Skip to Content

11 Costco Foods You Might Want to Rethink Before Adding to Your Cart

Costco can be a goldmine for tasty and convenient food finds, but not every item is worth grabbing without a bit of consideration. While plenty of products deliver great value and solid quality, some fall short in terms of nutrition, flavor, or overall satisfaction. Here’s a look at 11 Costco food items that warrant a closer look before you decide to add them to your cart.

1. Kirkland Signature Protein Bar

Kirkland Signature Protein Bar
© Costco Wholesale

Have you ever reached for a protein bar, hoping for a quick, healthy snack? Kirkland Signature Protein Bars might catch your eye at Costco. Despite their convenience, they often contain high sugar alcohols, which can upset your stomach.

Additionally, the taste may not satisfy everyone, as some find it too artificial. With options aplenty, consider what suits your taste buds.

The protein bar market offers numerous alternatives, many with cleaner ingredients. So, before you decide, explore other brands that may better align with your dietary preferences.

2. Otis Spunkmeyer Frozen Cookie Dough, Chocolate Chunk

Otis Spunkmeyer Frozen Cookie Dough, Chocolate Chunk
© Easy Lunches

The aroma of freshly baked cookies wafts through your kitchen with Otis Spunkmeyer’s frozen cookie dough, promising a delightful treat. However, these cookies come with a hefty calorie count.

Packed with sugar and fat, overindulgence may lead to unwanted weight gain. While the convenience of pre-made dough is tempting, making cookies from scratch offers healthier control over ingredients.

If you enjoy baking, crafting cookies from scratch allows you to adjust sweetness and ingredients. The joy of baking your own can be just as rewarding and more health-conscious.

3. Pierre Signatures Angus Cheeseburger

Pierre Signatures Angus Cheeseburger
© Costco Business Center

Fast food cravings might lead you to Pierre Signatures Angus Cheeseburgers, available at Costco. They promise an easy-to-make meal, perfect for busy days. But, these pre-packaged delights may not be the healthiest choice.

Loaded with sodium and preservatives, moderation becomes key. The convenience might overshadow the nutritional pitfalls.

Visit your local butcher or make burgers from scratch to better control ingredients. Freshly made burgers can offer a satisfying taste without the extra additives. It’s worth considering a homemade approach for a healthier bite.

4. Kirkland Signature Italian Sausage and Beef Lasagna

Kirkland Signature Italian Sausage and Beef Lasagna
© Costco Business Center

Lasagna lovers may be drawn to Kirkland’s Italian Sausage and Beef Lasagna. Offered in generous portions, it appeals to families seeking a quick dinner solution.

However, think twice due to its high sodium content. Excessive sodium can lead to health issues if consumed regularly. Finding a balance is essential.

Homemade lasagna might take more time but allows for ingredient control. By choosing fresh ingredients, you can craft a dish that aligns with your dietary needs, offering both taste and health benefits.

5. Farm Rich French Toast Sticks

Farm Rich French Toast Sticks
© Harris Teeter

For a quick breakfast fix, Farm Rich French Toast Sticks stand out with their golden hue. Yet, they may not be the morning fuel you need. High in sugar and low in fiber, these sticks might leave you craving more.

Consider the nutritional profile and how it fits with your breakfast goals. Homemade alternatives offer more control over sugar content.

By making French toast from scratch, you can add whole grains and fresh fruits, enhancing both flavor and nutrition. It’s a delicious way to start the day right.

6. Kirkland Supreme Cauliflower Pizza

Kirkland Supreme Cauliflower Pizza
© Costco Business Center

Pizzas come in various forms, and Kirkland’s Supreme Cauliflower Pizza might intrigue the health-conscious. While cauliflower is a trendy alternative to traditional crusts, it’s crucial to examine ingredients.

This pizza includes processed toppings and cheese, potentially negating health benefits. Balance is important, especially if you’re cutting calories or carbs.

Creating your own pizza offers control over toppings and crust. Fresh vegetables and lean proteins can transform a simple dish into a nutritious meal. A homemade approach often results in better taste and health-conscious choices.

7. Kirkland Signature Chicken Bakes

Kirkland Signature Chicken Bakes
© Costco Business Center

Craving a hearty meal? Kirkland Signature Chicken Bakes might tempt you with their savory filling. Yet, their hefty calorie count and high sodium levels are worth considering.

Though convenient, these items are often loaded with preservatives. A balanced diet may suffer if these become a staple.

Exploring homemade options allows ingredient control, promoting a healthier lifestyle. Baking your own can provide the flavors you love without the excess calories and sodium. It’s a satisfying endeavor in both taste and nutrition.

8. Foster Farms Jumbo Chicken Corn Dogs

Foster Farms Jumbo Chicken Corn Dogs
© Foster Farms

Corn dogs evoke memories of fairs and fun, but Foster Farms Jumbo Chicken Corn Dogs come with extra considerations. While offering a nostalgic treat, they’re high in sodium and fat.

As a part of your regular diet, these may not align with health goals. Moderation is crucial. Making corn dogs from scratch lets you experiment with lean meats and reduced-sodium batter.

This way, you enjoy the familiar flavor while maintaining nutritional balance. Homemade options often surprise with both taste and health benefits.

9. Kirkland Signature Plain Cheesecake

Kirkland Signature Plain Cheesecake
© Instacart

Indulging in dessert can be delightful, and Kirkland Signature Plain Cheesecake often catches the eye at Costco. Creamy and rich, it satisfies sweet tooth cravings but packs calories and sugar.

For those mindful of diet, the richness may pose a challenge. Enjoying in moderation is key to balancing pleasure and health.

Baking cheesecake at home allows for creative control, enabling adjustments to sugar content and ingredients. A homemade version might surprise with its taste, offering a guilt-free indulgence.

10. Marie Callender’s Chicken Pot Pies

Marie Callender’s Chicken Pot Pies
© Amazon.com

Comfort food at its best, Marie Callender’s Chicken Pot Pies provide a cozy meal option. However, examine their nutritional content carefully. High in calories and sodium, they may not fit everyone’s dietary plan.

The convenience of a ready-to-bake pie is undeniable, but health-conscious individuals might seek alternatives.

Preparing pot pies at home allows for ingredient selection, reducing excess salt and calories. Personalizing the filling with fresh vegetables and lean meats creates a hearty, nutritious meal. Homemade versions often bring both warmth and balance.

11. David’s Cookies Mile High Peanut Butter Cake

David’s Cookies Mile High Peanut Butter Cake
© Amazon.com

Dessert lovers may find David’s Cookies Mile High Peanut Butter Cake irresistible at Costco. Its towering layers promise a sweet experience, yet its richness might be overwhelming.

High in sugar and fat, moderation becomes essential for those watching their intake. A treat for special occasions, perhaps.

Baking your own cake allows for ingredient tweaks, balancing indulgence with health. Opting for reduced sugar or alternative sweeteners can still result in a luscious dessert. A homemade cake might not reach the same height, but it delivers in taste and satisfaction.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *