Mayonnaise lovers, gather ’round! Whether you’re team creamy classic or all about that avocado oil upgrade, not all mayo is created equal.
Some jars are packed with wholesome goodness and heart-healthy oils, while others are sneaky little tubs of sugar, preservatives, and mystery ingredients.
So how do you separate the sandwich heroes from the salad saboteurs? We asked top dietitians to weigh in and rank the 10 best and 10 worst mayonnaise brands you’ll find in stores today.
From health-forward standouts to ingredient offenders, this list dishes out everything you need to know before you squeeze, scoop, or spread.
1. Hellmann’s Real Mayonnaise
Hellmann’s Real Mayonnaise is often celebrated for its rich, creamy texture and classic flavor. Many find it to be a versatile condiment for everything from sandwiches to salads.
What sets it apart is its commitment to quality ingredients like cage-free eggs, which appeals to those mindful of sustainable practices. Its consistency is smooth and easy to spread, making it a favorite among home cooks.
For those looking for a reliable choice that delivers on taste and ethics, Hellmann’s Real Mayonnaise is often considered a top pick. Its presence in kitchens around the world speaks volumes about its popularity and the trust consumers place in it.
2. Kewpie Mayonnaise
Kewpie Mayonnaise is a darling in the culinary world, adored for its unique umami flavor that enhances dishes with an extra layer of taste. Originating from Japan, it has become a go-to ingredient for chefs and food enthusiasts alike.
Its distinctive tang comes from a blend of rice vinegar and a bit of MSG, giving it a flavor profile that stands out from typical Western mayonnaise. The squeezable bottle with a red cap is not just a packaging choice but a symbol of quality.
For those seeking a mayonnaise that transforms simple dishes into something extraordinary, Kewpie offers a taste adventure worth exploring.
3. Duke’s Mayonnaise
With a heritage rooted in Southern tradition, Duke’s Mayonnaise is beloved for its tangy zip and creamy texture. Its lack of added sugar distinguishes it from many competitors, appealing to those with a preference for savory over sweet.
The brand prides itself on its authentic recipe, unchanged since its creation in 1917 by Eugenia Duke. This commitment to tradition resonates with fans who appreciate its genuine taste.
Whether used in potato salads or spread on a BLT, Duke’s Mayonnaise delivers a taste of the South in every jar, making it a staple in many kitchens.
4. Sir Kensington’s Organic Mayonnaise
Sir Kensington’s Organic Mayonnaise presents itself with an air of sophistication, aligning quality with sustainability. Known for its organic ingredients and free-range eggs, it caters to the environmentally conscious consumer.
Its bold taste, crafted with a hint of citrus, sets it apart from other brands, offering a fresh twist on the classic mayo experience. The brand’s commitment to ethical sourcing makes it a popular choice for those who prioritize both flavor and environmental impact.
For those wanting a gourmet touch in their everyday meals, Sir Kensington’s provides an elegant option that doesn’t compromise on principles.
5. Chosen Foods Avocado Oil Mayonnaise
Chosen Foods Avocado Oil Mayonnaise is a favorite for health-conscious individuals, featuring heart-healthy avocado oil as its primary ingredient. This mayo offers a creamy texture with a subtle hint of lime, providing a refreshing alternative to traditional options.
Free from soy and canola oils, it’s an appealing choice for those with dietary restrictions or preferences for cleaner ingredients. Its versatility makes it suitable for a variety of dishes, from salads to sandwiches.
For those seeking a mayonnaise that aligns with a health-focused lifestyle, Chosen Foods offers a delicious, nutritious choice that doesn’t sacrifice on taste.
6. Primal Kitchen Avocado Oil Mayonnaise
Primal Kitchen Avocado Oil Mayonnaise is a beloved staple for anyone following a paleo or keto diet. Made with simple ingredients like avocado oil, cage-free eggs, and vinegar, it avoids unnecessary additives.
The brand emphasizes its commitment to healthy eating, offering a mayonnaise that’s free from sugar, gluten, and soy. Its creamy texture and clean flavor make it a versatile addition to various culinary creations.
For those who prioritize health without compromising on flavor, Primal Kitchen offers a product that satisfies both dietary needs and taste buds, making it a pantry essential.
7. Blue Plate Mayonnaise
Blue Plate Mayonnaise, a Southern classic, is cherished for its rich, creamy consistency and slight tang. Originating in New Orleans, it captures the essence of Southern cooking in a jar.
This mayonnaise is often a go-to choice for those who appreciate a touch of nostalgia in their food, as it has been a part of family recipes for generations. Its loyal fan base swears by its smooth texture and balanced flavor.
Ideal for enhancing the taste of sandwiches, coleslaw, or seafood dishes, Blue Plate Mayonnaise brings a taste of tradition and quality to the table.
8. Just Mayo
Just Mayo presents itself as a modern twist on the traditional mayonnaise, offering a vegan-friendly option that doesn’t compromise on taste. Made without eggs, it appeals to those seeking plant-based alternatives.
Its creamy consistency and rich flavor have won over many who were initially skeptical about egg-free mayonnaise. The brand prides itself on using sustainable and non-GMO ingredients, aligning with values of health and environmental consciousness.
For those in pursuit of a kinder, greener culinary choice, Just Mayo delivers a delectable experience that stands up to its egg-based counterparts.
9. Best Foods Real Mayonnaise
Best Foods Real Mayonnaise is synonymous with tradition, offering a reliable taste that has satisfied generations. Known for its creamy texture and rich flavor, it’s a staple in many homes.
The brand’s dedication to quality ingredients, like cage-free eggs and responsibly sourced oils, reflects its commitment to both taste and ethical practices. This mayonnaise is versatile, perfect for enhancing salads, sandwiches, and spreads.
For those who value consistency and a trusted name, Best Foods continues to be a preferred choice, delivering the familiar taste that many have grown up loving.
10. Trader Joe’s Organic Mayonnaise
Trader Joe’s Organic Mayonnaise embodies the brand’s commitment to quality and value, offering a tasty option for those seeking organic ingredients. Made with cage-free eggs and organic oils, it appeals to the health-conscious shopper.
The mayonnaise’s creamy texture and subtly sweet flavor enhance a variety of dishes, from sandwiches to salads. Its affordability paired with its organic credentials makes it a popular pick among savvy consumers.
For those looking for a budget-friendly organic option without sacrificing taste, Trader Joe’s delivers a mayonnaise that’s both delicious and ethically created.
11. Miracle Whip
Miracle Whip has been a household name for decades, known for its distinctive tangy-sweet flavor. Unlike traditional mayonnaise, it includes additional spices and flavors that offer a unique twist.
This dressing often divides opinions; some love its bold taste, while others prefer a more classic mayo experience. Despite its polarizing presence, it remains a popular choice for adding zest to sandwiches and salads.
For those who enjoy a different take on the typical mayonnaise, Miracle Whip provides a flavorful journey that sparks both nostalgia and curiosity.
12. Kraft Mayo
Kraft Mayo is a staple in many kitchens, known for its creamy texture and balanced flavor. It’s a versatile option, fitting seamlessly into a variety of dishes.
While it may not stand out in the same way as some artisanal brands, its reliability makes it a popular choice for everyday use. The brand has a strong presence in the market, trusted by those who favor traditional taste.
For those seeking a no-fuss mayonnaise that’s both affordable and dependable, Kraft Mayo remains a go-to, supporting countless meals with its familiar flavor profile.
13. Great Value Mayonnaise
Great Value Mayonnaise offers a budget-friendly option for those who prioritize cost over premium ingredients. Its creamy texture and mild flavor provide a basic but satisfying addition to meals.
While it may not boast the organic labels or artisanal touches of other brands, it serves as a practical choice for everyday use. Its affordability makes it accessible to a wide range of consumers.
For those looking for an economical mayonnaise without any frills, Great Value delivers a reliable product that caters to basic culinary needs.
14. Spectrum Organic Mayonnaise
Spectrum Organic Mayonnaise appeals to those who value organic, non-GMO ingredients. Made with organic eggs and expeller-pressed oil, it offers a clean, wholesome taste.
The mayonnaise’s smooth consistency and subtle flavor make it a pleasant addition to various dishes, from sandwiches to dressings. Its organic credentials resonate with consumers who prioritize health and sustainability.
For those seeking a mayonnaise that aligns with a natural lifestyle, Spectrum provides a product that combines quality and ethics, meeting the demands of the conscientious eater.
15. Hampton Creek Just Mayo
Hampton Creek Just Mayo has garnered attention for its innovative approach to traditional mayonnaise. Offering a plant-based alternative, it’s designed for vegans and those seeking sustainable options.
Its rich, creamy texture and well-balanced flavor have won over many who might otherwise miss the taste of egg-based mayo. The brand’s focus on using non-GMO and sustainable ingredients appeals to eco-conscious consumers.
For those in search of a compassionate, delicious alternative to regular mayonnaise, Hampton Creek Just Mayo offers a satisfying option that doesn’t skimp on taste or ethics.
16. Whole Foods 365 Mayonnaise
Whole Foods 365 Mayonnaise represents the brand’s commitment to quality and transparency. Made with cage-free eggs and non-GMO oils, it offers a wholesome choice for consumers.
Its smooth, creamy consistency and clean flavor make it a versatile partner for various culinary creations. The focus on responsible sourcing aligns with the values of Whole Foods shoppers.
For those seeking a mayonnaise that emphasizes quality ingredients and ethical practices, Whole Foods 365 delivers a product that satisfies both the palate and the conscience.
17. Bramwells Mayonnaise
Bramwells Mayonnaise offers a straightforward, no-nonsense option for those seeking value and taste. Its creamy texture and subtle tang make it a reliable choice for everyday meals.
While it may not boast the premium credentials of some competitors, it serves its purpose well, providing a basic yet satisfying flavor profile. It’s often favored by those looking for affordability without sacrificing taste.
For consumers seeking a cost-effective mayonnaise that doesn’t compromise on quality, Bramwells provides a practical solution for various culinary needs.
18. Heinz Seriously Good Mayonnaise
Heinz Seriously Good Mayonnaise lives up to its name with a rich, creamy consistency that’s hard to resist. The brand’s dedication to quality ingredients ensures a satisfying taste experience.
Its smooth texture and balanced flavor make it a favorite for enhancing sandwiches, salads, and beyond. Heinz’s reputation for quality is evident in every jar, making it a trusted choice for many households.
For those in pursuit of a dependable, delicious mayonnaise, Heinz provides a seriously good option that stands out in the crowded condiment aisle.
19. Lidl Batts Mayonnaise
Lidl Batts Mayonnaise offers an affordable option with a taste that rivals pricier brands. Known for its creamy texture and mild flavor, it’s a versatile addition to many dishes.
While it may not boast organic or artisanal labels, its cost-effectiveness makes it a popular choice for budget-conscious shoppers. Its reliability has earned it a loyal following.
For those seeking value without compromising on taste, Lidl Batts provides a mayonnaise that’s both economical and enjoyable, supporting a wide array of culinary creations.
20. Cains Mayonnaise
Cains Mayonnaise is a beloved classic in the Northeastern United States, known for its rich, creamy texture and robust flavor. It’s a staple in many traditional recipes, cherished for its consistency.
The brand’s heritage and dedication to quality have earned it a place in the hearts of many who grew up with it in their kitchens. Its distinctive taste is a testament to its enduring appeal.
For those looking for a mayonnaise with history and heart, Cains offers a timeless option that’s been trusted for generations, enhancing dishes with its unique character.
Leave a comment