowed by other ingredients. For cheese aficionados, this can feel like a missed opportunity. With so much potential to customize, the lack of abundant cheese leaves a void that bread and toppings can’t fill.
4. Firehouse Subs
Firehouse Subs is known for hearty portions and savory meats, yet its cheese sometimes fails to impress. The richness and fullness of flavor one expects might be lost amidst the layers.
While the subs are filling, the cheese can sometimes blend into the background rather than taking center stage. This can lead to a delicious sub experience overshadowed by the absence of cheesy satisfaction. A sub experience that has the potential to be great, but leaves cheese lovers yearning for more.
5. Arby’s
Known for its meats, Arby’s cheese options can sometimes leave cheese lovers wanting. The signature roast beef might steal the show, pushing the cheese to the sidelines.
The quest for a heavenly cheesy bite can turn into an elusive chase. Despite the flavorful meats, the cheese often doesn’t get its time to shine. For those seeking a cheese-forward sub, Arby’s might not satisfy your craving. It’s a journey where cheese takes a backseat.
6. Potbelly
Potbelly’s warm sandwiches are beloved by many, yet the cheese experience can sometimes be underwhelming. Those expecting a melty embrace might find themselves wanting more.
While the toasted bread and flavorful fillings are commendable, the cheese often doesn’t make the impact one hopes for. It’s a sandwich that promises much but delivers less in the cheese department. The potential for a delightful cheesy sub is there, but it lacks that gooey, satisfying finish.
7. Lenny’s Grill & Subs
At Lenny’s, cheese lovers find their paradise. Each bite bursts with gooey, melted cheese that complements the hearty subs perfectly. The balance of flavors is a testament to their commitment to quality.
Sub enthusiasts relish in the rich, creamy cheese that doesn’t just accompany but enhances the sub experience. A single bite can transport you to cheese heaven, with layers of flavor that satisfy every craving. The generous cheese portions make Lenny’s a top choice for those seeking an indulgent, flavorful meal.
8. Jersey Mike’s
Jersey Mike’s is synonymous with cheese perfection. Their subs are a celebration of melted cheese that oozes with every bite. Fans of cheese find joy in the generous portions that complement their quality ingredients.
The subs at Jersey Mike’s are crafted with attention to detail, ensuring that cheese isn’t just an ingredient but a star player. It’s a sensory delight that beckons cheese enthusiasts. For those who cherish a cheesy experience, Jersey Mike’s delivers consistently, offering a satisfying bite each time.
9. Publix Deli Subs
For those who crave cheese perfection, Publix Deli Subs have become a staple. The melted cheese envelops the sandwiches, elevating the flavor to new heights, creating a deli experience that delights the senses.
The quality of the ingredients is evident, with cheese that melts beautifully, adding a rich, creamy texture. Each bite reflects their dedication to quality and taste. For anyone seeking cheesy fulfillment, Publix Deli Subs offer an unforgettable experience.
10. Mendocino Farms
Mendocino Farms crafts subs that are a tribute to cheese lovers. The cheese isn’t just melted; it’s a velvety layer that embraces each ingredient, creating a symphony of flavors.
Every bite reveals the care and quality that goes into their subs, with cheese taking center stage. It’s a dining experience where cheese isn’t just present but celebrated. For those who cherish a rich, cheesy experience, Mendocino Farms stands out as a prime choice.
11. Ike’s Love & Sandwiches
For cheese enthusiasts, Ike’s Love & Sandwiches offers a truly charming experience. Their subs are packed with a generous layer of cheese, providing a delightful culinary experience.
At Ike’s, the cheese is more than just a topping; it enhances the flavors of their diverse fillings. Each sandwich feels like a warm embrace, delivering cheesy excellence with every bite. This dedication to indulgence has made Ike’s a beloved choice for those seeking satisfaction in every sandwich.
12. Schlotzsky’s
Schlotzsky’s offers a sub experience where cheese is more than an afterthought. It’s a key player in creating a flavorful masterpiece that excites the taste buds.
The cheese here is perfectly melted, enhancing the distinctive flavors of their signature subs. Rich and creamy, it brings every bite to life. For those yearning for a cheese-filled adventure, Schlotzsky’s delivers a satisfying and delicious journey.
13. Capriotti’s
Capriotti’s knows how to make cheese the star of their subs. With each bite, the cheese is a delightful surprise, melted to perfection and complementing their flavorful ingredients.
The rich, creamy texture of their cheese brings an unparalleled depth to their subs. It’s a culinary delight that promises satisfaction in every bite. At Capriotti’s, cheese lovers find their haven, where each sub is crafted with care and cheesy goodness.
14. Which Wich
At Which Wich, the sub experience is elevated by cheese that enhances the entire meal. The gooey, melted cheese adds a comforting texture that pairs beautifully with their diverse fillings.
Fans of cheese are treated to a haven of flavor, where each bite highlights the power of perfectly melted cheese. It’s a symphony of tastes that leaves a lasting impression. For those who cherish cheesy perfection, Which Wich stands as a beacon of deliciousness.
15. Eegee’s
Eegee’s offers a sub experience where cheese takes the spotlight. The rich, melted cheese envelops every ingredient, creating a harmonious blend of flavors.
With each bite, the cheese provides a creamy, satisfying texture that delights cheese enthusiasts. It’s a comforting experience that warms the heart and satisfies the palate. Eegee’s dedication to cheesy excellence makes it a must-visit for anyone seeking a hearty, flavorful sub.
Leave a comment