Mayo has ruled sandwich spreads for decades, but it’s time to expand your horizons. From creamy avocado to zesty harissa, there’s a whole world of flavors waiting to transform your everyday sandwich. These alternatives aren’t just tastier – many offer better nutrition and accommodate dietary restrictions that mayo can’t match.
1. Avocado Smash
Mashed avocado transforms ordinary bread into something extraordinary with its buttery texture and subtle flavor. Simply scoop a ripe avocado, add a squeeze of lime juice, sprinkle of salt, and mash until you reach your desired consistency.
The healthy fats in avocados keep you satisfied longer than mayo ever could, while providing nutrients like potassium and fiber. Some people add garlic powder or red pepper flakes for extra dimension.
To prevent browning, press plastic wrap directly onto the surface of leftover avocado smash before refrigerating. For the creamiest spread, choose avocados that yield slightly to gentle pressure but aren’t mushy.
2. Hummus
Chickpeas transformed into velvety goodness create a protein-packed spread that puts mayo to shame. Traditional hummus blends chickpeas with tahini, olive oil, lemon juice, and garlic for a nutty, smooth texture that clings perfectly to bread.
Unlike mayo’s one-note flavor, hummus offers complex taste that pairs beautifully with both veggies and meats. Store-bought varieties come in dozens of flavors – roasted red pepper, olive, jalapeño – but homemade allows you to control the consistency and flavors.
For sandwich perfection, spread hummus thickly on one side and add crisp vegetables for textural contrast. The protein content helps make your sandwich more filling and nutritionally complete than with mayo.
3. Greek Yogurt Spread
Tangy, thick, and protein-packed, Greek yogurt makes an exceptional mayo replacement that adds dimension to any sandwich.
Mix full-fat Greek yogurt with minced garlic, chopped herbs like dill or chives, and a pinch of salt for a spread that delivers creaminess without the heaviness. The natural probiotics support gut health while the protein content makes your sandwich more satisfying. Unlike mayo, Greek yogurt brings a pleasant tanginess that brightens flavors, especially in chicken or turkey sandwiches.
For best results, strain your yogurt through cheesecloth for a few hours to remove excess moisture. This creates an ultra-thick spread that won’t make bread soggy. Try adding lemon zest or a dash of za’atar spice blend for Mediterranean-inspired sandwiches.
4. Ricotta Cheese
Fresh ricotta offers a delicate, cloud-like texture that transforms ordinary sandwiches into something special. This versatile Italian cheese works beautifully in both sweet and savory applications, making it twice as useful as one-dimensional mayo.
For savory sandwiches, mix ricotta with lemon zest, cracked pepper, and fresh herbs like basil or thyme. The mild, milky flavor provides a neutral canvas that enhances rather than competes with other ingredients. Sweet applications shine too – try ricotta with honey, cinnamon, and sliced strawberries on toast for breakfast.
Unlike cream cheese, ricotta’s texture is lighter and more pillowy, creating a luxurious mouthfeel without heaviness. The protein content makes it more nutritionally valuable than mayo as well.
5. Cottage Cheese
Lumpy but lovable, cottage cheese creates a protein-packed sandwich base that’s miles healthier than mayo. Blending it briefly transforms those characteristic curds into a smooth spread while maintaining the fresh dairy flavor.
Mix in chopped chives, cracked pepper, and a dash of garlic powder for a savory version that pairs beautifully with turkey or roast beef. The high protein content (about 14 grams per half-cup) makes your sandwich substantially more filling than with mayo.
Health enthusiasts appreciate cottage cheese’s impressive nutritional profile – low in calories yet high in calcium and protein. For the smoothest texture, use small-curd varieties and blend with a touch of olive oil. Try it with sliced cucumber and radish for a refreshing summer sandwich with satisfying crunch.
6. Baba Ghanoush
Smoky roasted eggplant forms the foundation of this Middle Eastern spread that makes mayo seem utterly boring by comparison. The silky-smooth texture comes from blending charred eggplant with tahini, olive oil, lemon juice, and garlic.
The complex flavor profile starts with deep smokiness, followed by nutty tahini notes and bright lemon finish. Unlike mayo’s flat taste, baba ghanoush evolves as you eat it. Spread it thickly on crusty bread and pair with roasted red peppers, feta, and cucumber for a Mediterranean-inspired sandwich.
Making it at home allows you to control the smokiness – more time over an open flame or under the broiler intensifies this distinctive characteristic. The plant-based ingredients provide fiber and nutrients while keeping calories lower than oil-based mayo.
7. Flavored Cream Cheese
Cream cheese transforms from breakfast staple to sandwich superstar when blended with bold flavors. The dense, velvety texture creates a moisture barrier that prevents soggy bread – something mayo often fails to do.
Savory versions with chives, jalapeños, or sun-dried tomatoes pair beautifully with turkey, roast beef, or veggie sandwiches. The tanginess cuts through rich ingredients while the creamy texture brings everything together. Sweet varieties with berries or honey make incredible dessert sandwiches. Unlike mayo’s singular flavor profile, cream cheese adapts to whatever you mix in.
Make your own flavored versions by blending room-temperature cream cheese with roasted garlic, fresh herbs, or caramelized onions. For best spreadability, let cream cheese sit at room temperature for 15 minutes before using it.
8. Pesto Varieties
Vibrant basil pesto delivers an intense herb-forward punch that makes mayo seem like a bland afterthought. This Italian spread combines fresh basil, pine nuts, Parmesan, garlic, and olive oil into a versatile green sauce that transforms any sandwich.
Beyond classic basil, explore sun-dried tomato pesto for sweet-tart intensity or kale pesto for earthy notes and extra nutrients. The oil-based nature of pesto means it infuses surrounding ingredients with flavor while preventing bread from becoming soggy.
Pesto works magic with turkey, chicken, or mozzarella sandwiches. The concentrated flavor means a little goes a long way – just a tablespoon can replace several spoonfuls of mayo. For a dairy-free version, substitute nutritional yeast for the Parmesan and enjoy the same herbaceous punch.
9. Harissa
This North African chili paste packs serious heat and complexity that plain mayo could never dream of matching. The brick-red mixture combines roasted red peppers, hot chili peppers, garlic, and spices like cumin and coriander into a versatile spread.
Unlike one-dimensional hot sauces, harissa offers layered heat with smoky undertones and aromatic spice notes. The thick consistency makes it perfect for spreading directly on bread. Start with a thin layer if you’re heat-sensitive – a little goes a long way!
Harissa transforms ordinary turkey or chicken sandwiches into memorable meals. For a cooling contrast, pair it with cucumber slices or a schmear of yogurt on the opposite bread slice. Many grocery stores carry harissa paste, but the homemade version allows you to customize the heat level to your preference.
10. Chipotle Aioli
Smoky chipotle peppers transform ordinary aioli into a spread with personality and kick. The distinctive flavor comes from dried jalapeños that have been smoke-dried, creating complex notes that regular mayo can’t touch.
Making chipotle aioli at home lets you control the heat level. Start with mayonnaise or Greek yogurt as your base, then blend in chipotle peppers in adobo sauce, lime juice, and garlic. The result is smoky, spicy and slightly sweet – perfect for elevating basic turkey or chicken sandwiches.
Unlike plain mayo, chipotle aioli actively contributes flavor rather than just adding moisture. The smokiness pairs beautifully with bacon, avocado, or grilled vegetables. For extra dimension, add a touch of honey to balance the heat with subtle sweetness.
11. Sriracha Greek Yogurt
This brilliant marriage combines tangy Greek yogurt with the sweet-spicy kick of sriracha for a protein-packed spread that makes mayo seem nutritionally empty. The cooling dairy base tempers sriracha’s heat while maintaining its distinctive flavor profile.
Creating this spread couldn’t be simpler – mix thick Greek yogurt with sriracha to taste, adding lime zest for brightness and a pinch of salt to enhance flavors. The result delivers protein, probiotics, and bold taste in one vibrant package.
This spread adds nutritional value with approximately 10 grams of protein per quarter cup. The vivid orange-pink color brightens any sandwich visually. Try it with turkey, cucumber, and lettuce for a refreshing lunch with satisfying heat that builds gradually rather than overwhelming your palate.
12. Mustard Variations
Mustard offers incredible diversity that single-note mayo can’t match. Dijon brings sophisticated tanginess, whole grain adds interesting texture, and spicy brown delivers pleasant heat – each creating distinctive sandwich experiences.
Mustard actively enhances surrounding flavors through its natural acidity. The vinegar base cuts through fatty meats like ham or roast beef while complementing cheeses beautifully. Specialty mustards infused with honey, horseradish, or herbs create even more possibilities.
Health-conscious eaters appreciate mustard’s minimal calorie content – typically just 5-15 calories per tablespoon compared to mayo’s 90-100. The bold flavor means you need less to make an impact. For maximum flavor, spread mustard directly on protein rather than bread to create a flavor-sealed package within your sandwich.
13. Tapenade
This Mediterranean olive spread delivers intense umami and complex saltiness that makes mayo seem utterly one-dimensional. Traditional tapenade combines olives, capers, anchovies, and olive oil into a chunky paste with remarkable depth.
The bold flavor profile means a little goes a long way – just a tablespoon can transform an ordinary sandwich into something special. Black olive versions offer earthy notes while green olive varieties bring brighter, more vegetal flavors. The natural oils create a moisture barrier that prevents bread from becoming soggy.
Tapenade pairs magnificently with turkey, chicken, or vegetarian sandwiches. For a complete Mediterranean experience, combine it with roasted red peppers and fresh mozzarella. Most supermarkets carry prepared versions, but homemade allows you to control the salt level and olive varieties for a customized spread.
14. Peanut Butter
Peanut butter transcends its reputation as just a partner for jelly. This protein-rich spread creates magnificent savory sandwiches that showcase its versatility far beyond mayo’s limited range. The natural oils and protein in peanut butter create a satisfying mouthfeel while adding nutritional value.
Try it with crisp bacon for a salty-sweet combination that’s become cult-favorite, or pair with thinly sliced apples and sharp cheddar for a sweet-savory masterpiece. Even pickle fans have discovered peanut butter’s affinity for briny companions – the contrast between creamy, sweet spread and tangy, crunchy pickles creates unexpected harmony.
Choose natural peanut butter without added sugars for savory applications. The healthy fats and approximately 8 grams of protein per serving make this spread nutritionally superior to empty-calorie mayonnaise.
15. Almond or Cashew Butter
More refined than peanut butter, these tree nut spreads offer subtle flavor profiles that enhance rather than dominate sandwich ingredients. The smooth, rich texture creates a luxurious mouthfeel that makes mayo seem pedestrian by comparison.
Almond butter brings a delicate nuttiness that pairs beautifully with roasted vegetables or sliced apples. Cashew butter offers sweeter notes with buttery richness that complements turkey or chicken perfectly. Both provide healthy monounsaturated fats and protein that make sandwiches more nutritionally complete. For savory applications, choose unsweetened varieties and add a pinch of salt to enhance flavors.
The natural oils in nut butters create a moisture barrier that keeps bread from getting soggy – a functional advantage over mayo. Try almond butter with roasted eggplant and red peppers for a vegetarian sandwich with satisfying protein.
16. Tahini
Ground sesame seeds create this Middle Eastern staple with a uniquely nutty, slightly bitter profile that makes mayo seem flat by comparison. The smooth, pourable consistency coats bread perfectly while adding distinctive flavor that enhances surrounding ingredients.
Raw tahini tends toward bitter notes, while toasted tahini develops deeper, more complex flavors. Either way, this spread delivers healthy fats, protein, and minerals like calcium and iron. Mix it with lemon juice and garlic for a simple spread that pairs beautifully with roasted vegetables or grilled chicken.
Its subtle bitterness balances sweet elements like roasted bell peppers or caramelized onions. For maximum spreadability, stir tahini thoroughly before using, as natural separation occurs with the oils rising to the top.
17. Vegan Mayo
Plant-based mayo alternatives have evolved dramatically, now offering texture and flavor that rivals traditional egg-based versions. Made with aquafaba (chickpea water), soy milk, or oil emulsions, these spreads satisfy mayo cravings without animal products.
Modern vegan mayos nail the creamy texture and tangy flavor profile of conventional mayo while being cholesterol-free. Some versions incorporate nutritional yeast for subtle umami notes that traditional mayo lacks. The best brands spread beautifully without the sometimes-greasy mouthfeel of conventional mayo. Perfect for classic applications like chickpea “tuna” salad or tomato sandwiches, vegan mayo works anywhere traditional mayo would.
Refrigeration extends shelf life significantly compared to egg-based versions. For those monitoring fat intake, look for varieties made with aquafaba rather than oil for lighter alternatives with fewer calories.
18. Cashew Cream
Soaked cashews blend into a remarkably versatile cream that can replace mayo with superior nutrition and adaptable flavor. The neutral, slightly sweet profile provides an excellent base for both savory and sweet applications.
Creating cashew cream requires just raw cashews soaked in water, then blended with fresh water until silky smooth. Add lemon juice and salt for a basic savory version, or incorporate herbs, nutritional yeast, or garlic for more complex profiles. The result spreads beautifully with a luxurious mouthfeel similar to mayo but with more nutritional benefits.
The creamy consistency stands up to sandwich fillings without making bread soggy. For maximum smoothness, use a high-powered blender and strain through fine mesh if needed. Refrigerated cashew cream keeps for about 5 days.
19. Tofu Spread
Silken tofu transforms into a chameleon-like spread that absorbs flavors while providing protein-packed creaminess. When blended with lemon juice, garlic, and herbs, it creates a remarkably versatile mayo alternative with significantly fewer calories and more nutrition.
The neutral base allows endless customization – add nutritional yeast for cheesy notes, sun-dried tomatoes for Mediterranean flair, or curry powder for Indian-inspired sandwiches. The smooth texture spreads easily while staying put on bread without soaking through.
The plant-based protein makes vegetarian sandwiches more satisfying and nutritionally complete. For best results, drain silken tofu thoroughly before blending and store in an airtight container for up to five days.
20. Tomato Jam
Slow-cooked tomatoes with sugar and spices create a sweet-savory spread that makes mayo seem utterly uninspired. The concentrated flavor combines tomato’s natural umami with caramelized sweetness and subtle spice notes from cinnamon, cloves, or ginger.
The thick, spreadable consistency stays put on bread while adding moisture without sogginess. The vibrant red color brings visual appeal to any sandwich creation. Tomato jam pairs magnificently with sharp cheeses, bacon, or turkey. The sweet-savory balance cuts through rich ingredients while complementing milder ones.
Make your own by slowly simmering tomatoes with brown sugar, vinegar, and spices until thick and jammy, or look for artisanal versions at farmers markets and specialty stores.
21. Caramelized Onion Spread
Patience transforms humble onions into a deeply flavored spread with remarkable complexity. Slowly cooking sliced onions until golden brown develops natural sugars while concentrating their savory essence into a sweet-savory masterpiece.
The resulting spread delivers umami richness that makes mayo seem flat by comparison. Add a splash of balsamic vinegar during cooking for tangy depth, or incorporate fresh thyme for herbal notes. The spreadable consistency works beautifully on everything from beef to vegetarian sandwiches.
The concentrated flavor means a little goes a long way – just a tablespoon can transform an ordinary sandwich. Make a large batch on weekends and store refrigerated for quick sandwich upgrades throughout the week.
22. Roasted Red Pepper Spread
Charred red peppers blended with olive oil and garlic create a vibrantly colored spread with natural sweetness and smoky depth. The silky texture and concentrated flavor make mayo seem bland and uninteresting by comparison.
Making this spread at home is surprisingly simple – roast red bell peppers until blackened, remove the skins, then blend with olive oil, garlic, and a touch of salt. Some versions incorporate walnuts or almonds for protein and texture. The result is a versatile spread that works on virtually any sandwich.
The vivid color brightens any lunch while the sweet-smoky flavor enhances everything from turkey to mozzarella. Unlike mayo, this spread contributes vitamin C and antioxidants from the peppers. For extra dimension, add a pinch of smoked paprika or a splash of sherry vinegar before blending.
23. Mashed White Bean Spread
Cannellini beans transform into a protein-packed spread with creamy texture and endless flavor possibilities. Simply mash the beans with olive oil, lemon juice, and herbs for a nutritious mayo alternative that adds substance to any sandwich.
The mild, slightly nutty flavor provides an excellent canvas for additions like roasted garlic, fresh rosemary, or sun-dried tomatoes. The spreadable consistency works beautifully on hearty breads without making them soggy.
For maximum creaminess, warm the beans slightly before mashing or use a food processor for ultra-smooth results. Try it with roasted vegetables, turkey, or tuna for a Mediterranean-inspired sandwich that’s more satisfying than anything made with mayo.
Leave a comment